Phoenix's demise SPOILERS

SPOILERS FOR SGA: 4x20




The Phoenix goes down a la Pegasus.

For those who haven't seen the episode and are freaking out, the reset button is pushed at the end.

Category:

Entertainment

Tags:

• sga
• stargate
• atlantis
• phoenix
• daedalus
• carter
• wraith

[Roebot56]

@attilantis I believe it is actually the USS George Hammond.

[SamHelenCarterMagnus]

I am so gald Sheppard changed the timeline or I would've shot someone. Sam Carter is a awesome character.

[GangsterHutterite]

That's one hell of a way to go.

[TheShadowwolf88]

The noble end of the Phoenix and her commander!

A TRUE heroic and glorious death!

[tenthousandhairs]

@xRAYKOx and @fmcc0904 i have not read your debate so i am not taking sides but why argue about crap when you canjust sit back and enjoy an awesome program

[TheIcelandicPatriot]

Now there is only one way for a ship of war to go down and that by taking down atleast one other mother fucker with them.

[fmcc0904]

@xRAYKOx Already read what you said, btw. Yes, it's late, but you replied straight away, so calling me immature for posting at "4 in the morning" is a tad hypocritical as not only did you do the same, but you did it less than 20 minutes after I thoroughly debunked your entire argument. Retcon certainly does matter in a case like this, because it shows sloppiness on the part of the writers and makes you look like a fool for trying to come out looking intelligent. But the point is, no one is right

[fmcc0904]

@xRAYKOx But to add - I recall quite clearly that the Vegas Sheppard did not track with what 3x08 McKay described. And? Please, do yourself a favor and look up RETCON. It's a fairly simple concept, used by writers who grow lazy and/or don't care if the fans notice a discrepancy within one of the story arcs/subplots/etc of a show they work on. It's what happened there. Keep on trying to appear intelligent; you're only in denial.

[fmcc0904]

@xRAYKOx End point is: I know all 3 series (even though only half of SGU was watchable) far better, as well as the idiotic cock-ups made by the production team, and putting those two together is so incredibly simple. Why it's beyond your ability, I have no idea. But there it is. I don't think anyone will deny that the writing style in Season 5 of SGA took a nosedive (for the most part) and we learned later it was because of the trash they were working on alongside, and considered a priority.

[fmcc0904]

@xRAYKOx I believe the now-vilified Wright and Mallozzi even admitted to fouling up the continuity to make "Vegas" as in retrospect they were "getting bored" with making Atlantis and were eager to get started on their new pet project (which failed miserably, btw), Universe. Apparently, that was one of the few episodes in the last season of SGA they "enjoyed" making, so they took a few liberties and went on a whim, trying to use a previous-episode reference even though it didn't track.