Upload

kali vs silat

by hiholdac • 2,193,177 views

demo bercy - see more on : www.academiefranckropers.com and : http://www.afsdamp.net/?q=node/7

Silat pertama ditemukan di sumatera ' dan berkembang keseluruh nusantara. Mencapai bentuk yg sempurna pada jaman majapahit . yg disebut beladiri sundang majapahit dengan senjata pedang dan keris. Kali eskrima .berasal dari pilipina,tp dasarnya dari silat majapahit,yg dibawa para prajuritnya , Di indonesia sendiri silat yg mirip dgn kali ada didaerah sulawesi' bugis.
Report spam or abuse
+samzfisher i don't think sufi is similar like hindus etc. they're sect of sunni islam too. not 'sunni' in tamil language. hahahaahah. :P hhmmm your argue is valid tho. silat was firstly found in sumatra indonesia. and i think that time indonesia was a hindu-buddha before islam came to them. i think you're correct.
Report spam or abuse
Yeah silat was also an invention and knowledge of human being. Knowledge will always continue to improved and evolved and becoming better everyday. 
Report spam or abuse
malaysia sebelumya juga bagiann dari tanah indonesia cuman tidak mau merdeka bersama sama dan memilih memecah diri untuk menjadi negara boneka...itu yang setau aku.... jadi pencak silat ya dari malaysia n juga dari indonesia cz indonesia and malaysia is majapahit kingdom
Report spam or abuse
Silat malaysia cma bsa gulet ja beda dengan indonesia banyak seperti debus dll.yg mnggunakan ilmu tenaga dalam
Report spam or abuse
Pencak Silat adalah Ilmu Bela diri dari tanah Asia khususnya Indonesia dan Malaysia. Ilmu Pencak Silat hanya merupakan ilmu melumpuhkan lawan dan mengunci bagian tubuh lawan sehingga tidak bisa bergerak atau lemah. Zaman dahulu ilmu pencak silat juga disandingkan dengan tenaga dalam.
Report spam or abuse
read BERNAMA and watch ASTRO youve learn NOTHING my brothr DEMOCRACY PLURAL IS THE WORLDS NEEDED INDONESIA have done HOW ABOUT YOURE... MALAYSIA?
Report spam or abuse
exivicion de cali filpino.
Report spam or abuse
Semuanyaa milik Allah. Tanpa Allah siapa laa kita. Datang dr mana tu tak kesah. Kita sesama islam mesti mnguatkan ukhuwah. Sesama sedara islam
Report spam or abuse
Silat always originally from Malay's ancient martial arts. In Malaysia, a few silat was discover such name as Gayong Makhrifat, Gayong Patani, Cekak/Cekak Hanafi, Lincah, Sendeng, Helang Putih, Lok 9 and many more. Silat is close-counter martial art. As we can see how Bruce Lee was defeated by someone from Indonesia man. Bruce Lee was the fastest man on earth, but why he lose someone Silat's learner. When we study and learn more about Silat, we will know how dangerous this martial art. Greeting from Malaysia.   
Report spam or abuse
Report spam or abuse
+Paw !! the future of porn is in your hands
Report spam or abuse
Malaysia bukan BAHAGIAN DR indonesia..asal malaysia dr kesultann mlayu mlaka.dan melaka asal ny dr palembang..sebelum zaman pnjajah xda wilayah negara2 x wujud pn masa tu malaysia, indonesia..yg paling afdal ada lah seblom zaman pnjjah..tanah mlayu,sumatera,tanah jawa,tanah ksultan brunei,tanah ksultan sulu.zmn ksultan kita bangsa nusantara hidup harmoni krn kekuatan islam,bila islam kita lemah. kita di pisahkan krn pnjjah x mnginginkn islam.kita jd lemah..bljr la sejarah seblom komen..tq
Report spam or abuse
Ngak kesah Silat datang Dari mama..asalkan kita INI smua datang Dari Allah yg maha ESA..bikin APA mau gaduh sama2 kita dong..emangnya hanya org yg bodoh sahaja yg sanggup menampakkan ketidakmatangan dalam menilai sesuatu perkara tanpa bukti..Jangan tunjukkan yang emang kita ni nmpk lemah Karena bukn org Asia saja yg menunton vidio INI..namun seluruh dunia..
Report spam or abuse
SILAT from Indonesia, FULL STOP! Its from Sumatra, very popular when Srivijaya from South Sumatra and kingdom from Java (Majahpahit) was ruled. It come to Malaysia and Philipines when ths Nusantara kingdom annexed Malay and Philipines, Thailand. It spread by Srivijaya and Majahpahit!   Both kingdoms are from Indonesia..Not MAlay or Philipines. IF our friends from Philipines can say Yes the Silat was brought by Majahpahit why can't the Malaings say Yes too??...The answer is because the Malaiys have another story about "Nusantara". They think tht the Centre of Nusantara is in malay Peninsula. Its dificult to the malays to accept tht they were ruled and paid tributary to the Srivijayan and Javanese...!
