Historical Errors / Contradictions of Luke Pt 3

Peter accuses the wrong Annas of killing Jesus. Also Peter states that Jesus was killed and then hung on a tree which totally contradicts all the New Testament Gospel accounts. Theudas was killed by Cuspius Fadus between 44 and 46 CE, and Judas of Galilee was killed in the year 6 CE, yet this passage in Acts 5 states this happened after the death of Theudas. It was not Judas, but, his two sons that were killed between 46 and 48 CE. This can be found in Josephus's "Antiquities of the Jews", Book 20, chapter 5.

Category:

Education

Tags:

• bible
• errors
• christian
• atheist
• gnostic
• history
• josephus
• contradictions
• peter
• church

[00AliIbnAbiTalib00]

My friend 90% of the high priests during the first century are from the same family : the family of Anan. Ananus saw jesus before Kaiphas did. He wasnt the hig priest but because he was the elder in the family, he was still considered somehow high priest.

[ForBibletruth]

@00AliIbnAbiTalib00, The High Priest at the time was Ananias ben Nebedeus, who served from 46 to 52 CE. The Ananus you refer to was removed in the year 15 CE.

[straygypsy]

Hmmmmm..

I thought the last King of the Jews was King Agrippa?

He was the true "anointed one" that was killed in 44 AD.

This also throws the Christian doctrine out the window..

[ForBibletruth]

King Agrippa did die in 44CE. He is called Herod in Acts chapter 12. The Herod I refer to in this video is Herod V, also known as Herod of Chalcis, who died in 48CE. He was Agrippa's brother. The Agrippa who Paul appears before is Agrippa II, and was promoted sometime after his uncle Herod died. Agrippa II was only 17 years old when his father died, so he was kept in Rome, and Cuspius Fadus became the first Roman Procurator in Judea.

[straygypsy]

OK...You mean 44AD correct?

This was one of the reasons how I knew Christianity was false...

They say "the anointed one" that was "cut off" just before the destruction of the 2nd Temple was Jesus when the real anointed one was King Agrippa.

[ForBibletruth]

Yes, 44 AD and 44CE (current era) are the same year. I have heard this theory before, and believe you are talking about King Agrippa II, who was the King that was cut off when Jerusalem fell in 68 CE.

[zytigon]

Try excellent Bible scholars Robert M. Price, John W. Loftus, Dan Barker, Valerie Tarico, Gary Greenberg, G.A.Wells, Albert Schweitzer, Joseph Wheless, C.Dennis Mckinsey, also Richard Carrier, Victor J. Stenger, Ken Humphreys, Jason Long, John R. Shook, Thom Stark, Israel Finkelstein

[goodndite]

They worship a man....and it shows

[goodndite]

Sorry to clog up the comment section momentarily, but aside from the specific details, I tend towards seeing things in a purely spiritual sense and when looking at it in that light, I cannot help but see the real and observable damage that Christianity does and has always done to the mind and heart of anyone deluded enough to let it get a grip on them.

[goodndite]

Christianity IS deceit and I believe jesus, a murderer by proxy. In a symbolic sense, a murderer of truth, a murderer of a man's spirit, but a murderer none the less.

[goodndite]

This, I believe, is the chief reason Christianity is such a chaotic mess. Though I am neither Jew nor Christian, I would if given only the 2 choices, follow the OT before I would ever follow that lying bunch of deceit called the NT. Speaking of deceit, of the 3 'great' religions, Judaism, Christianity and Islam, Christianity has done far more to delude and deceive people than the other 2 ever have, even with all their attendant faults we all know about.

[goodndite]

Your videos are interesting and well tought out. I won't go into what my spiritual beliefs are as it would likely start an arguement of sorts. But suffice it to say I grew up heavily studying the Bible and in the 'Church'. I can tell you beyond any doubt that this 'jesus', if he existed at all, was an evil person vis a vis what God was written to have said in the OT. This jesus did in fact blatantly contradict the teachings, rules et al and lead people astray and has been doing it ever since.

[ForBibletruth]

Yes, much of that is do to the fact that many preach that you are saved by grace alone and that you are not under the law. Paul was talking about the ceremonial laws and no one ever taught that you should just continue to sin if you felt like it. Some preachers will say anything to keep the peace, keep the church full, and keep the cash flowing in.

[dankwilliams]

great video, 5 stars.