 Welcome to Toffy TV. This video is brought to you in association with One Football's app. One Football's app is a free app. You can download straight onto your phone and get all the latest transfer rumours from around the world, all the transfer stories as they break. They also, on the app, you get the latest scores, the latest stats for all of the games as well. So download it. It's brilliant. I've got it on my phone. One Football have done some videos with us. Absolutely brilliant app. And the best thing about it, I guess, is that you can have a direct feed to the club, to your club. So obviously, Everton is on mine and will be probably for the majority of people watching this. And you get all the latest evidence, rumours, the stories, the breaking stuff, all on it. There's videos, Everton videos as well. So just go and download the app. The link is in the description. It's well worth it. It's a great app. And go and do it now, because why wouldn't you? Why wouldn't you? So we thought we'd have a little chat about the players leaving and the players who are staying. What kind of features they have at Everton Football Club, if any. Let's start with the players who have left the club. And first of all, I want to start with Luke Garbert, right? Because we've seen Carlos Press Conference, right? And I do genuinely feel sorry for the lad, because the lad signed when he was 16 years of age from Leeds. Anyone who remembers at the time, there was a lot of issues with the signing. Leeds, I think it was Ken Bates, wasn't he? So he said he would never ever deal with Everton. And funny enough, that may have led to us not signing Fabian Delph the first time. There was a lot of talk of that when he went to Villa, that it was because of that. Luke Garbert, obviously, was a young lad, great left foot, worked his way through the traditional channels of coming into the first team. And he broke into the team. Well, I said he broke into the squad, sorry, went around, you know, Martin is his first season, second season, you know, started to look, started to look like he could be the successor to Leighton Baines long term. Played a couple of games, certainly the Wolfs Bay game away where he was brilliant that night, set piece delivery was fantastic. But I always remember the next game against Spades, he was left out. And that was sort of like the way it was for him. The next summer, he was given a five year contract, the one that has ended today. And he was sent on loan to full, where he broke his leg. Now, this is where I feel genuinely sorry for Leighton, because I think he had talent, I think he had something about him. But I think he was mismanaged by Roberto Martinis. And he has never, ever fulfilled his potential. I don't know if he was ever given a correct career pathway. I don't know. Some of it, of course, is down to the player. I think the players maybe somewhere has fallen out of love with football because it's, it's, he's been getting paid money and he's not really, not really that bothered. He's gone on loans, etc. But you know, what do you thought on this player is now leaving? He's now, what, 27? 27 years right. Qualified for the testimonial. Been at 11 years. Yeah. Disappointed the way it went. Yeah. Because you write that at one time, it looked like he would become a first team regular. I think the issue we had was that Baines was still playing brilliantly. Baines was only, I think 29 or something when he first got 29, 30, but was still absolutely brilliant. I mean, Baines is still in the first team. Well, first team squad now. So that shows you how good Baines has been. So I think there was no real, you're looking at 29, remembering how good Baines was. No matter how good Garba was, he wasn't out on Baines. No. But he should have been someone who was used within the squad, whether that was as a left side of my field player at times. It's not like Everton of Dump. You know, we've had amazing players on the left. Peanart was our best. And he was, that was around the time Peanart was picking up injuries anyway. If you remember rightly, you know, we, Martinis, really, Martinis cocked them up. Really. There's no question about it. You know, he's done that for quite a few players, but Garba. I mean, the big thing I've seen, talking about this actually today saying maybe believed a little bit of the hype of Barham at the time, there was talks, well Liverpool wanted them, really wanted them when we were going, when we were trying to get them to reshine a five year deal as he was coming to the end. I believe they've had no guarantee they got in Liverpool at that time either, but Brendan Rodgers really liked them. And, you know, we offered them a deal to stave off a couple of other clubs as well. We give them a big contract, but he was planning to go to, there was a deal in place for him to join Bournemouth, who had just been promoted. And I think that would have been a great deal for him. I think it would have been a good sign for him. Eddie Howe, where they play football and stuff. But what happened was they got off a tyre on Mings and decided to go permanent with Mings because obviously rather than just take a lone player. And once they paid, I'm sure they paid something like eight million for Mings, who was now a centre back. They took that, they took him instead. And that kind of left Garbot up in the air. And it was mad anyway because he went to Fulham, but Mings got injured and done his cruciating immediately or got an injury and was out anyway for the season or for a long period. Garbot went to Fulham and got an injury and was out for the season after a few games. So that from then on is because he has only gone