rosh hashanah torah reading - hagar
Uploader Comments (efendler)
Top Comments
-
nice chanting!
-
Batavian, shut up.
And deen, you also need to shut up. You ought to respect this man's reading rather than insult it and act like you're better than him. You talk as though he's not a real Jew since he's Ashkenazi. Get over yourself. Ashkenazis are just as much Jews as the Sephardics. Both groups should stop bickering and realize that they're both Jews.
All Comments (20)
-
@deen21 There is no set of "taamin" [sic] or method of chanting more correct than others, and Yemenite pronunciation has its own - shall we say - defects e.g. the San`ani tradition distorted the correct Qof sound to "Gof" and the Gimmel to "Jimmel" under local Arab influence, not to mention the rendition of the Qamatz as 'o' and the Segol as 'a' which many Hebrew specialists dispute.
-
Nice reading - I could really learn the Rosh Hashana trope from this! What's up with the coloured highlighting? Some learning aid? Can you upload a recording of the trope by itself? (Darga, munach zarka munah segol, munach, munach revi'i, mahpach mashta, zakef katon.....)
-
Nice job!
-
i guess its anglo-saxon ashkenazi pronounce :D "tzivahh" "errrr" "arrr" in eastern europe you dont hear these sounds.
-
very nice
-
can you try beter?try to see and let ppl to hear your voice!!
-
nice to help ppl! i tank you
-
you right!
-
dont vory about the acent becouse you have to feel and his excellent i will like to hear your acent if you judge ppl about the accent
-
this is a nice attempt to record one of my favourite trops sets: the classic nusach Ashkenaz leyning for Rosh HaShanah...however the effort could be improved with more attention to the Hebrew - particularly kamatz katan, even in sephardic American pronunciation..eg. vayamol, not vayamal..and so on..
post-post-scriptum: v'ahavta l'rayacha ca'mo'cha.
efendler 4 years ago
And a p.s.: Gents, I deleted the off-color name-calling because - wait for it - "derech eretz kadma l'torah!"
efendler 4 years ago
Magnus - thanks for the support.... Deen - no offense taken. But mom is from Poland, dad from Vienna -- A Yemenite-style, sephardic reading would be inauthentic for me -- it's ok if my style is not to your taste .... And Batavian, no offense re: my American accent - once again, gotta be me! .... My goal: share a pleasant, accurate, American-style reading with people who might find it useful! Oh, my Israeli-born GF likes my reading -- but she would -- an Ashkenazi who grew up on a kibbutz!
efendler 4 years ago