<?xml version="1.0" encoding="utf-8" ?><transcript><text start="0.28" dur="5.89">R+L=J is a fan theory regarding George R.
R. Martin&amp;#39;s Song of Ice and Fire, the basis</text><text start="6.17" dur="4.179">of HBO&amp;#39;s Game of Thrones. It&amp;#39;s one of the
best-supported and most widely believed fan</text><text start="10.349" dur="5.29">theories. The idea is that Jon Snow is not
the bastard son of Eddard Stark and an unknown</text><text start="15.639" dur="4.941">woman, as Jon and most of Westeros believes,
but is actually the son of Ned&amp;#39;s sister, Lyanna</text><text start="20.58" dur="5.01">Stark, and Rhaegar Targaryen. So, for a bit
of context, Prince Rhaegar Targaryen was the</text><text start="25.59" dur="5.04">son of the Mad King Aerys Targaryen, who was
overthrown in Robert Baratheon&amp;#39;s Rebellion,</text><text start="30.63" dur="5.54">the war that made Robert king. Lyanna is kind
of the Helen of Troy of Westeros because Robert&amp;#39;s</text><text start="36.17" dur="4.25">Rebellion started when Lyanna, who at the
time was betrothed to Robert, was abducted</text><text start="40.42" dur="4.649">by or more likely ran away with Prince Rhaegar,
who was already married to Elia</text><text start="45.069" dur="1.54">Martell. Rhaegar spent</text><text start="46.609" dur="7">the start of the war in the Tower of Joy, in Dorne,
with Lyanna, before going off to battle, and to his doom, in the form of Robert&amp;#39;s</text><text start="53.609" dur="2.591">hammer. So after the war was over, Ned</text><text start="56.28" dur="5.239">and six others headed to the Tower to find Lyanna, where they were confronted by three of the dead King&amp;#39;s guard. When</text><text start="61.519" dur="4.301">the fight was over, the two survivors, Ned
and his friend Howland Reed, went up the tower</text><text start="65.82" dur="4.67">to find Lyanna Stark &amp;quot;in a bed of blood&amp;quot;.
There, Lyanna got Ned to make her a promise</text><text start="70.49" dur="7">before she died. So R+L=J suggests that Lyanna&amp;#39;s
&amp;quot;bed of blood&amp;quot; is one of childbirth, the baby</text><text start="77.619" dur="4.68">is Rhaegar and Lyanna&amp;#39;s, and that Ned&amp;#39;s promise
to Lyanna is to pretend that the child is</text><text start="82.299" dur="4.081">his in order to protect the child from Robert,
who would see the son of the Targaryen prince</text><text start="86.38" dur="3.96">as a threat and likely have him killed, just
as he had Rhaegar&amp;#39;s wife and other children</text><text start="90.34" dur="4.919">killed. In any case, Ned then comes back from
the war with a baby, Jon, who until his death</text><text start="95.259" dur="5.411">he raises as his own son in Winterfell.
So that&amp;#39;s the theory. What&amp;#39;s the evidence</text><text start="100.67" dur="4.29">that makes it more plausible than the alternative,
that Jon really is Ned&amp;#39;s bastard?</text><text start="104.96" dur="4.92">Firstly, it seems very out-of-character for
Ned Stark, a painfully honourable person,</text><text start="109.88" dur="4.239">to have fathered a bastard. In Ned&amp;#39;s own words,
to have fathered Jon was to &amp;quot;dishonor ... [himself]</text><text start="114.119" dur="5.081">and ... dishonor ... Catelyn, in the sight
of gods and men&amp;quot;. Ned isn&amp;#39;t like Robert, who</text><text start="119.2" dur="4.839">would &amp;quot;swear undying love and forget them
before evenfall&amp;quot;, Ned &amp;quot;[keeps] his vows&amp;quot;.</text><text start="124.039" dur="4.461">So right away it seems unlikely that Ned would
break his wedding vows to Catelyn by fathering</text><text start="128.5" dur="3.819">Jon.
At one point Ned refers to Jon as his &amp;quot;blood&amp;quot;,</text><text start="132.319" dur="3.721">but he never calls him his son.
At one point, he internally lists his children,</text><text start="136.04" dur="5.44">naming &amp;quot;Robb and Sansa and Arya and Bran
and Rickon&amp;quot;. The very next line he mentions</text><text start="141.48" dur="5.429">Jon, but not part of the list of his children.
Speaking of Arya – Jon is said to look like</text><text start="146.909" dur="3.44">her, and Arya is said to look like Lyanna.
Anyway, so</text><text start="150.349" dur="4.051">during a conversation with Robert about the
Rebellion, Ned thinks that &amp;quot;He [has] lived his</text><text start="154.4" dur="4.169">lies for fourteen years&amp;quot;.
What &amp;quot;lies&amp;quot; are Ned be referring to? Here&amp;#39;s</text><text start="158.569" dur="4.67">a hint – Jon is, at the start of the first
book, fourteen years old.</text><text start="163.239" dur="7">So what all these hints amount to is that Jon is Ned&amp;#39;s lie, a lie that &amp;quot;[haunts] him at night&amp;quot;, but which he persists with, because</text><text start="170.629" dur="4.711">&amp;quot;Some secrets are safer kept hidden. Some
secrets are too dangerous to share, even with</text><text start="175.34" dur="4.399">those you love and trust&amp;quot;
It hurts Ned to lie like this, but he does</text><text start="179.739" dur="4.521">it to keep his promise to his sister, to protect
his sister&amp;#39;s son.</text><text start="184.26" dur="3.38">One more thing about Ned – on multiple occassions, Ned opposes the killing</text><text start="187.64" dur="4.069">of Targaryen children. When Robert orders
the assassination of Daenerys and her unborn</text><text start="191.709" dur="4.291">child, Ned refuses, hurting his friendship
with Robert and endangering his honour and</text><text start="196" dur="4.9">life by disobeying the king. The other example
is his opposition to the killing of Rhaegar&amp;#39;s</text><text start="200.9" dur="3.41">wife and children at the Sack of King&amp;#39;s Landing.