one way and the lone Mings haven't worked out. The biggest indicator for me, the biggest disappointment, if you like, with Garbot since that thing was when Allardyce was here, Everett never registered in them as a left back. And we ended up playing Cucamarty. It was in the first half of the season wasn't it, when the Cooman, we never registered. Cooman, sorry, it was different. It could have played in Europe as a back-up to Baines. And then Baines gets injured in the November. He's not registered to play. Felt Anton, so Cucamarty and it comes in. Baines missed most of the season. Maybe he came back on February didn't he? For March, yeah. He misses most of the season. Cucamarty is playing left back and is not very good. And yet there's a kid there who's doing nothing kicking his heels and wasn't even giving a chance. And I understand that at the time people were saying, oh he's not clearly not good enough, people don't think he's good enough. So not even have that back-up, not even have that insurance policy of, well he's the only other left back we've got on the books because he was. Oviadaw had left at that point. And I think that's again, short sighting the stuff, the club didn't not go, you know, there's a kid there on X amount of money with X amount of years left on his contract, just throw him in the squad and see what happens when you've got other players who have registered to play, you're absolutely garbage. To me, he should have been put in in January into the squad. Okay, we can't do anything about the fact that he didn't, you know, cumin, that, I mean that summer we bought 107 number 10s. So, you know, and they quite clearly took up the 25 man squad. But it was in that January when Marty, you know, he'd done his best, but he wasn't very good. And you need someone not to left foot and garbage, I think at that time, I remember rightly was playing in the 23s and banging free kicks in and doing 100s said he's doing really well. And we would have, it would have give us some balance on that left. And that would have been the moment of the early time. And once that came and went, it was over then. It was over. And I think he went to Oxford and he'd done wealth. They really liked them. And then obviously he's been a Ripswitch and they really like him and he's done well. But 27, you know, his career's been, he'd say ruined by heaven really the way it's worked out. He's got a part of play as well, of course, but 27 contracts. I look at Marty Pennington at Hull, who's 24 or 25 or something or 23, 24. And you think, it's another lad who needs to just get away and get his career going because the shit went on for too long. Like, you know, your only potential for a little bit on you. Going back to the Bainswick thing now, what I would say is, what makes me laugh most about this is that Martin is in his whole spiel about, you know, I've took, I took Bainswick to watch Philip Lampley, you know, an old traffic into Man United because I want to, because I want to move him inside. And then, but then add this kid. Now he might have said, in the end, I don't think this kid's good enough to replace him. But it was the whole thing of, oh, I'm going to move him inside. And that's what, that's what made me laugh, because I think Gabor, did Gabor play both legs against Wolfsburg? And he was good in both of them. And he had something. And I'm sure he played against Lyle at home on set the goal. His set pieces were brilliant. And I remember people saying at the time, he's like a, like a mini Bains. He's a replace one for Bains. And you just think of things have gone slightly different. I know, listen, I don't think he was a great defender by any set of the imagination. That's why I had to play them ahead. I think he was good going forward and I think he was good to set pieces. But I think, like we just said, it's the plan. The plan just wasn't there for him. And yeah, I just think he could have worked together and Bains, who was starting to pick up the odd injury, dislike could have come in for him. And as you said, oh, they could have moved him in front of him or Bains could have played even tried a couple of games to centre my field. Then you'd have a genuine left back. You might have won that. That could be a back up to Luke. If he'd been in the squad, if Bains goes, if Bains doesn't sign the 12 month contract extension and the longer it goes on, the more you worry that it's not going to happen. Evan, they're going to be left with that a left back. There you go. So Luke garbage. But he's put good luck to Luke wherever he comes. Sure, he'll have offers because he's done well at it, which they want to keep him. The other two players, Cucamarty, who is the, you can say lad. Where's player I've ever seen player and I've seen a lot of bad ever players for me. And I know people will, will object to that because he was out of position, but I'm taking him on what I witnessed out of position. Even when he played right back, he wasn't very good. Let's be honest, but left back, he was horrific. He shouldn't be a professional footballer that can't use both feet. I'm sorry. You shouldn't be having to turn back when you get the ball. And there was so many games that we struggled in because when we'd give him the ball on a quick break, he'd start and turn on a passive back and he just wasn't very good. Not saying he didn't train hard and I'm not saying any. But another one, he got three years from Ronald Cumin. I don't know what's going on there, but he's given three years and obviously he went a fine odd on loan didn't he? Looked like that could have been his house. So like that he was going to. And I know he's been on the bench a little