J. S. Bach: Triosonate G-dur
Uploader Comments (palurj)
Top Comments
-
Ez igazi csemege!
kár hogy nem hallottam élőben. Jacques Loussier Bach (zongora) impróihoz fogható!
-
Very sorry to have insulted you. I apologise. What I really meant to say is that I don't think the piano adds anything to the performance, that the organ alone is more than enough. I'm sure that the piano alone would be wonderful. Its just that the Organ is such a large instrument its only rarely complimented by another, perhaps trumpet, violin or timpani now and again, but hardly ever by piano. In this case I don't feel the piano could be appreciated. Others might disagree though!!!
All Comments (11)
-
Ez tényleg jó!Hát hiába az improvizáció az egy külön tehetség az orgona művészeten belül!
-
This is no more of a travesty than Reger adding a third part to the two part inventions; thus effectively re-arranging them for organ. It is creative art at its best, and beautifully performed. Knowing how Bach used and re-used his own material and that of other composers, it is absolutely in the spirit of Bach's genius. Bach would be smiling at this!
-
Great! I wish I was in this concert...
-
Fantastic, great music, I am sure Bach would approve, after all, he used many variations of instruments in his works. JAYDEE AUSTRALIA
-
Heavenly ... thanks for sharing your wonderful performance with us from the other side of the world (Australia in my case!). I have subscribed and will enjoy much more of your music in days to come. Giovanna and hundreds of stars.
-
Great performance, beautiful piece!
Thanks for sharing. Please ignore any negative people, just enjoy the art!
-
Hallucinant ! Hihetetlen !
De ki vagy te, aki Thierry nevével irsz ???
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Why? Embarresing for the organ!
pipeup1 3 years ago
I have learnt: embarrassing is if you destroy the joy of the music lovers with your very high opinion and don't repeat enough for your concert. Sometimes is allowed to enjoy the music this way too. Please, try it! And if it does not work, play it only on organ perfectly. I just played this music once, that way, but I performed all the six sonatas several times in concert, solo, like it is written.
palurj 3 years ago