JS Bach - Toccata in F - BWV 540 - Pipe Organ
Uploader Comments (BigOrganPipes)
All Comments (26)
-
This sounds like Cameron Carpenter playing. If it is, he is playing this Toccata in F#.
So is this shot of the Holtkamp chancel organ?
-
Wow! This is fucking insane!
Comes like a tsunami and blows your head right off!
Amazing!!!
-
This might be my favorite organ of all time now. Possibly the best reeds I've ever heard, especially the pedal Bombardes.
-
t nearly blew the speakers out on my PC!
Yes, technically, it is wonderful-the organist is obviously very accomplished.
Not enough `light and shade` for me, however-maybe Bach wanted it this way.
A fine effort though-very impressive.
-
@Ntalikeris666, as far as showing off...if someone manages to still say something beautiful, I don't care. Someone like Lang Lang, on the other hand...
-
@KhagarBalugrak It all depends on the perspective from which you see a piece of music. In my opinion any way of playing is acceptable as long as the person playing supports his approach adequately.
I have as well, heard many other versions of the piece, some of which were boring (Something especially easy with the particular piece), some others though were simpler in terms of registration and, lets put it that way, much less of a 'showoff', but still managed to convince me through other means.
-
@Ntalikeris666, well, I think people should reconsider. Bach would have loved dynamic contrasts in his organ works. It is well-known that in his other pieces, like those for chamber ensembles, he would make dynamic contrasts; only the technological limitations of his time prevented him from using dynamic contrasts in his organ pieces.
must be hard for such a Cameron hater to actually enjoy something he recorded
BigOrganPipes 2 months ago
This sounds nothing like anything Cameron Carpenter could ever hope to do in his wildest dreams! This performance is being played by a REAL organist!
And the performance has the unmistakeable Willeke Smits name stamped all over it!
Clarion004 2 months ago
@Clarion004
well you would happen to be 100% wrong. this is off Cameron Carpenter's latest album "Cameron Live"
check my other videos for the interview that goes with this piece
BigOrganPipes 2 months ago