American Soprano Elizabeth Wheeler ~ Vilia song (c.1909?)
Uploader Comments (CurzonRoad)
All Comments (16)
-
A charming rendition of a piece that has deservedly been translated into many languages and survived many interpretations. Thank you, Doug!
-
Sorry about Alda - A momentary memory lapse. It could have been Farrar, Nordica, Lewis etc,. My apologies. Vivian
-
@stuartliff Alda was from New Zealand, but how about Mabel Garrison? Or Anna Case?
-
She has to hurry a bit, to get it all into a 10-inch disk, but her lyric freshness is always remarkable. Her ascents into the soft high register, without cooing or squeezing, are a thing of beauty. Thanks, Doug, this was an appreciated birthday present!
-
I agree Wheeler's is a sweet-toned performance, and I CAN understand the words (maybe because I already know them). Moreover, I can't really fault the phrasing. Still, it's a rather generic performance, but how much can a singer do with this music? To answer my own question, listen to Jeanette MacDonald's early recording; but avoid Joan Sutherland's, which is truly incomprehensible though rich in tone. La Sutherland was fond of the tune.
-
A charming performance. Thank you!
-
Lovely voice but surprisingly short phrased in places. I get the impression that this was not really her 'fach'. Why are there no voices today of this sort of quality? America seemes to have produced so many - viz Agnes Kimball, Edith Mason, Frances Alda etc.Anyway I am very grateful to have been given the chance to hear two new voices (Wheeler and Kimball) A million thanks Doug.
-
A very pure and beguiling voice. Wonderful. Thank you.
-
Nice performance.
Doug
What a wonderful performance - sweet tone and wonderful sense of the music.
Regards and thanks-John
65attila 2 months ago
@65attila
Agreed... while never a star, she made numerous recordings on Victor's budget Black Label, and in ensemble on the Purple Label. Nice, sweet voice. Thank you, John!
CurzonRoad 2 months ago
Very prettily done. I sure hope she knows what she is saying because I sure don't! A nice, well schooled voice, but to me, she lacks a "face".
Bivolari 2 months ago
@Bivolari
Perhaps not... but her sweetness and delivery are winsome. Thank you, Stephen!
CurzonRoad 2 months ago