Top Comments
All Comments (60)
-
@loyestor1951 I know,that tells how good both of them are. Both were still powerful vocals to overcome being sick. That proves how their talent came through and why they won.
-
@row759 Someone said that Kelly was sick during the championship round and still won. Carrie was sick too and won. That is my point.
-
@loyestor1951 no, because Carrie explained that she got so tried from 2 straight months of this contest that at the end so vulernable that you pick a cold. It just proves how good Carrie's vocals are. Even though she was sick she still won.
-
1:52 gives me chills everytime...such a natural effortless voice...
-
@pinecone1999..i know right? there arent too many artists nowadays that sound just as amazing as they do in their cds! examples, mariah,celine,kelly clarkson and more that im forgetting lol
-
@Siggy4844...agreed!!
-
@twentin08 I agree. like these two are my favorite. when carrie underwood season i rooted for bruce . but thats becuz i was only 12 and thought he was hot haha but carrie is amazing.
-
love that bitch so much carrie rock
-
Is it a coincidence that the two best idol champions were sick during the championship round???
-
MAGNIFICENT!!!!!!!!!



There is no doubt that Kelly Clarkson and Carrie Underwood are the most successful AI winners, you don't even hear from Ruben, Fantasia, Taylor and Jordin anymore. Album sales and airplay speak louder than titles. This was one of the few seasons where the voters got it right. I liked Bo Bice and he might have won another season but he had to go against Carrie Underwood and she was simply better than him.
Siggy4844 2 years ago 91
I'd put Kelly Clarkson and Carrie Underwood as the best American Idols :)
twentin08 3 years ago 84