Why And How I Gave Up Listening To Music?
Uploader Comments (kammy1)
Top Comments
-
congrats for giving up music bro, i'll tell you something from experience, giving up this "audio pornography" helps so much with salaah and concentration....and if u ever do feel tempted (shaitan is constantly working on a believer) try listening to some qiraat or a lecture reminding you of the hereafter or on why music is haraam.
-
@Bestman416 your solid! make sure u get a new keyboard after your current one wears out
All Comments (32)
-
Live your life and don't have such an impressionable mind. EVERY MAN, no matter HOW much sense it makes...you obviously wouldn't listen a person that isn't making sense. However, he's a man, just like you. When you die, you die. Life is explained through science. Not spirit. It's why doctors, morticians, and investigators can tel more about death and forensics than faith can. I'm not here to dispirit anyone, but if they believed the afterlife, they wouldn't be afraid to die.
-
Do you think that a guy who has never died can tell you what happens when you die? Your so concerned about what will happen when you die, that you aren't focusing on what happens when you live. Nobody living knows what happens when you die, and nobody dead is alive to tell. Music is just a voice, over instruments. Instruments are made from the earth, and the voice too, just as words. If you aren't living, you're already dead. Ironically, you listened to another guy who never die. SMH
-
kammy mashala u sound so intelligent yara
-
@kammy1 Yeah, you looked nervous, but you did well, brother.
Barak'Allahu fiik
-
@ItsJustAPlug Sure! Wouldn't a country be boring without a variety of accents!
I'm just not familiar with all the accents you have there; that's why this one sounded a little tough to decipher! (:
Jazak'Allah khair for replying.
- Loading comment...
And then in Bukhari, another Hadith relates a connection between musical instruments and the family of David (saw).
Volume 6, Book 61, Number 568:
Narrated Abu Musa:
That the Prophet said to him' "O Abu Musa! You have been given one of the musical wind-instruments of the family of David .'
570YaRasoolAllah632 2 months ago
@570YaRasoolAllah632 bro check the tafsir - the hadith was about flute - and by that it meant his voice - not an actual instrument - i.e. some scholars say Al Afasy has the flute in our day and age because of his voice - the last hadith u posted is applicable to what i am talking about - these singers use music and claim its halal - the Prophet SAW was talking about them - END QUOTE
kammy1 2 months ago
@kammy1
IF u look at the previous Hadith about the Day of 'Id and girls singing with musical instruments, which the Prophet Muhammad, swalala hu alayhi wa wasallam, allowed in that instance. It leaves a great deal of scope in opinions, i completely agree with you with regards to main stream music. Personally I feel that when someone (be it owais qadri, maher zain, sami yusuf) is praising RasoolAllah, swalala hu alayhi wasallam, and he uses a melody to help convey the meaning, its gud.
570YaRasoolAllah632 2 months ago
@kammy1
But its better if they resist certain forms of music. Your raps r quite gud btw.
Abu Dawud Book 15, Number 3306:
[color=green]"Narrated By Abdullah ibn Amr ibn al-'As : A woman came to the Prophet (pbuh) and said: Apostle of Allah, I have taken a vow to play the tambourine over you.
He said: Fulfil your vow."
570YaRasoolAllah632 2 months ago
@570YaRasoolAllah632 there is a difference of opinion on the duff - but still it was for special occasions - the Mushriks of MAkkah used to play the duff and recite poetry mocking Islam and the Prophet - is this the people we should follow? come on - REFLECT#
kammy1 2 months ago
@570YaRasoolAllah632 bro that is not logical - its like going through haraam means todo something halal - doesnt make sense - and its a god job we dont follow personal opinions but FACTS :) - END QUOTE
kammy1 2 months ago