Report spam or abuse
SELAMA INI BANGSA MALAYSIA DAN INDONESIA SELALU DIADU DOMBA OLEH ORANG2 KAFIR KARENA MEREKA SANGAT MEMBENCI JIKA BANGSA MALAYSIA DAN INDONESIA YG BERSAUDARA DALAM ISLAM DAN SATU RUMPUN INI BERSATU. WASPADALAH SAUDARA2 MUSLIM MALAYSIA INDONESIA DENGAN KELICIKAN ORANG2 KAFIR YG SELAMA INI MENGHASUT UNTUK MENUMBUHKAN BENIH PERMUSUHAN ANTARA NEGERI BERSAUDARA INI
Report spam or abuse
Can I ask, which group is using which system?
Report spam or abuse
if you want to kill you're opponent as fast as possible better take kali eskrima... it's not a martial art it's a fighting art... 
Report spam or abuse
Silat Gayong from Malaysia
Report spam or abuse
may indeed be a problem really comes from where the martial arts. but than we disagree about where it came from, the better we both mutually tolerant. we both want to preserve the wealth of our respective countries. so please, think before you all type :)
Report spam or abuse
nice crisp techniques hey they should do the MOCAP for the next assassin's creed game 
Report spam or abuse
sigh why do I even bother to look at the comments. Why fight over a stupid thing if this video's purpose is for entertainment only. Seriously. Smh
Report spam or abuse
Ni lawan ke pertunjukan..kalau setakat pertunjukan..atuk aku dekat rumah tu pon blh menang...mana ada silat yg main tadah je tunggu masa kena ketuk..hahahaha..funny movie..hahahahaaha
Report spam or abuse
These things make me laugh how they make it look so easy to defeat someone, we know from mma that it isn't so.
Report spam or abuse
+Adorable Cannibal  remember that MMA is a sport and the techniques shown in the video are used for killing. thats why its different, purpose wise MMA doesnt cut it like a Karambit would!! hehe
Report spam or abuse
+ivetz caliw caliw Ever used a karambit to kill or severely injure someone in a fight?
Report spam or abuse
+MrSolitude14 sorry man... Kali has many influences.. it has judo, karate, jiujitsu, kung fu, boxing ,muay thai and silat influences.... you can't just say that it is Silat... it has the same root as Silat, but it grew out of Silat and became an independent art of its own..... 
Report spam or abuse
+Adorable Cannibal Man you know a lot, therefore i must kill you xD
Report spam or abuse
Report spam or abuse
an average arnis practitioner from philipinnes would beat a malaysian silat master
Report spam or abuse
por favor, alguem sabe dizer se existe um estilo de eskrima na espanha ?
Report spam or abuse
ini bukan turnamen, tapi pertunjukan! Sebagaimana dikatakan Tyler Lalonde.  Aku nggak senang nih!!
Report spam or abuse
Report spam or abuse
this is not vs...this is just showing off...
Report spam or abuse
Lollll pencak silat From Indonesia, not From Philipini
Report spam or abuse
did you even read the description .. pencak is from indo and kali is from the phil got it
Report spam or abuse
U stupid illiterate. Read clearly bitch. U indos wll frever be our bitches.u cant even win a boxing matches against my country. What if martial arts? Just sayin fag
Report spam or abuse
visit my facebook group Martial Arts
Report spam or abuse
silat from indonesia, is the best .
Report spam or abuse
The 2 are goods! and kung fu is the best !
Report spam or abuse
you really have to be clueless to say "these styles were made for killing not sport"...fighting is a sport, a sport which the UFC dominates because the best hand to hand martial arts have been combined with the best athletes to create the best fighters, simple. again, the "this style is made for killing" statement is pure bullshit for this reason: do you really need a blackbelt in Silat or any other number of useless choreographed dance routines  ("you put your hand here and let me throw you as you jump a little bit and land hard afterwards" ) to kill someone with a sword or choke them until they die? no, you dont. for the douche that was shitting on MMA and BJJ, i know for a fact BJJ is for self defense (not for hard core steven segal killing) and its a HELL of a lot more useful than this garbage. stop living in the past and in fantasy ninja dreams, IF YOUR MARTIAL ARTS WERE MORE EFFECTIVE PEOPLE IN THE UFC WOULD UTILIZE THEM THEREFORE MAKING YOUR MARTIAL ARTS MORE POPULAR THAN FUCKING YOUTUBE VIDEOS 
Report spam or abuse
+Adorable Cannibal the Balintawak video is just for basic students.... later on there will be faster training as the student advances.... the video you showed me is pekiti tirsia, which has a DIFFERENT STRATEGY...... the strategy of Balintawak is Reflex and hand speed to parry and counter attack the opponent.... can't you understand that?? Other styles use those FANCY FOOTWORK which is sometimes impractical for civilians simply because during surprise attacks, the civilian panics and his techniques disappear.... Those fancy footwork are good for military because they literally expect an enemy to attack them... they always have a high degree of awareness...and they keep training with it.... while civilians don't even have the athleticism to do those fancy footwork.... some civilians are even overweight...  while in the streets, it is different... everything is CLOSE QUARTER... people approach you face to face and then suddenly hit you with a weapon... 
