 Well, the situation is the following. I was asked to finish on time and we have seven minutes for the Q&A So I would suggest the following I will gather questions to give the chance to each speaker to have one or two minutes one or two minutes Not more, please to try to to pick up the question there So I start with a Renault and Jean-Claude after that Obviously be brief in your question, but I know that Renault is expert We give up, we are too late, the others invest too much compared to us, we have too much capacity Are we French or European? We really lost this battle Where we will be able to do as we did Mirage 3 and Airbus to come back in the race or it's over Jean-Claude and I take the question from Joseph Is there a question in the middle? Yeah, just going back to Mayor and the comment he made about the Snowden story In the United States we believe that we have the right to have our communication to be protected from government And the debate at the occasion of the Snowden story was whether we can listen to anybody Or the government can listen to anybody, can listen to American citizens which creates even more problems And if you listen to citizens, at least and particularly for American citizens You should have a judge reviewing the process and the warrant to be established Joseph, and then to the first round, Madame What are the means and the tools for democracy in order to prevent cyber attack? Beyond and without infringing on the state of law Thank you very much So I will go for the last question Madame Yeah, that was really my question too Because when we started speaking about cyber attacks and all that And you hear about ransom, you hear about all kind of things But when it goes to the core of democracy and that I was really terrified when I was watching the Robert Mahler's audition When he was saying right now we are under a threat of the next elections Next election being attacked after what happened in 2016 And they felt so powerless, so you say how can we do it? So it's exactly the same question, either their way to prevent it And my question is to Mr. Mahishetri Because they seem to have a specific solution So that and to Jean, we get it, thank you So I return now to the panelists May I, would you like to go first? Yeah, okay For a couple of minutes Sure And in order to prevent, to the lady, in order to prevent what you are suggesting Country have to be very aware to the situation and protect its own people That's what we're doing in Israel Not only for the government, we do it also for private companies We do it for private companies For example, if we want to prevent attacks against our banks We have the ability really to prevent it Because we prepare ourselves from advance Not to allow possibility of attacks banks in Israel So we have to be prepared to prepare it You want to make elections in the United States? Of course you can manipulate it very easily today And that's what we did in the last elections according to the press So the United States have to prepare its own system to not be open to attacks That could be in your car, in airplanes, everywhere Matter of fact you can arrive everywhere and ruin everything from far away Unless you are making protections The protection is the other side of the cyber attacks You have to be protected very strongly Thank you Patrick Yeah, very briefly I think some battles are lost Yes, the public cloud one is gone There is too much money into it And we don't have the market This is gone But the technology is evolving So there are new battlegrounds I'll be brief So I think the first one is data We are not paying enough attention about how we want to manage data We have a response we heard this morning Protect the cities and yeah, but there is the source of value It's not value in itself, this is a source of value We should have a better plan Because if we don't have it Then there is a second aspect where we can invest and win market share It's software and in particular artificial intelligence But without trusted data It's very difficult just to have the engine You must have something to extract value from And then on the infrastructure part We alluded to rapidly this morning There is the emergence of edge computing Edge computing is linked to the deployment of sensors everywhere So meaning there will be a distribution of intelligence there And with the new wireless technology called 5G That brings two things First the virtualization layer And then the ability to manage seamlessly all your networks And I think here we have the opportunities to regain some position But the thing we've been discussing it's gone I'll just leave with it Thank you Jean-Louis Just I think that the worst is ahead And I'm not convinced at all that artificial intelligence And these new tools will be Will help more the defence than the aggression I think that the aggressors will benefit more from artificial intelligence Especially to disguise themselves Constantly your question And the question of Joseph We need to do far more For the time being If we look at the products in cyber security Both for industry for governments They are not French The situation where the French Air Force Would be entirely made with the foreign air place The tools, the main tools are either Israeli or American So this is a general challenge for Europe And we have to build an ecosystem Between start-up and large companies That we have failed to do so until now And second we need to be far better To have what I call reactive defence To really attack when our companies Our private companies are attacked by state actors There is an imbalance And we need to have a better protection from the state A better interaction with the state Or several states for the time being The Europeans should work together Especially for French intelligence Because if we don't know who attacks us If we have not evidence of who attacks us In fact we have already lost Pure protection is not enough We need a reactive defence At the French level but also at the European level Thank you One sentence Since we are speaking about artificial intelligence Which is the future of computing There is very famous people like Bill Gates Stephen Hawkins which says That they look at artificial intelligence As a danger to the existence of the human being Well I think everyone will appreciate The optimistic tone of this session And so it's time to thank our panelists