Carrie Grant - What i did for love

Carrie Grant sings What i did for love from A Chorus line on The Sound of musicals

Category:

Entertainment

Tags:

• Carrie
• Grant
• Chorus
• line
• what
• did
• for
• love
• The
• sound
• of
• musicals

[scuzzbuzzproductions]

To be honest I dont think Whitney, Christina, Mariah, Celine or Barbara would do this song justice.

It's more of a musical theatre piece than anything and I don't see many of them singing musical theatre well.

Maybe at a push Celine and Barbara.

X's

[MaliceIn1derland]

um ok....relax dude!

[fyasa2002]

@scuzzbuzzproductions so you skipped emmy rossum Oo

[greengringo2003]

Too bad the little envious queer script-reader had to add . . .

lovely rendition, regardless! 5 thumbs up, dear Carrie.

And the queer announcers need their own boyfriends anyway.

[ImBeautifullyTragicx]

To me, her emotion always seems fake. And then I can't enjoy the song :(

[scuzzbuzzproductions]

@TescoShampoo It's my opinion that she wouldn't do this song justice.

Is that such a bad thing to say?

No.

Just because she did Musical Theatre, does not mean I have to rate her as a Musical Theatre performer.

So she did Funny Girl, it doesn't mean I have to rate her.

I'm not saying she isn't talented.

She has a great voice, but my opinion is what it is, and I don't see a reason why it should be questioned.

[TescoShampoo]

@scuzzbuzzproductions What do you mean at a PUSH Barbra? Does Funny Girl ring no bells to you?!

[Cardywhite111]

I think she has a delicacy and sweetness in her voice which is appealing.. Everyone gives their own unique rendition....I liked this very much. Clearly Shirley Bassey is incredible but this has a poignancy on a gentler level which I found moving.

[barochial]

@scuzzbuzzproductions You know, I respect your opinion and your defense of it. I don't have to agree with it (of course). I saw the original touring company of A Chorus Line, and I always thought Barbra would do this song justice. (My opinion of - course.) ;)

[scuzzbuzzproductions]

@barochial I know she was.

Maybe because I positioned her next to people who haven't had the experience that she has in that area.

However, people were commenting about Barbra and the others that I listed, and I was just stating my opinion, on how I don't think that they would do this song justice either.

Just because someone has had experience in a certain area, does not mean that they are going to do a job well, in every aspect of the area, which in my opinion, this song would not suit Barbra.

[barochial]

@scuzzbuzzproductions I don't undrstand your comment as it pertains to Barbra. She was a major star on

Broadway before she was a recording or film star.

[laberriness]

@scuzzbuzzproductions I think they would have shown a bit more emotion than Carrie Grant. All these women have powerful voices, when I heard Grant singing I felt like there was no effort. Giving her the benefit of the doubt maybe she is tired, I mean she is pregnant. I understand what you are getting at with the those women not being able to do it justice, but then who would? I desperately suggest listening to Shirley Bassesy What I did for love & see if Carrie gives this song justice.