LOTR Be at peace, Son of Gondor
Uploader Comments (PennySmart)
Video Responses
All Comments (132)
-
great libertytaking in writing, great soundtrack and brilliant performance.
-
like if you think Boromir shouldn't have died
-
Greater love hath no man than this. That he lay down his life for his friends.
-
Man tear.
-
this is the most emotional scene in LOTR... I almost drop my tear on this first time when he said: MY KING...
-
No disrespect to tolkien, but this scene was waaaay better than the one in the book!
-
"I would have followed you. My brother. My captain. My king..."
Some of the most moving lines in that trilogy.
-
Long live the Captain of Gondor,
may his strengh fail him never,
may his reign last forever,
first in battle,
last in retreat
Long live Boromir,
even in death.
-
I think the beauty of this scene is in two things.
1: The acting. Amazing actors, both of them.
2: The honesty of it. We know that Boromir was a captain of Gondor, kind, courageous, and hopeful. He was merely twisted by the malice of the Ring. The viciousness of his character towards Frodo was not a reflection of his true intentions (I believe). Yet here we have this leader of Gondor who is completely believing "the world of men will fall." He was hopeless.
I think that Boromir was my favorite. Yes he tried to take the ring and would have done anything to get it. BUT he always wanted to do what was best for his people. He didnt want to go Rivendell when his father told him too. He wanted to stay and defend Gondor. But his fathers dark persuasion led him to the fellowship, and his doom. Did he do wrong in trying to take the ring yes. He always had the best intentions though. To save his people.
GT12331 2 months ago 3
@GT12331 Yes, I do agree with you and I also like Boromir. However I think it goes further than just him being mistaken: I think, within the story, the ring power maliciously knows how to make people bend to its will for whatever reason works for them. In the case of Boromir, it's saving his city and people.
PennySmart 2 months ago
Some of the best acting I've ever seen on Bean's part. Few people would know how hard it is to act like your dying, coughing up blood, having trouble breathing, being in extreme pain and being ashamed and fearful at the same time....good stuff.
ethongmurr 10 months ago 68
@ethongmurr Very true. That may be why the scene is so moving.
PennySmart 10 months ago 19