bit recently with the seven subs and it's been nice, I'm sorry. But now awful, awful signing, awful player. Bye. That's not what he said. No, he can't. He was, he was, he was, he was, you know what, right? The player can't help being what he is, but the manager can help signing him and for some reason. And I just remember that the sign, Southampton fan, just laughing, just laughing at how bad he was and that they were getting rid of him. And he was like, lived off that goal against Arsenal. Was a good goal. He was a good goal, but he was terrible. And the other one that's left today is Oomanias. The Prince. The sweet, sweet Prince has finally left. Again, what can you say? This is a player who rebate Oomanias signed him instead of signing some other quality players. And it's just baffling that we paid $13.5 million for a player who was playing in the Russian League. That was basically to give him play the year by some lad in his bedroom doing an online poll. And yet Roberto twisted it into he'd won the Russian play of the year, which he never did. Never. There was a load of nonsense. I don't even know where Roberto Manna got that from. But it was a load of nonsense. He'd seen the poll, hadn't he? He'd won some kind of a word. But it was probably like a... That's quite a ball. Yeah, but there you go. So they obviously hate that, didn't they? I mean, we spoke to people at the time and they said that Martinis was basically told not to sign him by all the scout reports and went against it. The biggest thing for me is obviously we had the opportunity to sign Muesha Denbilly for $5 million on the same day. And we signed Oomanias instead, which for $8.5 million more when Denbilly's worth $45 million playing for Leon in the Champions League. So that was a ridiculous sign. And I guess the... I guess the red flags were all over the gaff, Eilion. We signed them, rushed them through. Well, God, it done. We had Stoke away on the setty. He wasn't in the squad. And then we introduced them against Newcastle and he jogged around the pitch. Or he'd already been introduced into Newcastle, hadn't he, sorry? Jogged around the pitch with his jeans on. Didn't make the Stoke squad. And then there was all reports that he's injured and now he's got this wrist injury. The wrist injury. One of the worst injuries you can get him for. It is one of the worst injuries. And then obviously he'd come on with the likes of Bournemouth in the FA Cup for 10 minutes. He'd come on a filler. He'd come on against Westam at home. So it just didn't... The man who's bought you doesn't seem to have any faith in you. There's an issue, isn't it? I mean, the Westam game was just amazing. You know, we know what happened in 2-0 up, ended up losing 3-2. But that was the day I just came on. Where was he for the FA Cup semi-fine against United? Was he on a bench? What was he injured? I've no idea. I'm trying to think as he didn't come on, did he? But for that game, certainly, the manager brought them on. And I've never, ever witnessed this before in a football match. I generally haven't. A player run on the pitch and not have one idea what he was supposed to do. Not one idea. And not even... I've seen players run on the pitch and not have an idea, but then create something that they can do. Like, maybe they've run on and not understood the manager's instructions or whatever. So they just do what's natural to them, which is to just find the position and just play in it. And maybe he goes against what the manager wants. Moise Keane had all suffered. But they try and do something where he run on the pitch and he run into the places where the ball never, ever was. Like, it was unbelievable. And it was the fact that we brought them on. And we were down to ten men. And we were down to nine men. And we ended up losing the game. And he was hopeless. Absolutely hopeless. Mor i siwd o ddod na ddeu trwch ar yn Lennanolf, who'd kept Creswell in his own half. And we were comfortable. And so when he brought him on that day, siwd o trwch y cael chi roedd. If you were bringing a striker on, when you're only playing one up front and you're trying to hang on, you bring a striker on for a striker. If you want to put a striker on and go, listen, go up there, stand between them two centre backs, chase everything, don't give them a second. That's the only instruction you need. Putting them on. I don't know where he was supposed to play. He was awful. And you know what though? I don't play him in for that. It's the manager who's doing it because he got put on in a position where the manager knew where he wants them to play. He wants them to play right wing. Why are you putting them on? I think it was just a chance to just get them on the pitch. And he did something same. He did it at Villa as well. Remember the Villa game? Yeah, we were three and a lot. And then he put them on and they scored and they nearly scored again. And it was almost like, and again he didn't have a clue. And it was just like I'll bring them on when we're winning games just to get them on. I mean that was the bad side. He did obviously then come in and come in and bombed them. Made the decision after a couple of days of training that he would never play. He wasn't going to be in his options. And he was bombed out, obviously. He went out. He obviously ended up playing for the 23s and done well for others. He scored a lot of goals. And he went off to Hull and didn't score against Liverpool. He was one of the greatest internet thing. No, I don't know much. He beat them three one. He scored, didn't he? But he beat them three one in the league up, didn't he? Byr ydydd wedi ddiddorol. Ar old Trafford, he beat obviously