Report spam or abuse
+Adorable Cannibal Basic Physics will tell you that the force accumulates at the tip of the stick..... so Balintawak fighters move HEAD ON and try to go very close to their opponent with a stick..The weakness of the stick is Close range because your opponent cannot utilize the tip of the stick effectively... from there, they use their hand speed and reflexes to finish the opponent immediately.... While Pekiti Tirsia strategy is to use those fancy footwork to evade the incoming stick attack.. which is good if you are physically fit like a soldier or athlete... Balintawak footwork is very simple and economical and it can be done by any average person....  
Report spam or abuse
Indonesia and Philippines should be friends. just imagine if we become progressive (though im sure westeners would do everything for that not to happen, hence the term neo-colonialism) and become 1st world countries. with this arts there would be chaos. for sure.
Report spam or abuse
i'm from philipinnes and i love indonesia........ i hope that one day philipinnes and indonesia would share knowledge about sports
Report spam or abuse
boo euro ..noob silat ..
Report spam or abuse
Ini baru namanya seni beladiri, mma itu bukan beladiri, gulat campuraduk, kalau ngga meninggal, cacat seumur hidup. menang sakit kalah masuk rumah sakit.
Report spam or abuse
Report spam or abuse
who is doing kali and who is doing silat? 
Report spam or abuse
Kali (Vest). Silat (Full "Karate" uniform).
Report spam or abuse
boo euro ..noob silat ..
Report spam or abuse
Kali is better on blades rather than hands there are many MMA who can deflect this kind of attacks except for blades of course
Report spam or abuse
silat from indonesia :) (y)
Report spam or abuse
no art better than other, thy are just different, who wins ? depends of who is more prepared, has more resistance, is more effective, is faster and so on, these are arts and they all deserve respect, sad thing is many of us are fighters thru computer and nothing else
Report spam or abuse
muay thai & pencak silat are my 2 favorite but I just witnessed Kali fully for the 1st time and I'm impressed
Report spam or abuse
There are rules even in MMA and rightly so. No eye strikes, groin shots, kicking when the opponent is down. these can change the outcome of the fight. I agree with BJ pen when he "said" that a lot of MMA, not necessarily UFC, is watered down.   
Report spam or abuse
silat is form indonesia
Report spam or abuse
ese debilucho de kali ,,,,,,,,,,,, 
Report spam or abuse
this episode is all about kali escrima.A filipino martial arts ilove this VIDEO i also learn this in my school
Report spam or abuse
i love Filipino martial arts...and also Thailand martial arts...
Report spam or abuse
Pencak silat from indonesia.
Report spam or abuse
Report spam or abuse
I really like the way they bow.. Im also an anisador but i want to learn silat too...both of them are amazing! Indonesia and Phils. rocks!
Report spam or abuse
Demo only no real combat involved.
Report spam or abuse
Report spam or abuse
this is all just for show. 
Report spam or abuse
most of the military today in the world used kali or filipino fighting system, gather than any of the other martial arts.
Report spam or abuse
Report spam or abuse
Kali philosophy is different.... The approach of Kali in the fight scene is focused on weapons and improvised weapons..... As much as possible, you avoid fighting with empty hands.... Empty hands are used only in a very desperate situation where you cannot find any weapons such as knife or stick or scissor, screw driver, pencil etc.... The logic is simple... You have more chances of winning if you fight with "weapons" than fighting with empty hands.....  
Report spam or abuse
Report spam or abuse
Though I prefer Kali, both are formidable arts that utilise great techniques that exhibit both flair and practicality. This was a great demonstration.
Report spam or abuse
Hey Kali is Silat, Kali from Majapahit Kingdom From Indonesia or Nusantara
Report spam or abuse
lol... any Kali master will disagree with you... Kali is hybrid art.. it has judo ,aikido, jiujitsu, silat, western boxing, and kick boxing.... it is The Filipino MMA.... 
Report spam or abuse
what this language?Romeno? 
Report spam or abuse
kali vs silat???? it's just like ur comparing an airplane into car..
