3 Reasons to Kill The Dept. of Homeland Security: It's Unnecessary, Inefficient, & Expensive.





The interactive transcript could not be loaded.



Rating is available when the video has been rented.
This feature is not available right now. Please try again later.
Published on Nov 23, 2012

Go to http://reason.com/reasontv/2012/11/23... for links and documentation to all claims - and for more videos!

Sunday, November 25, 2012 marks the 10th anniversary of the creation of the Department of Homeland Security (DHS), which pulled together nearly two dozen federal agencies and departments under the control of new, single entity. Its responsibilities include running the US Border Patrol, the Plum Island Animal Disease Center, and FEMA.

DHS is the third biggest cabinet agency, but are we better off because of its existence?

Here are three reasons to get rid of DHS.

1. It's unnecessary. In the months immediately following September 11 attacks in 2001, President George W. Bush initially resisted calls to create a new high-level bureaucracy that would be laid on top of current activities. He was right to recognize that coordinating existing agencies would have been smarter and better. Unfortunately, he caved in to pressure to create a massive new department.

2. It's ineffective. To read the titles of Government Accountability Office (GAO) analyses of Homeland Security is to be reminded constantly that DHS is never quite on top of its game. Recent reports include "DHS Requires More Disciplined Investment Management to Help Meet Mission Needs," "DHS Needs Better Project Information and Coordination Among Four Overlapping Grant Programs," and "Agriculture Inspection Program Has Made Some Improvements, But Management Challenges Persist."

3. It's expensive. Last year, Homeland Security spent a whopping $60 billion, a figure that will doubtlessly increase in coming years. The construction of its new headquarters -- the single-largest projectever undertaken by The General Services Administration -- will cost at least $4 billion and is already years behind on schedule since breaking ground in 2009.

Since it's the holiday season, here's a bonus reason to get rid of the Department of Homeland Security: It also runs the Transportation Security Administration, whose nasty reputation for manhandling innocent travelers is only slightly more annoying than its massive and undeserved growth in personnel and cost over the past decade.

About 2.30 minutes.

Produced by Meredith Bragg and Nick Gillespie, who also narrates.

Go to http://reason.com/reasontv/2012/11/23... for links and documentation to all claims - and for more videos!


Uploads from ReasonTV

  1. 687

    A Great Year For Pot, Freedom, and Ending the Drug War: Q&A with MPP's Rob Kampia

  2. 688

    Marijuana Is Legal in Colorado...Now What?

  3. 689

    Why Copyright Law is so Mickey Mouse - And How to Fix It: Q&A with Jerry Brito

  4. 690

    Judge Napolitano: How Teddy Roosevelt and Woodrow Wilson Destroyed Constitutional Freedom

  5. 691

    Can an Undocumented Immigrant Become a U.S. Lawyer? California High Court Will Decide

  6. 692

    How Dewey Bartlett Balanced Tulsa's Budget without Raising Taxes

  7. 693

    James Payne on Six Political Illusions

  8. 694

    Indianapolis Mayor Greg Ballard: Making City Government Work

  9. 695

    Guns, Football, Macho Culture Didn't Kill Jovan Belcher's Girlfriend. Jovan Belcher Did.

  10. 696

    Censorship and "Unlearning Liberty" at College: Q&A with FIRE's Greg Lukianoff

  11. 697

    Reason Webathon 2012 w Nick Gillespie, Matt Welch, Kennedy, and more!

  12. 698

    Meet Congress' Favorite Bootlegger: Prohibition, Hypocrisy, and "The Man in the Green Hat"

  13. 699

    Reason Mag Preview w Matt Welch & Kennedy: APOCALYPSE 2013!

  14. 700

    "I escaped a North Korean prison camp" - Shin Dong-hyuk's Survivor Story

  15. 701

    LP Candidate Bruce Majors vs. D.C.'s One-Party System

  16. 702

    Texas Schools Track Students with RFID Chips! (Nanny of the Month, Nov '12)

  17. 703

    1000 Wrongfully Convicted and Counting: New Registry Checks Justice System's Power

  18. 704

    "The idea that you could openly sell things that help women achieve orgasm is pretty new."