scored against Liverpool and we showed the red men the greatest internet sensation. And he had a good end to the season. He went back off silver for me enough. And then obviously the next summer Cumin still bombed them up but ended up having to play him because he couldn't get a striker. And for a few games he done well for us. He scored against Sunder and scored. He went through against Bournemouth which won us the game. We were one little down. Scored a palace and then he was ended up getting through no faults of his own. Rarely got suspended for two games because for a dive that wasn't a dive. The referee even come out and said I've seen it again. It was a penalty. And we were gutted he was out because he had just had a little bit of a run and it was like he's all right. He scored. He came on against Waffa, didn't he? Didn't he come on against Waffa when we were two nil barn? He was running around like a lunatic. He scored that goal against Arsenal when we were going to be five two as well. And he had that like he didn't have a clue what he was doing but he had like a never say die attitude almost to things even though he didn't have a clue what he was doing. And you're right when he got suspended he was like oh he's been in good form and then. Well on his way it was in charge then wasn't he? Obviously he got the goal against Arsenal. Much, you know, the trip against Bournemouth Cumin wasn't happy that he'd scored because he made him look a bit stupid. And then obviously he had a couple of things then Cumin was shocked he scored the last goal of Cumin's reign which was ironic there he wasn't against Arsenal. And then on his way it took over and obviously on his way he knew him because he'd had them in the 23s and Tom Davis was fine them and all that. He was all right for a few games and you're right he scored a very important goal in that the 3-2 which was a massive win if you remember. I mean that we should have had a suppose someone and said he was like oh Sildadeir, two and a lot of cruising. He got some important goals and he did and then he got the suspension that we didn't need it. He got it the wrong time. Barre time the suspension was up, all the dice was in charge. And then. And we'd won two games. And we won a couple of games so he was sub again wasn't he and he was back out there and Tom Cumin was doing very well. But he still ended up getting a few goals in the second half of the season and I remember he'd come on for Troxon against West Brommer home and scored within about 30 seconds or something. I think he scored, he got one on the last day of the season down at Westam which was a good goal as well to be fair. So he's got something Nias. He's got, he's some kind of threat. Cos he's so random. Cos he's random. He's a bit like a crapper face in the parlor one shop is that you just don't know what he's going to do and he runs around. He ended up with nine goals in 39 games. He played 39 games in four and a half years. Yeah okay. So you know he's got like a one and four. Just over. Nobody listen. When we needed him he was there and that's the way it is. He's not going to go down as one to great standards. I look at the managers you buy them, not necessarily the... You know what makes me laugh is when people still and everyone's entitled to their own opinion. Everyone sees it differently and this is just my opinion but when people say I think we should have given that and it's a bit longer and you look at Adam McGeady. You know you look at what he did to John Stones, turned him from being a good like a whole gate now into being this kid that thought he could do whatever he wanted and there's never he covered from it. You know he was even playing for the one of the best managers in the world and he still hasn't recovered from it. That bit of that might be on stones to get that as well. You know but them kind of plays but Samietta in and tried to play and he was a left winger. You know he was falling out with Delphae. Delphae fall now. No listen. But they think we sort of saw them. Fywn as Morrie instead of Van Dijk. Just don't. No one out. They are the choicers though. They are the Van Dijk. Once you come to Everton I want to come and want to join 11 million quid. I'll buy this fella from Ardintein that's never played it for 9.5 million instead. It's almost like something is going on. And we had to pay 800 grand on top of that to get the other kid. He was waltzed out of the early Andrew Rodríguez. So combined it was. I think we saw this season when he came on against Newcastle when we were cruising in the game and I think you know him. The woman he broke in the onwre. He needed to chase it and fell over. He just went into the corner with it and just even and the game was over. There you got the golf run. No I know because he threw himself in and no. Listen. Not a very good footballer. He'll probably go to take you now. He's made. What makes it worse is all these players have made like a lot of money offers and that's what makes it even worse. So yeah there you go. That again though that's not his fault. It's not his fault. You offer these people. I think to be fair to you am anni arni, he's always given 100% forever. Oh always. 