You're viewing YouTube in English (US).
Switch to another language: | View all
You're viewing YouTube in English.
Switch to another language: | View all

Is Hillary Clinton Right That The Rich Don't Pay Their "Fair Share" of Taxes?





The interactive transcript could not be loaded.



Rating is available when the video has been rented.
This feature is not available right now. Please try again later.
Uploaded on May 28, 2010

Secretary of State Hillary Clinton recently said that "the rich are not paying their fair share" of taxes in the United States and other developed countries.

Is she right? It depends on what you consider fair. Using 2006 data, The New York Times found that the richest 20 percent of households were paying 26 percent of their income to the federal government in the form of income, payroll, corporate, and excise taxes. The average for all familes? 21 percent.

And there's this: "In 2006, the top quintile of households earned 55.7 percent of pretax income and paid 69.3 percent of federal taxes, while the top 1 percent of households earned 18.8 percent of income and paid 28.3 percent of taxes."

Paying in a lot more than you get out? That doesn't seem fair.

The rich are different than you and me; they've got more money. And they pay more taxes.

Politicians are different too--they rarely say what they really mean. Perhaps what Secretary Clinton means is that the rich can always pay more than they're already paying.

That would explain why she and the president are lobbying to let the Bush tax cuts expire at the end of the year, a policy that would raise all sorts of taxes on all sorts of people.

Which doesn't sound all that fair either.

Produced by Meredith Bragg and Nick Gillespie.

Go to for documentation and graphs.

Loading... Viral Vids

  1. 1

    Tax Day is Coming: Game of Thrones Edition

  2. 2

    Kim Jong-un [HEARTS] Obamacare!

  3. 3

    3 Reasons We Need a Dirty Deal on Debt Ceiling

  4. 4

    What if Miss Utah had Answered Correctly at the Miss USA Pageant?

  5. 5

    Sex, Violence & Satan: 6 Unbelievably Dumb Congressional Hearings

  6. 6

    "I Pledge to Serve Barack Obama" (Urgent 2012 Election Update)

  7. 7

    Ladies, We're Screwed: Why Obama's Re-election is Bad for Choice

  8. 8

    Remy: Grandma Got Indefinitely Detained (A Very TSA Christmas)

  9. 9

    Remy: Missing You - The Incandescent Light Bulb Song

  10. 10

    Occupy Thanksgiving: A Message of Hope, Redemption, and Dada

  11. 11

    Remy's Occupy Wall Street Protest Song

  12. 12

    Lindy: "No Knock Raid" - a song about the drug war's deadliest tactic.

  13. 13

    Stonewall 2011: The Night NY Legalized Gay Marriage

  14. 14

    Remy: Why They Fought

  15. 15

    Social Security, Snoopy Snoopy Poop Dogg, & Alan Simpson: Ultimate Remix

  16. 16

    To Surly, With Love: Are Teachers Overpaid?

  17. 17

    The Dumbest Thing Ever Said! Hillary Clinton, about the Drug War

  18. 18

    Buzz Bowl I: Four Loko vs Joose

  19. 19

    A Joe Biden (War On) Christmas

  20. 20

    The Pilgrims and Property Rights: How our ancestors got fat & happy

  21. 21

    TSA "My Ding-a-Ling" Sing-Along

  22. 22

    44 Ways to Say TSA: What do the initials "TSA" really stand for?

  23. 23

    Con Air 2010 (TSA Remix)

  24. 24

    Coming Soon to an Airport Near You: Prison-style strip searches?

  25. 25

    The Madness of Barack Obama

  26. 26

    Attack Ads, Circa 1800

  27. 27

    Who is Publius? or, Who's Afraid of Anonymous Political Speech?

  28. 28

    Busted for Growing Veggies!'s Nanny of the Month for September 2010

  29. 29

    Hollywood Hates Capitalism - Wall Street: Money Never Sleeps Edition

  30. 30

    Sen. Barack Obama on Sen. John McCain's Plan for an Economic Commission

  31. 31

    Get Reason's iPhone App Right Now!

  32. Is Hillary Clinton Right That The Rich Don't Pay Their "Fair Share" of Taxes?

  33. 33

    FCC Commissioner Copps "would love to have jurisdiction over everything."

  34. 34

    Federal Regulations and You: Partners in Democracy!

  35. 35

    EPA Rulemaking Matters! Subtitled For Your Protection

  36. 36

    EPA Rulemaking Matters! Video: Let Your Robotic Voice Be Heard! Let Your Robotic Voice Be Heard!

  37. 37

    Is the Tea Party Movement Racist?

  38. 38

    How The Hell Did GM Pay Back Its Loans "in Full And Ahead of Schedule"? Well, It Didn't.

  39. 39 Exclusive Track: DJ Carl Levin's Really Sh*tty Deal!