  19. 705

    David Friedman on How to Privatize Everything

  20. 706

    The Future of Financing the Arts: An Interview with Adam Huttler of Fractured Atlas

  21. 707

    Fixing Chicago's Traffic Gridlock: Reason's Adrian Moore and Sam Staley

  22. 708

    Greg Gutfeld: The Joy of Hate, Liberal Speech Police, & Conservative Punks

  23. 3 Reasons to Kill The Dept. of Homeland Security: It's Unnecessary, Inefficient, & Expensive.

  24. 710

    Philadelphia: No Love for the Homeless

  25. 711

    Roderick Long on Race, Gender, Equality and Libertarianism

  26. 712

    Athens of the Prairie: How Columbus, Indiana Got Great Architecture

  27. 713

    Lance Armstrong Cheated to Win. Is that Wrong?

  28. 714

    Media Manipulation and Unconventional Marketing: Author Ryan Holiday on "Trust Me I'm Lying"

  29. 715

    Watch Ron Paul's Farewell Address!

  30. 716

    Oklahoma Doctors vs. Obamacare

  31. 717

    Ladies, We're Screwed: Why Obama's Re-election is Bad for Choice

  32. 718

    Gary Johnson, Benghazi, and Free Speech: Reason's December Ish!

  33. 719

    What Writer Most Turned You on to Freedom? Or, What We Heard at Reason's Bastiat Prize Dinner.

  34. 720

    One Veteran's Story: "You Come Back And You Just Don't Feel The Same."

  35. 721

    Khan Academy Founder Talks Radical Education Reform and The One World Schoolhouse

  36. 722

    The Fallacy of Net Neutrality: Thomas Hazlett on the FCC & Consumer Protection

  37. 723

    3 Reasons Mitt Romney and Republicans Lost Big in Election 2012

  38. 724

    Obama Wins and Nothing Changes; The Wildly Unpopular Status Quo Is Ratified!

  39. 725

    Bronco Bama and Mitt Romney Aren't the Only Things to Cry Over

  40. 726

    Remy: Romney, Obama, and Binders Full of Chicks (The Election 2012 Rap)

  41. 727

    The Anti-Science Left: Author Alex Berezow on Why Both Parties Fail at Science

  42. 728

    Gas Lines, Gouging, and Hurricane Sandy: Keeping Prices Low Means Nobody Gets Fuel

  43. 729

    Q&A with Libertarian Vice Presidential Candidate Jim Gray

  44. 730

    LA to Pet Stores: You Can't Sell Animals Unless They're Rescued (Nanny of the Month, Oct. '12)

  45. 731

    Three Reasons U.S. Drone Policy Is Really Freakin' Scary

  46. 732

    Crowded Prisons, Unions, and CA Three Strikes: Why We Can't Just Build More Cages

  47. 733

    Eugene Jarecki on His Drug-War Doc The House I Live In and Why Prohibition is Doomed

  48. 734

    "I Pledge to Serve Barack Obama" (Urgent 2012 Election Update)

  49. 735

    Condoms, Porn, and L.A.'s Measure B: The Most Bizarre Ballot Initiative of 2012

  50. 736

    Tom Bevan Talks Real Clear Politics and Election Polling

  51. 737

    Steve Chapman on Election 2012, Chicago and Pot Smoking Presidents

  52. 738

    Liberty Fund's Chris Talley on Freedom, Dialogue, and Ama-gi Tattoos

  53. 739

    The Knockoff Economy: How Copying Benefits Everyone

  54. 740

    Hayek Institute's Barbara Kolm on the Eurozone Crisis

  55. 741

    Why Expanding America's Military Strength Puts The U.S. at Risk

  56. 742

    Reason-Rupe Poll on Fixing California, Prop 30 and Rolling Back State Spending

  57. 743

    Do the Cops Know Your Info? A Conversation with the ACLU of Illinois's Adam Schwartz

  58. 744

    Are We In the Final Days of Marijuana Prohibition?

