Rorschach's Journal October 16th, 1985
Top Comments
Video Responses
All Comments (147)
-
I may be in the minority, but this voice actor nailed both Rorschach and Dr. Manhattan (even if any female character was giggle-worthy). And an original score will always beat out a soundtrack. The timing of all components in this scene are perfect, and if you had to pick just one moment from the entire Digital Comic this is it.. This is the one.
-
Rorschach is deep, but has terrible grammar...
-
Admin, you so silly.
-
@girguy101 what a fagit, amirite?
-
REPOST, ADMIN
-
What's the name of background music?
-
@TheMajinTrunks Actually I watched the movie first, and then read the book. I didn't get that problem like your friends did, but I'm also very analytical when it come's to watching movies so I was able to assume the most of it expect the ending which is really the biggest gripe I had with the film. Thought, I do thank to movie, because without it, I wouldn't have picked up the graphic novel nor would have my circle of friends for that matter so the movie did pick up new fans for the comic.
-
@trusttruth1985 Didn't even nottice the age of the comment :P. The movie is good mind you, but it doesn't deliver the kick of the book.. Or even as good a kick as the animated comic. So many things were left out and so many things were just watered down. If you didn't read the book a very usual feeling for a watcher was confusion. Had many friends who hadn't read the book said they just felt confused. It's because the movie is just so shallow on key points. That's the bad part.
-
@TheMajinTrunks Wow that was a 2 year old comment you responded too o.O You know what, since then I understand perfectly what you're talking about. However I do still really enjoy the movie for what it is in that, as a movie, it's solid, but comparatively to the graphic novel it's not nearly as deep or thought provoking.
-
@trusttruth1985 actually the movie did it quite badly. Whole point of the book was ambiguity. Rorschach was a choice and so was Adrian. Weather you chose one or the other, that is left up to you. The reader. Weather rorschach's vision of never compromising was right... was left up to you. You didn't need Night Owl becoming Captain Obvious.
The movie was a washed out version of the book. Just like every other movie based on a book out there. It's not an insult. It's just the truth.
I feel you admin, I feel you.
MinnesotaUnlimited 5 months ago 28
no it didn't. There where parts of both that did and didn't do things right. Example. Rorschach's death was not as well done in the book when the movie's version was deeper more emotional. Stop bitching and wining like every other over sencitive fan of a comic book and stop ruining the enjoyment other people get out of these king of movie's.
trusttruth1985 2 years ago 10