Objective Morality vs. Christianity [William Lane Craig]
Sign in to YouTube
Sign in to YouTube
Sign in to YouTube
Uploaded on Aug 29, 2011
I don't think that arguing against objective morality, or arguing FOR it but towards a naturalistic source, are the only options. Take a look at what happens when we (even hypothetically) concede that it has a theistic basis! It certainly doesn't do Christianity any favors.
Twitter: https://twitter.com/nonstampNSC
SCRIPT IS AT http://www.nonstampcollector.com/mora...
OTHERS at http://www.nonstampcollector.com/main
Why couldn't an objective morality simply make sense? Why does looking at morality through the lens of Christianity make such LITTLE sense? Well, it's obvious why - Christianity and its god is nonsense. There could be no clearer sign that Christianity is a man-made bunch of bollocks, than to look at its claims on objective morality. All these special pleadings about context and new vs old covenants are the dying gasps of a belief system that before long won't have anyone even TRYING to make it make sense. You'd be better off trying to argue that Joseph Fritzl is the greatest father that the world has ever known (within a certain context).
Look elsewhere for an objective moral law giver, other than Christianity, for the god that you are convinced must exist. It can't hurt - and the bible has caused enough problems on this planet, with its contradictory and wicked claims and commands. Don't support, or give cover, to those who want us to base our modern societies around that absurd mess of a book. Be honest with yourself, and reject it, as people do who take a real, open, honest look at what it says. It isn't divine, it is appallingly man-made. Man-made as in MALE-made, too, quite obviously.
The graphics in this are taken from around the web, I don't claim copyright on any of them and this video is not being used by me to collect any revenue, and is being posted under a Creative Commons license, whatever that means.
-
Category
-
License
Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed)
- Source videos Loading... View attributions
Loading...
Loading...
Loading...
Loading...
Loading...
Next in NonStampCollector in a serious mood
Suggestions
-
9:12
The Ten Commandments- the basis of our laws and moralsby NonStampCollectorFeatured
273,316
-
9:58
Christianity Debateby NonStampCollector
216,732 views
-
9:53
Quiz Show (Bible Contradictions)by NonStampCollector
840,523 views
-
1:01:55
Sam Harris (Beyond Belief 2007)by Religions Suck
15,279 views
-
1:29:20
Is God Necessary for Morality? William Lane Craig vs Shelly Kagan Debateby bdw5000
48,581 views
-
Atheism
89,071 videos2K
-
9:51
Hitchens: religion degrades humanity.by Melvin6566842
143,026 views
-
53:00
William Lane Craig's Post-Debate Thoughts on Sam Harrisby William Lane Craig Videos
17,364 views
-
2:40
Genesis (take #2)by NonStampCollector
56,558 views
-
12:30
How do you know the bible is God's word? (The Atheist Experience)by bdwilson1000
125,677 views
-
8:58
Atheists SECRETLY believe in Yahwehby NonStampCollector
111,194 views
-
7:27
The Eye of the Pythonby NonStampCollector
106,300 views
-
5:46
What Would Yahweh Do?by NonStampCollector
109,632 views
-
4:36
1 Corinthians 13by NonStampCollector
149,291 views
-
9:57
High Stakes Intelligent Designingby NonStampCollector
257,182 views
-
2:56
A new religion. (but more of the same)by NonStampCollector
51,035 views
-
11:06
Is Christian morality psychopathic? (Sam Harris)by bdw5000
57,877 views
-
11:23
Yahweh's Amazing Miracleby NonStampCollector
92,017 views
-
3:26
Five Biggest LIES About Christianityby Edward Current: Comedy & Music
625,057 views
-
6:29
A Personal Relationship with Jesusby NonStampCollector
154,625 views
Uploader Comments (NonStampCollector)
Andy McFarlane 5 days ago
Sorry for having to take two posts
Let's assume:
1. There is a God
2. He has a loving character
3. He has a moral code that He says will bless His people.
Then:
If someone does not abide by that code, for the sake of Himself and love for His code-abiding people (CAP), punishment is in order.
Ex: If someone murders another: the threat of murder can still exist, so to lovingly protect the living CAPs, the threat should be eliminated in love for them.
Sign in to YouTube
Sign in to YouTube
NonStampCollector 5 days ago
OK then.
