Upload

Prizefight: 'Guitar Hero 3' vs. 'Rock Band'

by CNET • 136,443 views

Brian Tong brings you a battle of the bands between 'Guitar Hero 3' and 'Rock Band.' Who rocks harder? The Prizefight ring will decide it all.

Report spam or abuse
Rock band is just a lame ripoff of guitar hero the only new thing is drums and the rockband guitar controller sucks compared to guitar hero. I own both and guitar hero 3 is 10x better.
Report spam or abuse
+Kentavious! true idk why I said this, but yeah I realize now that rock band isn't a ripoff, although I have both and prefer guitar hero mainly for its controller being better.
Report spam or abuse
The people who did GH1+2 went on to do rock band, GH3 and on was a completely different developer, but you can't say rock band is a rip off when its made by the same people who made the first guitar hero
Report spam or abuse
Yea rock band won and guitar hero sucks
Report spam or abuse
yes rock band rules but the down side is your money
Report spam or abuse
Report spam or abuse
Everyone who is saying "This guy knows nothing" and "Guitar hero has drums too." This is an old video! This was before guitar hero had drums! Rock Band won this by far. Also the neck in-game is a more solid color,so it doesn't look like a mess,that is more so a personal preference. 
Report spam or abuse
this guy knows nothing.
Report spam or abuse
rock band better graphics good sound track but low settings like you cant pick a charicter
Report spam or abuse
brian tong hasn't aged a day!
Report spam or abuse
Report spam or abuse
guitar hero awsome sound track awsome settings there both good
Report spam or abuse
guitar hero have singing drumming and bass too sucker
Report spam or abuse
Report spam or abuse
Wrong, Rock Band didn't copy anything. The company that made Rock Band made the first two Guitar Hero's (Harmonix). After Guitar Hero 2, Activison took over, and made Guitar Hero 3, while Harmonix made Rock Band 1.
Report spam or abuse
Fuck you in guitar hero you can play 2 guitar and a drum and a mike
Report spam or abuse
@skullkid9830 They did? Well at least I have my Beatles and Metallica game.
Report spam or abuse
it shows someone using x box controller on gh3
Report spam or abuse
guitar hero es muchisimo mejor q el rock band!!
Report spam or abuse
Guitar hero 3 > Rockband 1 and 2 Rock Band 1 and 2 > GH 2, World Tour, 5, Warriors of Rock
Report spam or abuse
ROCKBAND is much more party factor but GH3 is harder
Report spam or abuse
Report spam or abuse
they should make a ratchet and clank vs jak and daxter prizefight
Report spam or abuse
You are really wrong, Konami's Guitar Freaks was out YEARS before harmonix even knew what was good. So really, Hamonix is more of a thief for stealing an original idea.
Report spam or abuse
@xXGhilliedxSamuraiXx im just there IS band hero
Report spam or abuse
Report spam or abuse
Rock band is the way better!
Report spam or abuse
@skullkid9830 any time man! just a lover of rockband and I want everybody to be able to have the fun that I have with the game.
Report spam or abuse
@yukikodethmetal666 fair enough if you found it easy, but i like it due to the fact the beatles are my fav band so its fun to play the music
Report spam or abuse
rock band es una mierda copia de guitar hero puto ignorante
Report spam or abuse
recount recount guitar hero is way better
Report spam or abuse
Report spam or abuse
@xXGhilliedxSamuraiXx they were actually the same price lol, but i agree that rock band awesome
Report spam or abuse
@2001spacegodzilla Band Hero is literally the worst of all music games. The song choice was nasty, the drum kit was hilariously designed, and the character models in game looked like people from Whoville.
Report spam or abuse
So they had the right to take there ideas and put it into a new game, which was Rock Band.
Report spam or abuse
Report spam or abuse
fuck you gay!!! fuck band hero guitar hero is better!!!!!!
Report spam or abuse
Chinese fucking crazy ¬ ¬ xbxer
Report spam or abuse
Rock bands better it was the first makers of GH GH2 and then they invented the best game ever rock band.......The games better the graphics the drums the DLC the gameplay and everything the makers who took guitar hero that is acitvison fucken took the drums experience and the looks from rock band and look what happen to them now guitar hero whent bankrupt because no one what to buy it anymore and plus they shutoff there DLC now but rock band didn't shutt down there DLC it comes with new DLC eve
Report spam or abuse
guitar hero is dead and rock band is not. i think who the winner is
Report spam or abuse
don't forget the future - later that fall gh4 came out with drums and microphone so now guitar hero wins!!!!!!!!!!!!
Report spam or abuse
Report spam or abuse
Report spam or abuse
Report spam or abuse
I have gh3 and I KNOW it's the best!
Report spam or abuse
Without Harmonix (Rock Band developpers), there wouldn't even be GH3 in fact not even GH: Warriors of Rock, and Activision is not making any GH: Franchise anymore... Their bankruptcy was involved about instrument peripherals cost.
Report spam or abuse
Why can't they make a mix named rock hero?
Report spam or abuse
you can use guiter hero guitars for rock band and rock band guitars for guitar hero
Report spam or abuse
Actual instrument beats both!!
Report spam or abuse
guitar hero is fantastic rock band is loser
Report spam or abuse
Guitat hero is more challenging compared to rovk band
Report spam or abuse
okey i say like this i play gh and i love it and i also think it is better than rock band becouse it is harder so i say like this rockband is for newbies and gh for masters :D SUCK ON THAT!
