Randy Newman, 2008 "Down In New Orleans"
Uploader Comments (massumori)
Top Comments
-
I'll have to disagree. Newman's "sound" fits the whole fact that the story takes place in Louisiana in the 1920's.
Alan Menken's too contemporary for it.
-
Why all the hate? This song is fine. Just because Alan Menken didn't write it doesn't mean it's bad. There are other composers about there.
Video Responses
All Comments (54)
-
@Spudfish93 I know his voice is bad in the films but Toy Story etc. was after the 1990's. He's been around since the 60's. Also you have to understand that the music has to fit the film, which is normally Disney. Try and compare 'The Natural' soundtrack and 'You've Got A Friend In Me' or 'Nothings Gonna Stop Us Now'. They are completely different. Obviously you've just seen a couple of Disney movies and decided that all his stuff sounds the same. Look into things before making assumptions.
-
@rockermanmatt You're obviously missing the point.
I didn't say his music annoyed me, I said it was his voice.
I didn't say his music in general is repetitive, I said it was his movie soundtracks.
I don't listen to his stuff so how can I possibly form an opinion on it?
-
@Spudfish93 No, you go and listen to his early work that's not from movies. 'Short People', 'It's Money That I Love', 'Mama Told Me Not To Come', 'You Can Leave Your Hat On'. This guy is probably the best lyrics writer in America today, talking about racism, religion, greed and inequality. He is praised by many many popular musicians and people in the industry. You obviously don't know what you're talking about.
-
@rockermanmatt Why would I want him to care about me?
Also, I disagree, I find his stuff incredibly repetitive.
Like, compare the soundtrack of Toy story with the soundtrack of The Princess and the Frog and you'll now what I mean.
-
@Spudfish93 I doubt he cares about you. He's extremely respected and rich, not to mention probably the best song-writer in America today.
-
Randy Newman annoys me considerably.
It's just his voice, it just sounds like he has water in the back of his throat constantly...
-
I Love Alan Menken, but I Agree Randy Newman's style fit's the setting much more. Do I think that Menken could haved done wonders with the movie? Yes, But Newman was a fine choice as well.
-
@weihnachtskaktus and WHY is it so wrong that he is the composer? if you say that there is no melody, than you have a serious problem with your ears...
-
Is it just the sound recording, or is his singing a little raspier than in Toy Story?
-
i swear to god randy newman's still got it!!!! menken can't hold a candle to rand!!!



@Scrawnyfish in the movie that's not Randy, it's Dr. John, a 70's folk singer.
MusicAllDay2 1 year ago
@MusicAllDay2 Dr. John, a folk singer? You gotta be kiddin me. I would call him New Orleans R&B artist. And he still kickin today.
massumori 1 year ago 6
@MusicAllDay2 Dr. John, a folk singer? You gotta be kiddin me. I would call him New Orleans R&B artist. And he still kickin today.
massumori 1 year ago