100% no great 100% 100%. He's given everything. It's not that. The same with a goodtimer team that can sit here and go you know what he got on he walked around. He didn't care. He just wasn't up to a level but he wouldn't accuse them of being unprofesional or anything like that. Right, let's talk about three players who's still at the club and have still got contracts whose Ie ddod i'n mynd i'r gweithio i'r gyfnodd. Mae'r bethau, eich ddod i'u gwneud o'r ddylygiadau yng Nghymru o'r Llywodraeth, gyda'n mynd i'r bobl hwn, o'r oed. Rwyf yn y bwysig o'r cyfrydd o'r ddod i'r hwn. Mae'n bwysig o'r cyfrydd, mae'n bwysig i'n cwm yn ei fod yn ei ddod, ac mae'r bwysig o'r ffordd o'i ddod i'r rai hwn. Dwi'n gwybod, dwi'n gwybod eich bod gwaith eich gweithio, I think I'd play him alongside Gomez, he'd certainly have a goa thing cos I think it's the state of arm that's feeling Tom is struggling so and Sigarton is gilfy Sigarton, I think Bessarty'd get a little bit of a goa at the minute but then in the summer when everything is equal he's another one he's been here and we signed him in 2014 after a well cuff, he signed an extension didn't he got offered an improved contract because against Martinis but he did have and I've seen people saying this and it's right he did have those good few months and we all thought actually the pennies dropped and he's really good, he was brilliant he was brilliant against Manchester City in Y Ayat or even he was at his best and he had some good months. Manchester City away when we were doing another mill. City away he's had some good performance was forever the problem with Bessarty's whenever he's got on a good run he's ended up getting an injury and that's knocked him back now he's been fit for a while he's played it that butter and he's played at Sheffield United. So hang on what we'll do with all three of these we will so we'll just if we can't get rid of him right do you think we could find a use for him and the reason why I'm thinking about this is right I've been watching sorts like James McCarthy recently and thinking I maybe we got rid of him too quickly maybe we should have looked at the bigger picture and looked at what we had and maybe didn't fit into the manager plans or such but who else have we got that's like him if there's a problem. You know obviously we had you know we had Garner so that's one of the reasons McCarthy went. Well we just broke a Batman. Yeah no I know but that was the reason why he meant but you know and that's why you need to play but I'm saying so do you think if we do you think there's any future for him if we can't get rid of him do you think the manager might look at it slightly different now and go well out if you know if I can't get rid of you I will give you a chance and I think that's the that's the whole point with these these three players yeah so do you think with more message and looking at the squad and looking at the short window do you think he there's any way back for him? He's got 12 months on a deal. I guess the question is has he got quality? Bezzert and he's got some quality. Is he good enough to play alongside André Gomez in the season is what you've got to ask because the big problem Bezzert has got and the other two are slightly different to Bezzert. The big problem Bezzert has got all right or everything they've got yeah is that we've got André Gomez who is clearly our number one centre midfiel player because we haven't really got anybody else liking so he's going to be the the fella who will play more often than not right and if you so you put Gomez in a category on his own because when André Gomez isn't there it's that anybody else in evidence midfiel that does the same kind of thing as him controls the way we play keeps the ball whatever no right Guilfe no they can't do that so then that if you so if you're thinking evidently playing a 4-4-2 so you left midfiel that is André Gomez then on the right you've got Tom Davis who is like that you've got Guilfe Sigarton who let's be honest I think evidently take and if they got a bid for him I think they'd accept it because he's not a centre midfiel player not in a Premier League in a position where his partner isn't gone or his partner's not someone who's going to go like this all day long. Delth your manager say and he doesn't know when he's going to be fit and it's been let's be honest they've hasn't worked out at all it's been poor and it could have been the other way and neither main three go by man we write off till January at least that the earliest so for best it is he different than the three we've already got he knows the role because he's played there he's a good man to my marky but evident as a team for this evident team to evolve needs someone I can go both ways but I'm rolling up in the arm of the ball is he that no I think he lacks discipline and there's that and I think if he played I think if I think if he had the qualities we needed I think Chris Waddle would have played in the chip with United because I just don't think he's got the discipline to play in a in a you know next to someone like Andre Gomez where you again know what he's going to do I think he's or if he hasn't got the discipline is he got the pace to get up and down the pitch that's what you need to ask yourself I'll be honest I think I think the jury me slightly out on this one because I think if you can't if you can't get rid of him I'm not saying you're not going to wouldn't like use him but I definitely I definitely like have him say the next season train with like I wouldn't just kick him out the door and go well you're and we've done this with players in the past with a thing you're not playing so therefore you you know you do something else well if we can't get alone for him or whatever and listen we really just want to get these plays out the door of course you can those we do sorry but if he wasn't I would definitely have him somewhere in there but he's does that does that block the path of a Benny Benning to me I don't know because I don't know what they think of Benny Benning me truly so it's a difficult one with my message but don't get me wrong I don't think he's