Let's assume it isn't necessarily that way, that that system looks kinda suitable for humans, but that an infinitely powerful God might have a better way.
Let's assume that God is allowing humans to experience everything; joy, pain,... because we wanted to, and agreed to forget that we'd agreed to it in order to experience those things fully. Let's assume that God agreed to not interfere with our experience of experiencing things.
There's your idea fucked. It only takes imagination.
Sign in to YouTube
Sign in to YouTube
Andy McFarlane 4 days ago
However, if you have the slightest inclination otherwise, I suggest that you carefully consider the choice, and I will remind you that the God with Biblical morality has said that those who reject Him with his justice, mercy, and grace will be rejected.
Sign in to YouTube
Sign in to YouTube
NonStampCollector 4 days ago
OK. Well, I suggest that you carefully consider that you've been misled, and that by committing your life to this god, you are committing your life to a ridiculous fantasy that makes a fool of you.
Sign in to YouTube
Sign in to YouTube
Video Responses
All Comments (2,394)
Patrick Rebstock 4 hours ago
Yes Jesus was incarnated as a human,because humans are the top species. But his soul is Angelic. Now,souls and bodies are diffrent from one another. So any being that has been incarnated as a human could be considered atleast some what human. But when they die they go back to there past status as whatever they are. So,Jesus is now back to his prevous status as a angelic. Yes he has a mother in life. Aliens are another matter,they're just another form of life. There. I've explained it to you. :)
Sign in to YouTube
Sign in to YouTube
Andy McFarlane 6 hours ago
The Bible never really says God's gender, either. Men and women are equal in the sight of God, and honestly, men have really screwed up this world because of greed, lust, pride, etc. But God is not necessarily man, and He isn't corrupt like so many. The best reason I could come up with is that the Bible was written to a Patristic culture where it was common that even if God was gender neutral, "his" would be common terminology as it is today.
Sign in to YouTube
Sign in to YouTube
Andy McFarlane 6 hours ago
Is that what He said? Or did you here that from people claiming to be His people? Maybe even me. The main point God is trying to get across is that sin leads to death- by nature! For so long I was viewing women as objects, lusting after their bodies without a care for their person. And I was being destroyed, I could feel it, and I was hurting them. Their image in my mind had been degraded. God's truth showed me that my sin was leading to death and I needed to be healed for their sake and mine.
Sign in to YouTube
Sign in to YouTube
Andy McFarlane 6 hours ago
By "morality" I was meaning a def. of morality, not the actions of a person. If a god created the world and said that he was the lawgiver, then I'd argue he has the final authority on what is good v. what is evil, not the majority of humans. Being created, we are lower than he. Even if we think the god made a world with "defective brakes," even to question a tyrant would be foolish. But I am here to say YHWH is not a tyrant, but a Father who wants us to be saved from our destructive rebellion.
Sign in to YouTube
Sign in to YouTube
hydrolito 9 hours ago
That is sex not love, if you feed all your needy neighbors as much as yourself you would likely starve.
Sign in to YouTube
Sign in to YouTube
hydrolito 9 hours ago
Jesus if he existed would have been a earth human not an angel from heaven(space alien). It plainly mentions his mother.
Sign in to YouTube
Sign in to YouTube
hydrolito 10 hours ago
Also god's not all knowing in Revelation 20 as needs things looked up in books.(a human invention), sits on a throne (another human invention) Guess with old age he got senile and can no longer stand. LOL
Sign in to YouTube
Sign in to YouTube
hydrolito 10 hours ago
So if a automanufacturer makes cars with defective brakes do you believe his morality is higher? You wouldn't say that about any other creator so why would you say it about a mythical god?
Sign in to YouTube
Sign in to YouTube
hydrolito 11 hours ago
The Bible even calls the believers sheep and fish and you know that they get eaten. Unbelievers called swine and dogs which jews didn't eat so which is better?
Sign in to YouTube
Sign in to YouTube
Andy McFarlane 12 hours ago
You saying something is evil is an expression of your morality, not necessarily absolute morality. Who is to define what is moral? I'd say slaying a dragon that is killing innocent civilians is morally good, but perhaps PETA would say something different. Who is to say one morality is greater than another? If a Creator exists, I'd argue that His morality is higher than any of ours.
Sign in to YouTube
Sign in to YouTube