the doctor and rose:elusive- my tribute to rose tyler

does what it says on the tin- moviemaker was being a right pain so this isn't as good as i wanted it to be- especially the end. By the end i was sick of the sight of it so here is is. of course all belongs to the BBC and the song is by Scott matthews

Category:

Entertainment

Tags:

• doctor
• rose
• love
• elusive
• billie
• piper
• david
• tennant
• christopher
• eccleston
• who

[PINKKYLIELOUISE]

The compainions don't always have to be in love with the Doctor or vice versa it's about friendship and adventure watching Dr Who again I nothing really against Rose it was her family more then anything I didn't like and the way she treated her boyfriend also not keen on Billie Piper seen her live not very nice In the past it was about the DOCTOR AND THE ADVENTURES THAT THEY WERE HAVING AND THE ACTORS THAT PLAYED THE DOCTOR WERE ALOT OLDER SO IT WAS MORE STUDENT TEACHER OR FATHER THING

[04nbod]

no they don't but the pining after him is annoying.When you mean seen billie live do you mean singing? because that really has nothing to do with her acting. Times have changed and each doctor/companion relationship is different. Rose did learn from the doctor anyway. I think you have to let the classic series be in the past and embrace the new series as something different if you want to get the most out of it

[PINKKYLIELOUISE]

Good video But Ohh my god I cannot understand all this fuss over Rose Billie Pipers crap the only thing she knew how to do was batt her eye lashes there was much better companions then her Martha better dosn't love herself as much as Rose did

[04nbod]

i disagree- martha is bland and unoriginal and all she does is moan the doctor doesn't fancy her. I think Rose is the best companion ever, no offence to the old ones but Rose had character development that no other assistant had even martha(so far)Rose was far more of a real person- she had qualities that were unlikable like anyone did but in the end it was balanced out by her good qualities.

[PINKKYLIELOUISE]

Thanks for that I'll try too cause I absolutley loved the final episode this week absolutley ace hope John Simms isn't really killed off and come on Rose fans Martha was good too this season has been the best not enough Daleks though sorry I know negative but without no bad there be no good sometimes it helps to be alittle negatives so things can be improved I really wish I never said anything negative about Rose now too many fans cool video

[cluby17]

Oh, PINKKYLIELOUISE , What's with the bitter comments???

...I really(and i mean REALLY) don't care if you like our dear rose OR NOT, that's YOUR problem, BUT what's the need for being so harsh,...You should, instead of always looking just for the bad in "things" you don't like, that's so pessimistic, and so sad...look for the bright side, it always makes it more light to watch and to live with.

[PINKKYLIELOUISE]

I think if the Doctor always fell in love the relationship wouldn't be as meaningful or as special at least both Martha and Rose want to go exploring with the Doctor companions in the past use to always moan when they got there. I Like it when a companions not quite as smart the Doctor abit like Rose was as long as they are not popping back to see her annoying Mother all the time.

[PINKKYLIELOUISE]

Yes I mean singing it's when she spoke to the crowd I'm on about and the actings not all that great either and I don't like any of the old Doctor Whos my brother's the fan I like the new ones I like the episodes with Dalecks in and this Season been the best David Tennant's finally got his grove but Martha's not as good as I first thought and didn't the doctor in the past use to have more then one companion.

[Rabid1st]

Pretty cool. I like the song and I love that you've used rare clips that really show Billie's range. She could give so much with a look. It was heartbreaking.

Rae

[Padme0]

ohh the song is beautiful. The video was also well made^^ good job.