going to come back and then he's going to be like oh he's on one I just think it the way things are at the moment yeah well we might end up doing that if everything don't get a good enough deal to take him off off their hands then maybe we'll and if he impresses in pre-season with the new coaching staff that's up to him certainly if you give these people a chance Sandro he's done nothing in Spain absolutely nothing and ironically this is his best season three goals this season in 22 games I think it is for them he's played on the right for us and don't know right but is he best not a goal scorer but he's not he's not doing whatever he had in that when he had that season for Malaga it's gone hasn't he I suppose the only way to look at it and we're clutching at stores here is with the ass gone could he be the fourth choice fourth I mean obviously and if he played in a 4-4-2 with Dominic Alden Llewman that could he be fourth choice striker because obviously now Cheng Toten's out and we're out trying to get rid of him anyway and the ass is gone so suddenly if he came back he'd be fourth choice but probably wouldn't make the bench so if we couldn't get again like Bessage if you couldn't get rid of him would you just have to have him training every day just in case one of the other strikers wasn't fit and then you know Moise Keane at the moment he'd go into the team or you know and then Sandro would go on the bench because you wouldn't need the centre forward coming off the bench because I do think that the gap between the people who are coming through like the likes of Ellasim's is still quite big so well he's got more experience than Ellasim he's another one if you can't get rid of him he's our player and he's still our player for two seasons whether people like that or not you can't have seen people go and just kick him off you can't there's FFP there's contract obligations and all that fourth choice striker it's up to him isn't it he did very well in pre-season in Silver's face here I think it was wasn't it on the right wing didn't he last year I know he'd never got used at all but because Evan had made the decision I guess it depends what Marcel Brands thinks Marcel Brands is looked at him and has gone after that first pre-season he's not good enough and I want him gone then deals side to farm I'm out somewhere else who's to say valid a lid won't come in and buy him in the summer if ever and go and tell you what you can have him for a million yeah or even someone else someone else in Spain just don't mind the civil might come back or something go will if it's a cheap they're a bit good not at all but for like a cheap deal they might go someone for a couple of you know obviously his wages are the big problem and he's not going he's not going to shift enough for me like this and you do everything you can to get rid of him worst case scenario worst worst case scenario is he becomes he becomes the new 23 isn't he yeah he becomes the new nyas which is you know a play you're trying to get rid of you can't so you have you use him when you need to use him and again that that's the same with message if that happens to message and you try everything you can to get rid of him and if it doesn't doesn't if it doesn't happen it doesn't happen and the final one you had up a lot he's put a little thing out of day for it to sport and saying you know thank you you buy this time but now he wants to come back and recently we know we've mentioned this recently he has been like trying to get himself back in the the good books of everm everm fans and you know doing the the going around on his bike and getting stuck into Liverpool fans a little bit and trying to get where there's before that he's being a little bit funny with everm fans and a little bit like you know more lean towards Palace I don't know whether he thought he was something still there for him but um but again he's a player he goes into his last year of his contract again since the injury he's gone on obviously he's come back he was brought back to really by Aladais he's gone on loans he's like he's a villar he went to andalech he's been at sport in Portugal but it's never quite worked for him any way he's gone again coming back to his final year at everm the plan will be the same won't he try and find the club forward try and get him off the books I know he's saying he wants to come back he wants to play but again that that seems that's even though certainly on the right hand side we've we've there's there's a gap there he's not the player I feel it surely um not what we've seen after the injury I think when he come in from Palace I think he was decent he had five assists before his injury he had a scene to have a decent little partnership with Rom and all the friends and all that he got on well and then obviously had a horror injury and was out for a year and then your right Aladais brought him back too quickly didn't really work you know he played games that he shouldn't have really played when we had Adam Ola Luchman um and then he went off obviously to villar in the hope that he gets some game time and then we'd have a with a session when he's had a year back at playing at the club and he had a good time in Andalech and they wanted to keep him but it was just the money didn't have any money and got six goals in 27 games or something for Andalech um he's only played I think he's played 22 games for Everton or something or 29 times for Everton he was actually doing well for sport Lisbon till he got sent off and then he got sent off he got sent off for an elbow that was never an elbow and then they and they just sort of bombed them out after that so he's got he's got