  40. 40

    Taxes: The Price We Pay For Civilization

  41. 41's Nanny of the Month for March 2010: Salt-Banner NY State Rep. Felix Ortiz

  42. 42

    3 Reasons Public Sector Employees are Killing the Economy

  43. 43

    Reason Saves Cleveland: The Outtake Reel

  44. 44

    3 Reasons Health Care Reform Won't Cut The Deficit By One Thin Dime.

  45. 45

    Dramatic Olbermann vs. Dramatic Chipmunk

  46. 46

    3 Reasons Not To Sweat The "Citizens United" SCOTUS Ruling

  47. 47

    Obama's Doublethink Doubletalk (State of the Union Remix)

  48. 48

    The First Anti-Ted Kennedy Tea Party: Boston's Anti-Busing Brigades

  49. 49

    Brown and Coakley Supporters Greet Obama in Boston

  50. 50

    We're the TSA and You Can Count on Us! (to overreact to tiny threats and ignore big ones)

  51. 51

    Worst. Decade. Ever.

  52. 52's Nanny of the Year 2009!

  53. 53

    Real World DC (Health Care Remix)

  54. 54

    Be Happy!: Why this is the best holiday season ever.

  55. 55

    Nanny of The Month - November 2009

  56. 56

    Thanks For Supporting Reason's Webathon 2009

  57. 57

    Buy American Pot: A Special Message From the AMGA, Dedicated to Keeping Pot Illegal & Profits High!

  58. 58

    UPS vs. FEDEX: Ultimate Whiteboard Remix

  59. 59

    Budget Deficits for Dummies: Or how I learned to stop worrying and love $1.4 trillion

  60. 60

    Barack Obama Wins 2009 Nobel Peace Prize and...

  61. 61

    Cracking the Education Monopoly: Los Angeles parents demand choice - and get it.

  62. 62

    Light Bulbs vs. The Nanny State

  63. 63

    Banning Sex Toys?! Nanny of the Month, September '09

  64. 64

    No American Should Have to Choose Between Health Insurance and Getting Drunk

  65. 65

    Obama to Citizens on Health Care: Send In All Fishy Emails

  66. 66


  67. 67

    Would ObamaCare Cover Sticker-Shock Treatment?

  68. 68

    What if Government Ran Health Care? (Sprint Ad Remix)

  69. 69

    UPS vs. FEDEX: Ultimate Whiteboard Remix

  70. 70

    UPS vs. FEDEX: Ultimate Whiteboard Remix (Broadcast Cut)

  71. 71

    Liberal and Conservative Agree on Bill of Rights...

  72. 72

    Free* Government Money With Matthew Lesko!

  73. 73

    C-SPAN After Dark: Alcee Hastings' Cher-Like Awards Show Acceptance Speech

  74. 74

    Morticians Association of America Endorses President Obama's Tough New Fuel Efficiency Standards

  75. 75

    128 Days Later: It Can Always Get Worse

  76. 76

    Have the Bestest 4th of July Ever! (Errant Fireworks Display!)

  77. 77

    Cuban Punk Rocker Gorki Aguila on Music, Life and Getting Led Zeppelin Records in Cuba

  78. 78

    Real Man of Genius: Joe Biden

  79. 79

    Stimulis: Because all economies have performance issues

  80. 80

    W-2 WTF?!?!: Tax Facts to Make Your Head Explode!

  81. 81

    Obama Kids: Sing for Change (Pyongyang Remix)

  82. 82

    Smiles Outlawed: DMV Makes Life Even More Miserable

  83. 83

    3 Great Reasons to Pay Your Taxes (or Else)!

  84. 84

    Introducing the Government-Backed DMV Automotive Repair Center!

  85. 85

    Obama, You're No Stranger to the Bong: An Open Letter to the President

  86. 86

    Are You the Change You've Been Waiting For?

  87. 87

    Where's Sock Puppet's Bailout?

  88. 88

    Where's my bailout?

  89. 89

    Christopher Hitchens: Bah, Humbug on Christmas [Updated 12/19/2011]

  90. 90

    Stop Outsourcing Roles in Pro-Obama Videos!

  91. 91

    To Surly, With Love: Are Teachers Overpaid?

  92. 92

    Reactions to Obama's Jobs Speech 9/8/2011 or, "Two Girls One Job"

  93. 93

    Reactions to Obama's Jobs Speech 9/8/2011 or, "Two Girls One Job"

  94. 94

    NYPD Cop Punches Protester at Occupy Wall Street, 10/14/11

  95. 95

    The TSA's 12 Banned Items of Christmas

  96. 96

    Guantanamo Bay in 54 Seconds: What Every American Should Know

  97. 97

    3 Ways to Make Obamacare Less Totally Horrible

  98. 98

    Are You Afraid of The Dark? (Election 2014 Parody)

  99. 99

    Don't Tell 'Em (Obamacare Version)

  100. 100

    Which President Bombed Iraq Best?

  101. 101

    Congress Makes Christmas Come Early! Did Uncle Santa Bring You a Gift?

  102. 102

    'Twas the Night Raid Before Christmas

  103. 103

    Vote Frank Underwood: A House of Cards Political Ad

  104. 104

    7 Creepy Robots for Cops

  105. 105

    Remy: Best Song Ever! (One Direction Parody - Tax Code Edition)

Sign in to add this to Watch Later

Add to