The Who's "Tommy" (pt. 9) - The Acid Queen
Uploader Comments (sbamkmfdmdfmk)
Video Responses
All Comments (16)
-
Just saw the 2012 version of Tommy at the Frankfurt English Theatre, and it was definitely better. Here, the actress has no sense for the role, she not a gypsy and not an acid queen.
-
this is really the only part of the show i had a problem with, i was just thinking how wonderful everyone was doing and how much i enjoyed all of it till this song. i just wish someone who could have done the song justice had been chosen but i understand you gotta do what you gotta do.
-
Gateway playhouse was better
-
yes, I agree, this is pretty bad!! Sorry Poor sweet looking girl! just not the role for you!
-
they could at least lowered the bar for her if she cant sing high then they can change it up so she at least sounds disnat
-
@sbamkmfdmdfmk Once again, I give you credit for memorizing the score and reworking the musical interlude parts (written specifically for the Broadway show) for a three piece band. These are obviously not professional actors, but you did the best with what you had. I used to perform years ago, and Tommy is a show I would have loved to be in.
So, did you direct this?
rumblefishism 1 year ago
@rumblefishism I was the music director and guitarist.
sbamkmfdmdfmk 1 year ago
I try not to judge amateur actors too harshly. For all we know, she tried out for the show thinking that she was just going to be a dancer, but the director decided to cast her in a role which she obviously could not handle vocally. Blame the director for that. At the very least, they should have lowered the key for that poor girl.
rumblefishism 1 year ago
@rumblefishism Actually the actor had more with the lower parts than the higher parts. She's not a rock singer, but she's a great actress which is why we went with her. We had a very limited pool of auditionees (almost everyone who tried out was cast in the show) so we chose the best option based on our choices.
sbamkmfdmdfmk 1 year ago
@sbamkmfdmdfmk That's surprising that only a limited number of people turned up for auditions; Tommy is a popular show--especially with young people.
I saw a production of Tommy where the Acid Queen was a transvestite male, and surprisingly, it worked really well.
rumblefishism 1 year ago
@rumblefishism I was surprised with the low audition turnout too, but it also wasn't a full community theatre show. It was a school-based production at the Avondale School District in Michigan with a company made up of alumni, teachers, and current students from there.
sbamkmfdmdfmk 1 year ago