something I don't know whether he's good enough for the player no he's got he's listen he's a powerful player he's quite quick I don't know if he has got that power anymore don't think that's the problem listen I've not watched them religiously since since he left us so I wouldn't be able to tell you that I've seen him have these flashes where he's done well um tricks that he's always gone and I think I've said it always about Balasi if he simplified his game he'd be much better player the tricks are great but use them to actually get away from someone don't just use them because you're trying to fee fee yourself off which he started trying I think that was his biggest thing when he come back he started trying to do tricks to show everyone he was back but he wasn't back because the tricks weren't going away and a couple of times he'd do it and wouldn't the player would just be looking to say and what you do it trick to buy your half a yard that's all you do so I don't I am unsure he can it's good that he's got this attitude it's good that he's going I want to wear the blue shirt again I want to fight he's probably looking and going this is carlawant i lotty I'd love to play under this man and do it even if it's for 12 months and then I leave on a three I think from an everton perspective they'll be looking and going no we want you off the door we want to get you off the wage bill because you're not part the problem with all of these is none of them contribute to our team and they're all taking money off the door and that's the issue that brands will have we've seen we've now got the nias we've now got the gar but we've got the Cucamarty and Morgan Snidlans gone there's four off the wage bill and it's a big chunk of money that's gone off the wage bill and brands will be trying to get to the Matty Pennington there's the likes of Callum Connolly if you don't think it's got a much of a hope here it's got a year left on his deal it was out on loan as well they'll want those two gone the only one really who's out on loan who do you probably want to keep well do you want to keep his Lewis Gibson who's doing well a Fleetwood Karen Dahl's just come back and he's playing a wig and but I don't think they want to I think they'll want to get to the Karen Dahl now because he's made no inroads and he's on a decent wage and John Joe the plan was always and obviously John Joe has had the best loan he's gone to a top you know a top league in one of the top five leagues and played all season it remains to be seen that I don't think he's good enough or he isn't good enough but he's given himself half a chance that was the clear path wasn't it that was the plan the plan was to send them on loan and bring them back and and then evaluate them where there's these are different these are different these have already you know saved the papers or haven't saved the papers in a way so um I don't know maybe maybe me why I said the other two are different abesities there is a big gap on that right hand side dependent now everything and I'm sure Carlo until off he will be sick with Marcel Brands and going I want to win I want a proper winger and a new winger who's quick and can get goals and blah blah and we don't win up rivita that at the moment the situation's interesting now isn't it because when the season finished you know there's going to be five weeks there's going to be five weeks on them we get under this season to begin on the next season you know pre-season's going to be they're going to be back in pre-season two two and a half weeks three weeks at the very very most after the flash comes so these players will be will be called back for pre-season will be called back for testing if you haven't ordered if you haven't left the club they'll be called back to testing they'll be there for they'll be the manager will it's a it's a good thing and a bad thing for them that he the manager won't will have to see them but he won't have long to see them so we'll have to assess them very quickly and he's always going to assess them as an afterthought after the plays that he already knows but at the same time the fact that like martin is still being around the squad the ass is still being around the squad gives these an outside chance to force the way in and then it's on them of course we'll be trying to get rid of them but then you know that's up to them isn't it and oh you can ask is to come back five for the place and you know if we can't get rid of them then there's an option there at the very least and maybe them you know they can earn the money at least even if they're just training but that's what it is isn't it it's about that it's about if you're paying someone then you might as well get them to do something and that's the way it is the my only question to finish would be do any of them offer us something we don't have at the moment and that's the for us for everything to improve you're looking for something you haven't got at the moment there's no sentiment we want them all bombed out of the club clearly but and that's what Marcel Brands will be doing on me there you go there isn't your thoughts give us your reactions your memories of the players you've left the club the zuma the sweet prince hold the special place let us know and for the other three do you see anything in those other three players that you know makes you think yeah they'll they could they could do something next season they could contribute to this squad let us know your thoughts in the comments if you like this video give it a like subscribe if you haven't already if you want more great videos join us over on page and the link is in the description we'll see you later