Report spam or abuse
Report spam or abuse
I know, were part of the same supeior race, Austronesian. I know that some pinoy talk a lot but I know that indonesian do to. Its annoying when people like that, I meant no disrespect either. You seem to know about Indonesian culture, hopefully. So maybe you can teach me some. Like your guy's empires. the Sir and the Maj
Report spam or abuse
Report spam or abuse
Report spam or abuse
Both are great arts that originate from the regions of the world. I think the best is not Kali nor Silat, but learning both and combining them.
Report spam or abuse
Do your homework man.. Eskrima/Kali is a complete system which involves armed and unarmed combat techniques which is way different fom MMA which is a sport.. skilled MMA fighter vs skilled Eskrima/Kali practitioner?.. we'll who knows it depends on the skill of the fighter and how fast effective one can opt for an opening/opportunity to strike. For physical conditioning and strength I go for MMA, But for effectiveness and practically in real world scenarios I would go for Eskrima/Kali. MABUHAY!
Report spam or abuse
The Brazilians have merged the two into one Personal Defense Training... /watch?v=R4KFuYwM3zs this art is growing here, the number of practitioners to increase In Brazil the problem of melee weapons like knives and machetes is great, this is the best training to learn how to defend and attack with them. Along with Kombato (Krav Maga modified in Brazil) Here the civilian can not have firearms in the street, at home only for the defense of property ... have to defend themselves in the streets!
Report spam or abuse
calm down bro the raid taun 2007 belumlah tayang, sekarang bnyk orang europe & amerika pada penasaran.....mungkin akan berguru ke indonesia ha......ha...ha....
Report spam or abuse
Report spam or abuse
Really excellent video. So exciting to watch, im happy there is a kali school near by!
Report spam or abuse
Report spam or abuse
whats a difrent between this two martial art..
Report spam or abuse
i'm Filipino and i don't know this technique i'm a faggot seriously i want to learn this martial arts
Report spam or abuse
if u dont know material art ( pencak silat, karate , kung fu etc) dont to much speak..
Report spam or abuse
Report spam or abuse
woww2 hold ur horses dude.silat is actually originated from malaysia.please get ur facts right.....
Report spam or abuse
Report spam or abuse
what the fuck is that silat??? this not silat, this called "silap"
Report spam or abuse
'Silat batin' is the most deadly
Report spam or abuse
your point is?...we were colonialized by the dutch, but then we and by our effort alone that kick the dutch ass back to europe.
Report spam or abuse
why is this simulated in such a large crowd and on Eurosport?
Report spam or abuse
excuse me for sounding ignorant, but which is which?
Report spam or abuse
for all of you, `Kali` is a new term, it invented by Inosanto. the old terms in FMA are eskrima, arnis, dumog and even..SILAT. Inosanto system is actually blend system that consists heavy silat influence.
Report spam or abuse
im a filipino but silat is very very cool.... and very tough to master.... kali is tough to master too... :)
Report spam or abuse
Oh PLEASE... THIS IS NOT SILAT.. DON'T BE STUPID!
Report spam or abuse
Wow!silat is good in this video
Report spam or abuse
terang aja kali menang yg silat cuma karung asah pukulan gak melawan banyak bacot lo semua sini gw hajar muka lo pada bebek
Report spam or abuse
It's to slow movement based on scenario, silat using fast movement in fight, and slow movement in kuda-kuda and in ekstrim one that we called KEBATHINAN, This performance is bad, cause using scripts. ACTUALLY THIS IS NOT PENCAK SILAT, It's stupid thing to said those pencak silat. The Two Bold man are already position as winner before the game show, hehehehehe........... STUPID TWO BOLD MAN, You just acting like CLOWN, hehehehe.......
Report spam or abuse
Silat is better, but KALI is the best!!
Report spam or abuse
wtf are u saying best serial killers in the world .. no ur did wrong we are the most finest killers in the world... xD
Report spam or abuse
Pelajari perkembangannya juga dong Om
Report spam or abuse
and also martial arts of Malaysia.my country.and im javanese btw :)
Report spam or abuse
Report spam or abuse
Report spam or abuse
it is a fact that indonesia was conquered by the dutch. but that is not me that saying them self as `genetically warrior` nation. i just react on silly comment that saying pinoy are inborn warior.
Report spam or abuse
type this on youtube: `eskrimadors a brief story`
Report spam or abuse
Oh, is that so ? Where are in MMA the pressure point manipulation, the eye-gouging, the throat strikes, wrist locks, small joints manipulation, and actually most of ancient martial arts' most dangerous techniques ? They are banned from it, because they are too dangerous for it. MMA is a sport, it isn't martial : it has a ridiculous amount of limitations and rules which lessens its efficiency in real combat. MMA can hurt a lot, sure, but real martial arts are designed to kill.
Report spam or abuse
Show more Loading...
Sign in to add this to Watch Later

Add to