Dr. Felisa Wolfe-Simon @ NASA Sums Up Her Findings On New Life Forms
Uploader Comments (frednikgohar)
Top Comments
-
Her paper has now been shown to be extremely flawed, and fellow scientists are saying she should never have published it.
-
@robert7f Dear Robert, that's not the way science works. If this woman wants to shift a paradigm she has to provide conclusive evidence. She is not perfectly honest, she is biased and misleading.
All Comments (21)
-
What ever kept you up at night lead to this amazing discovery, but that doesn't mean you will find the meaning or origin of life using scientific test.
-
She should have Grabbed one of all the birds on the lake and tested THEM with higher levels of arsenic. Go Big or Go Home.
-
This research has been discredited. The scientific community is united in declaring that none of the data presented support the conclusions. The two researchers are now perpetrating a deception.
-
I remember when this aired here in NZ last year, and want to know if she has discovered anything new from her findings? thanks
-
@frednikgohar I do agree indeed that its nice to have things like this to stir the pot. I just wish people like our distinguished panel knew what was in the pot first hehe. Thanks for the post! and GO NASA!
-
Ha ha ha ha .... an now the so called "scientific evidence" seem to be just bullshit!!
-
@trevorbuvyer Yeah she really does sound like one.
Sorry but I think this paper does not prove that Arsenic can do diddly. The controls sucked, but the author has proved one thing. She can always find work in theatre....perhaps this what NASA's new role is haha....ah all the best.
dinofernando11 1 year ago
@dinofernando11 I'm no scientist but I am aware of how much controversy this paper has caused... and i did a disfavor by not posting including the dissenting voice that was present at this press conference. And it certainly doesn't help that the esteemed scientist comes accross more as a 2nd grade teacher than a... well... scientist.
However, I do think the very notion that disputes current thinking about Life, is a good kick-in-the-a** to think outside the box...
Best,
/F
frednikgohar 11 months ago