Upload

Mariah Carey VS Mimi: Live Vocal Range : G#2 - G#7

by Aang Carey • 11,550 views

This Is The Vocal Comparison Between Mariah Carey Vs Mimi. They're The Same Person. But, in The Different Era. Mariah Carey's Live Vocal Range : B2 - G#7 Mimi's Live Vocal Range : G#2 - Eb7 Low...

FFS, Mimi is from 2004 to present.
Report spam or abuse
mariah's headvoice runs can be seen on dreamlover
Report spam or abuse
my saving grace G5 sharp and the following A6 are clearly lipped
Report spam or abuse
Mariah sings more soul music and mimi sings whatever comes anyways i love mariah and mimi
Report spam or abuse
Mariah... Mimi, ñ sei dizer 'qal' é a melhor, só sei de uma coisa, ela é cantora mais completa e versatil de todos os tempos, soube se reiventar cm o passar ds tempos, ditou tendencias, canta do R&B, Jaz ao Hip Hip Hop, simplesmente a melhor
Report spam or abuse
The singing style, it's' like two different vocalists... Mariah, just wow, her versatility is beyond amazing!
Report spam or abuse
I love Mimi and mariah but I have to say Mimi won
Report spam or abuse
I Was after butterfly.. Walter Afanasieff worked with her on my all && most of the songs on butterfly :)
Report spam or abuse
Report spam or abuse
she has belted an A5 live before though
Report spam or abuse
I really love mariah , the way she sings and her dress choice was very beautiful and touch my heart , and i don't really see that in Mimi ,,but both voice was amazing
Report spam or abuse
Report spam or abuse
ALL THE SAME TO ME... I LOVE THIS WOMENS VOICE!!
Report spam or abuse
I bet I can burp in C1. And sneeze in C8.
Report spam or abuse
whould you rather she not lipped, sang the hard parts? shell end up damaging her nodules and will kill her voice off forever. id rather she lipped and sing live when her voice is in good shape.
Report spam or abuse
Report spam or abuse
Blue Diva out of fifth element eat your heart out.
Report spam or abuse
Hear this!!!!!! Mariah : Like To Hit A Belt notes But not As High As MIMI Mimi : Like To Hit A Whistle. But not As High As Mariah For me, they're all the best. because they're the same person. just have different voice.
Report spam or abuse
What show id mariah performing in at 5:35?
Report spam or abuse
It was due to people loving Mariah that she became mimi. Wake up people ....
Report spam or abuse
and haters say that the whistles in IWKWLI are lipped .. look the difference!
Report spam or abuse
Report spam or abuse
Well, even though it is the same person, mariah wins on everything, EXCEPT the lows "MIMI" had better ones, not to mention she could go lower, which is always more difficult than going higher. Nice Vid btw
Report spam or abuse
Damn! Love Mariah more, but mimi has a few good songs too. regardless, it's the same person and she has a great voice!
Report spam or abuse
Report spam or abuse
I Think It was 1996 she stopped working with Walter Afanasieff...... Her work was so much better with him
Report spam or abuse
Mariah carey can do whatever mimi can do mimi cant do what mariah can Co'z She is limited That why Mimi try hard to be so much better than mariah ....
Report spam or abuse
@jesparza562 heller acutally mimi has the higher chest range. mariah went to a G5. mimi has gone to an A5. really mimi has the bigger range:) but let's not forget that "they" is a "her" and that she ain't no differnt haha
Report spam or abuse
WHATS IS NAME THE FIRST SONG ? !!! PLEASE HELP MEE!!!
Report spam or abuse
Report spam or abuse
@trmimi1970 Heartbreaker.. (Forget Where it was Performed)
Report spam or abuse
Report spam or abuse
@marco1416 i know that.... 1997 she was mimi. because she has changed some kind of her music (Music style)
Report spam or abuse
Mariah= Better mid range and belting Mimi= Better lower range, head voice and whistle Both amazing.
Report spam or abuse
@RomuloVideos2 When She Change Her Music Style (Butterfly Era) 1997
Report spam or abuse
I think her Longest is the belt at the end of "Lead The Way" - 18 - 20 secs.
Report spam or abuse
Actually Mariah Carey is 1990-2003 and Mimi was 2004------------
Report spam or abuse
Report spam or abuse
As a baritone, I'm offended someone would actually consider that a real G#2.
Report spam or abuse
@hessounusual95 oh crap i was about to say the same thing. 1990-96 are her best eras, so either debut vs emotions eras or music box vs daydream eras should be interesting. after that, it's either hit or miss for the most part :/
Report spam or abuse
Report spam or abuse
I really, really don't like this separation of years. I think it should be 90-99 Mariah, 00-present Mimi. Yes Mimi peeked her head in a few times, but you can't say Mimi emerged at ANY POINT that she was still signed to Sony. The two can't coexist. 90's Mariah and 00's Mimi are two different eras.
Report spam or abuse
This is for live only, Lead The Way was never performed live.
Report spam or abuse
Thank You! WOW loveeeee her high notes always!! :D
Report spam or abuse
To be honest i like "Mimi" her voice is so airy & silky, and WITHOUT a doubt her whistles were more beautifully controlled
Report spam or abuse
Report spam or abuse
this is ridiculous...Mariah is Mariah.Mimi is her surname and she will never change.
Report spam or abuse
lets remember mariah was when she was younger and easier mimi is like a fine bottle of whine the more it ages the better it gets so lets see what she will bring to her next album i hope its a mixture of both mimi and mariah!!!
Report spam or abuse
I love both Mariah Carey and Mimi and I want Mariah's voice back!!!!!!!!!
Report spam or abuse
What the differences of Mariah Carey and MIMI.. Can someone tell to me..
Report spam or abuse
Report spam or abuse
range is just approximate but I love Mariah Carey cuz crystal voice and Mimi has rough voice though :D
Report spam or abuse
Her voice gives me chills. She is a music legend. She was and always will be amazing.
Report spam or abuse
Report spam or abuse
Both, plus her Bb6's sound exactly the same
Report spam or abuse
mimi lower range is better but mariah had a better higher chest rang
Report spam or abuse
Been a fan since Vision of Love - yes I remember when the video was on MuchMusic - but MiMi - she is so free and creative now - this si the real her
Report spam or abuse
Love both but perfer the original MARIAH CAREY <3
Report spam or abuse
Report spam or abuse
the only acceptable competition against Mariah is Mariah herself :) she's incomparable.
Report spam or abuse
Report spam or abuse
Her mid range was so effortless back then
Report spam or abuse
i think mimi exust since charmbracelet era not 97.. IMO lol
Report spam or abuse
@jesparza562 yeah, i think so..... but, they're all the best for me. however the voice is different, but the vocal range never change. and, i love mimi in her Butterfly Era
Report spam or abuse
I Dont Like MiMi To Much , Mariah Was Raw , Easy On The Upper Belts , MiMi Has More Versitality With Her Notes But I Juss Perfer Mariah
Report spam or abuse
Can i know whats the opening song? Thanx!
Report spam or abuse
i actually think that mimis whistles are way better than mariahs, she did her highest whistle as mariah but mimi seems to have more control cleaner sound and does little tunes instead of single notes (with the exception of the beautiful dream lover whistle) :)
Report spam or abuse
Report spam or abuse
@MrButler124 sorry, mariah's highest chest is G#5 a half lower than MIMI
Report spam or abuse
Report spam or abuse
Report spam or abuse
Mariah, obviously. Not only did she sing her difficult songs/notes live, but they SOUNDED a billion times better back then too.
Report spam or abuse
Report spam or abuse
Sign in to add this to Watch Later

Add to