Top Comments
All Comments (141)
-
This Cover rocks
-
they destroyed the solo completely
-
a little different, but not bad. and to those who say that this is insulting to the pink floyd band is stupid, anytime a band (especially one with some decent success) covers a song this is purely a compliment cause it ment that the band wrote something that was iconic enough to cover
-
@CitizenKANE2277 You have a point, token rule of covers is be at least as big as the band you want to cover, only other bands that are a large enough cultural force to compete would be like zepp, stones etc
-
Listen, idiots. Pink Floyd is band you do not cover. Plain and Simple. There are very few bands in history that can even hold a candle next to their compositions. When I listen to this version all I hear is, "There izz noo pain, you are reeceiving. Huhh a sistant ship smoke on huh harizawn." He sings it poorly. End of story. I realize that opinions are "subjective," but c'mon......
-
@TicoPrime the wall tour 2011 roger waters. gilmour was a guest appearance and he made a mistake in the lyrics. so that is no criteria. these people have done a great job. hats off you you guys =)
-
@saraandjerry5 Your comment began with "omfg gay". Your opinion is officially disregarded. Btw, amazing cover, open your mind. Imitation is the greatest form of flattery. If you're that big of a fan of Pink Floyd take it as a compliment to one of your favorite bands
-
Not bad, thanks for covering :-S
-
Why everyone feels like this insults the memory of Pink Floyd irks me a bit. It is most certainly not horrible; a cover wouldn't be published if it wasn't meritable to some degree. For example, I'm just as big a fan of Queen as you guys must be of Pink Floyd, but, begrudgingly, I admit that there are good covers of the band, even if the originals were utter-fucking-ly amazing. This is another example in that it may not be as good as the original- nothing will be- show the piece some respect.
It´s not bad, but the mistake in the lyrics is a complete fail.... But not bad, I´ve heard worst covers...
TicoPrime 8 months ago 10
@Secondlifecreator Look, the original is amazing. That's why they are covering the song. Aaron Lewis has been doing it for a long time at his acoustic shows. I don't see why you need to be an asshole about it. This is a pretty outstanding cover, and remember they are paying tribute and respect to Pink Floyd by covering their song. Relax man, not everything has to be perfect in your eyes. Enjoy the music or leave. You have a choice. But don't trash others for having an opinion.
TheBananamanAssassin 2 months ago 8