Report spam or abuse
you forgot this is the only guitar hero with computer guitar battle's but i go with gh5 :P
Report spam or abuse
Rockband ist der größte Scheiß, den ich auf meiner X-Box hatte. Die Songs sind voll Gammel, außerdem ist das voll scheiße Virtuell Gittarre zu spielen mit richtigen Saiten. Es gibt auch für Guitar-Hero viel Zubehör und meiner Meinung ist ein Drummset total unnötig, denn es heißt Guitar Hero. Unser Fazit: Rockband ist scheiße
Report spam or abuse
guitar hero 3 has better songs, the first points will be 5 for guitar hero and 3 for rock band
Report spam or abuse
@tony19o8 Rock Band didn't copy Guitar Hero because Harmonix made the first three guitar hero's (Guitar Hero, Guitar Hero 2 and Guitar Hero Rocks The 80's) and then they sold Guitar Hero to Neversoft and decided to make Rock Band.
Report spam or abuse
@basinger232 like i said thats just his opinion, i agree with u gh3 has better songs. the songs r not that hard so dont pay attention to that asian guy he dont know shit.
Report spam or abuse
i like the rock band game but i prefer G hero controllers. (drum, guitar)
Report spam or abuse
@DrumDrumDrumDrumBoy Very True. But technically you could flip tht statement 2. If Harmonix never struck gold with guitar hero there probably would be no rock band today.
Report spam or abuse
guitar hero has a mic and drums TOO. you idiot
Report spam or abuse
Both are good, but Guitar Hero is much better in my opinion.
Report spam or abuse
guitar hero 3 is better it has got better songs !!!!
Report spam or abuse
WTF!? just because you suck at guitar hero dosen't mean rock band is better
Report spam or abuse
Seriosly, theres easier difficulties if you are a "newb".. Jesus.
Report spam or abuse
big fat ass bullshit while i like rockband more people will find it addicting because it will make them stretch their limits to become a better rocker
Report spam or abuse
Rock band only because the drums
Report spam or abuse
Report spam or abuse
Report spam or abuse
@pierLuD9319 indeed on guitar hero 4 not on guitar hero 3...read the title instead of trolling
Report spam or abuse
the first game of rock band is easier than gh but rb 2 and 3 are WAY harder
Report spam or abuse
He never mentions that you can't see the hammer ons while playing guitar on Rock Band!
Report spam or abuse
Report spam or abuse
Report spam or abuse
did you just know rock band was better because it was later? rock band is the first edition of the saga because was maked for be best than GH3? no? well, is GH3 and is older than RB, you compare super mario bross with new super mario bross wii, jackass, kill yourself fucking blonde chinese nigga with pink slips
Report spam or abuse
I find RB fret feel better than guitar hero and I play proper guitar
Report spam or abuse
Guitar Hero can suck my nuts. I can't fucking stand the guitar itself and i have both. Now Rock Band being easier is also bullshit cause while it's all in a matter of opinion personally when i put it on expert AND use the cheat to speed the track up i can find myself with more than overwhelmed with songs not to mention my people playing with me need to be just as good to get us through the song. That alone having to put my trust in others to get through pushes the diff. to the limits.
Report spam or abuse
gh 1. stole the f***in drums and mic 2.only has 150 songs 3. is not harder 4.
Report spam or abuse
@Matthew Shea actually rock band didn't copy the makers of gh and gh2 made rock band
Report spam or abuse
only the first rock band wasnt good the rest was
Report spam or abuse
I think Guitar beats both. But i'll say there both better than power gig
Report spam or abuse
Report spam or abuse
Report spam or abuse
guitar hero is better than a rock band!
Report spam or abuse
Report spam or abuse
Report spam or abuse
w8 i saw his last video it sais the PS3 is better then why is the games for x-box?
Report spam or abuse
Hey people! Guess what?! harmonix created gh and rock band. So they're both good. Each have good selections in music and each are easy to play when you learn to play the game.
Report spam or abuse
gh3 has a bass a drumm and microphone
Report spam or abuse
@xXGhilliedxSamuraiXx I play the better game. It is guitar hero. Stop being a retard who cant tell the difference between two music games. Also, Rock band just copies guitar hero. Rock band is a copying no good game.
Report spam or abuse
plus rock band is a copie of guitar hero .... a bad copy
Report spam or abuse
guitar hero warriors of rock can do the same thing as rock band now. WHADDUP!
Report spam or abuse
@SKAlderonn That is what I am saying. Rock Band innovated and that is what mattered. People still argue that GH beats RB but RB led GH to its demise so...
Report spam or abuse
@Killerledgendary Just play with the better game, which is undoubtedly Rock Band.
Report spam or abuse
@CCBlackhawk they only stole the guitar, but then they made drum, microphone, made a WAYYY better guitar, and etc.
Report spam or abuse
Guitar hero sucks. Why 1.guitar hammerons are harder to see 2.drum set looks shitty 3.vocals are horrible. Rock band is much better and guitar hero is like rock band but shitty
Report spam or abuse
Report spam or abuse
Report spam or abuse
im a rock band guy to but this was a fanboy review
Report spam or abuse
Guitar hero copied rock band. Guitar hero sucks ass. Rock band is much better
Report spam or abuse
@videovader101 gameplay > graphics. Why are people so in love with graphics now days. Having fun is better that how good looking a character model is
Report spam or abuse
Show more Loading...
Sign in to add this to Watch Later

Add to