This refusal to kill</text><text start="204.31" dur="3.97">children for the sake of their Targaryen
blood is mirrored by Ned&amp;#39;s protection of Jon.</text><text start="208.28" dur="2.26">To return briefly to the Tower of Joy, it</text><text start="210.54" dur="4.529">seems very odd for three members of the Kingsguard
to be there with Lyanna Stark. Shouldn&amp;#39;t they</text><text start="215.069" dur="4.071">be protecting the siblings of the now-dead
Prince? A very good explanation for their</text><text start="219.14" dur="5.5">presence is that they were guarding the heir
apparent, the son of the prince, Jon.</text><text start="224.64" dur="3.429">So now to Essos, for a Biggie in terms of textual
evidence.</text><text start="228.069" dur="4.28">While in House of the Undying, in Qarth, Daenerys
has a vision of &amp;quot;A blue flower [growing] from a</text><text start="232.349" dur="3.64">chink in a wall of ice, and [filling] the air
with sweetness&amp;quot;.</text><text start="235.989" dur="5.191">Blue flowers, specifically blue winter roses,
are consistently associated with Lyanna Stark. At the Tourney</text><text start="241.18" dur="4.839">of Harrenhal, Rhaegar selected Lyanna as the
“Queen of Love and Beauty” – over his wife – and presented</text><text start="246.019" dur="4.78">her with a crown of blue winter roses. A storm
of blue rose petals feature in Ned&amp;#39;s dream</text><text start="250.799" dur="5.56">about Lyanna, and the statue of Lyanna in Winterfell
Crypt has a garland of blue winter roses.</text><text start="256.359" dur="4.35">What this strongly suggests is that something
to do with Lyanna is at a &amp;quot;wall of ice&amp;quot;. That</text><text start="260.709" dur="5.011">something is very probably Jon on the Wall.
So given all these hints, it seems</text><text start="265.72" dur="6.03">very likely that Jon Snow is the son of Rhaegar
Targaryen and Lyanna Stark. But what are</text><text start="271.75" dur="4.81">the implications of R+L=J?
It&amp;#39;s been suggested that being both a Stark</text><text start="276.56" dur="5.52">and a Targaryen makes Jon the Song of Ice
and Fire personified. What this actually means,</text><text start="282.08" dur="4.78">exactly, is unclear but it does seem to suggest
that Jon is very important, perhaps he&amp;#39;s the</text><text start="286.86" dur="4.85">Prince that was Promised, or Azor Ahai, or
one of the three heads of the dragon, or any</text><text start="291.71" dur="4.13">of the other various prophecised figures.
In any case, Stark blood is associated with</text><text start="295.84" dur="4.38">powers like warging, and Targaryen blood is
associated with an affinity with dragons and</text><text start="300.22" dur="4.849">fire. Jon having both would possibly make
him capable of some pretty impressive stuff.</text><text start="305.069" dur="4.711">A more concrete implication is that, if Jon
is the son of Prince Rhaegar, he has a claim</text><text start="309.78" dur="4.68">on the Iron Throne – more so than Dany, actually.
That&amp;#39;s assuming, though, that Rhaegar and</text><text start="314.46" dur="3.35">Lyanna were secretly wedded, which could have
happened despite Rhaegar&amp;#39;s existing marriage</text><text start="317.81" dur="4.55">to Elia – polygamy is a bit of a thing with
Targaryens – but if they weren&amp;#39;t married,</text><text start="322.36" dur="3.41">Jon would still be considered a bastard, and
an illegitimate contender for the throne,</text><text start="325.77" dur="4.56">though he could possibly be legitimised. Jon&amp;#39;s
vows with the Night&amp;#39;s Watch are another complication.</text><text start="330.33" dur="4.05">He&amp;#39;s sworn an oath to &amp;quot;hold no lands&amp;quot;, to
&amp;quot;wear no crown&amp;quot; – so surely he can&amp;#39;t be king.</text><text start="334.38" dur="4">But even if he could overcome that barrier,
would anyone believe his claim to the throne?</text><text start="338.38" dur="6.11">How could he prove his parentage? And besides, it seems doubtful that Jon would even want the Throne.
Powers and thrones aside, finding out his</text><text start="344.49" dur="4.269">true parentage would be very significant for Jon
personally. He&amp;#39;s always struggled with rejection</text><text start="348.759" dur="4.891">from Cat, alienation from being a bastard,
and the difficulty of not knowing his mother.</text><text start="353.65" dur="4.94">Finding out his true parentage would undoubtedly
be a big deal for him, if not for all of Westeros.</text><text start="358.59" dur="4.52">So that&amp;#39;s R+L=J – the main evidence, and some
of the possible implications. Let me know</text><text start="363.11" dur="3.08">in the comments what you think of the theory,
and whether you&amp;#39;d like to see more videos</text><text start="366.19" dur="4.699">on A Song of Ice and Fire fan theories – some
of which are pretty crazy and awesome.</text><text start="370.889" dur="2.671">If you&amp;#39;re interested in A Song of Ice and
Fire fan theories and discussion, you</text><text start="373.56" dur="4.12">might like to check out westeros.org, the
wiki, and the subreddit.</text><text start="377.68" dur="1">That&amp;#39;s all from me.
Thanks for watching this video.</text></transcript>