Carly Smithson vs. Leona Lewis - Without You

Video showing Carly Smithson's and Leona Lewis' versions of Without You. Which version do you prefer?

Carly Smithson is a contestant in American Idol 2008 and is still in the competition. Leona Lewis is the winner of the 2006 X Factor UK competition.

Category:

Music

Tags:

• leona
• lewis
• carly
• smithson
• without
• you
• mariah
• carey
• factor
• xfactor
• american
• idol
• bleeding
• love
• simon
• cowell

[AzrailBosanski]

Look people, Carly has a power voice which Leona cant even dream of, and first of all, you can not compare this two artists, because they differ in numerous ways, two thumbs up to two of them, but, my fav is Carlye, so CARLY ROCKS

[vdvxx]

Leona by miles miles miles!!!

[lasentinellaa]

Carly is terrible. In the high parts is often out of tune :\ Leona is way better!

[ailleachtx]

carly, one million percent. seriously, leona's wasn't that good. no one can beat carly, sorry

[akashnai90]

LOL...people who prefer Carly's version to Leona's mean that they know music better than Simon...which is totally laughable :P :P :P

Leona's version is better...absolutely

[the09conradz]

i like carly's because she doesn't try to sing it like mariah she sings it with her own style.

[brigitaification]

leona

[670nick]

i like them both but by leona is the best new vocalis out there i cant wait to here more frome her

[cireasa]

2 different types of voices, and i like Carly's better. But Leona is the one that actually pulls it off.

[Khelloo]

The first one, chh she's ok, but Leona is much better :x

[tripleJ1955]

My vote goes to ... Harry Nilsson. Both of these chicks are just posers.

[carshe209]

COMPARE, VERSE BY VERSE.. carly hit the notes with more clarity.. plus she hits the power parts better.. LEONA WHINES! A FACT FROM MY HEALTHY MIND AND HEALTHY EARS.. WHAT GOOD ABOUT LEONA IS THE ENDING COZ SHE SUSTAINED IT BUT THE FACT THAT THE PITCH IS THERE .. STILL POOR! CARLY IS BETTER.. LEONA IS POPULAR BUT IT DOESNT MEAN THAT SHE'S BETTER