  59. 745

    Capitalist Pig on Why Hedge Funds and Ayn Rand are Great for the Economy

  60. 746

    How Romney and Republicans Can Appeal to Libertarians

  61. 747

    How Obama and Democrats Can Appeal to Libertarians

  62. 748

    The Exonerated: True Stories of Innocents Sprung From Death Row

  63. 749

    Short Skirts and Bear Markets: An Interview with Stock Market Analyst Robert Prechter

  64. 750

    Damon Root on 3 Supreme Court Cases to Watch in 2013

  65. 751

    Journalist Andrew Malcolm on Embracing New Media

  66. 752

    John Goodman on Curing the Health Care Crisis

  67. 753

    Russ Roberts: Why Keynesians Always Get it Wrong (and Most Economists Too)

  68. 754

    Ai WeiWei, Pussy Riot and the Power of Punk Art: An Interview with James Panero

  69. 755

    Marginal Revolution University: Q&A with Alex Tabarrok

  70. 756

    The Cast of Atlas Shrugged Part II Talks Film's Impact

  71. 757

    Really Good Reasons to Skip College: Q&A with Blake Boles

  72. 758

    Freedomain Radio's Stefan Molyneux on the Inevitable Growth of the State

  73. 759

    Helicopter Parents vs. Free Range Kids: Q&A with "America's Worst Mom" Lenore Skenazy

  74. 760

    Why U.S. Health Care Costs More Than Canada's: "A Mercedes Costs More than a Corolla"

  75. 761

    After Debate Hangout

  76. 762

    Citizenship Denied: DOMA, Immigration, and Gay Marriage

  77. 763

    Atlas Shrugged Part II: What We Saw at the World Premiere in D.C.

  78. 764

    Reason-Rupe Poll: Obama Leads Romney, 52-45 Percent; Gary Johnson Pulls 6 Percent

  79. 765

    Obama vs Romney: Special Interactive Nanny of the Month!

  80. 766

    Wall Street Journal's Stephen Moore on the 2012 Election

  81. 767

    Too Big To Regulate: Barron's Gene Epstein on Dodd-Frank

  82. 768

    Wake the F*ck Up! - A Rebuttal (NSFW!)

  83. 769

    Steve Horwitz on Austrian Economics, Bleeding Heart Libertarians, and Family

  84. 770

    Rachel Carson's Silent Spring at 50 Years

  85. 771

    Immigrants DREAM on: Neither Obama nor Romney will help you

  86. 772

    Remy: Imagine (There's No YouTube)

  87. 773

    Boob Over Bottle: Mike Bloomberg's Latest Nanny State Dictate

  88. 774

    David Simon on Treme, New Orleans, the Drug War, Obama, The Wire - And Disappointing Libertarians

  89. 775

    Why Your Vote Doesn't Count, Obama's Failed Narrative, Four More Years of War

  90. 776

    What We Saw at the Occupy Anniversary Protest in NYC

  91. 777

    It's Time to Legalize Hemp! Q&A with CEO of Dr. Bronner's Magic Soaps

  92. 778

    Angelenos Block Ban on Medical Marijuana Dispensaries...For Now

  93. 779

    Buckyballs vs The Consumer Products Safety Commission

  94. 780

    Internet Freedom and Authoritarianism: Author Rebecca MacKinnon on Consent of the Networked

  95. 781

    Alan Charles Kors on Campus Speech Codes, Libertarianism, & The Case for the Humanities

  96. 782

    NY's 9/11 Memorial: When Did Honoring the Dead Become an Occassion for Fleecing the Living?

  97. 783

    Michael Moynihan on the Politics of Travel Guides

  98. 784

    Occupy vs. DNC: Are Dems Crony Capitalists?

  99. 785

    Recalled Gov. Gray Davis: Public-Sector Unions "Can't Overtax the System"

to add this to Watch Later

Add to