Uploaded by taldari on Jun 18, 2011
From BBC News:
A Conservative MP has suggested "vulnerable" jobseekers - including disabled people - should be allowed to work for less than the minimum wage.
Backbencher Philip Davies said the £5.93-an-hour legal minimum may be a "hindrance" to some jobseekers.
Firms were likely to favour other candidates and MPs should not "stand in the way" of those who wanted to work for less to get on the "jobs ladder".
But mental health charity Mind said it was a "preposterous suggestion".
Mr Davies, the MP for Shipley, made the comments during a debate in the Commons over the minimum wage and employment opportunities.
The minimum wage is currently £5.93 an hour for those over 21, £4.92 for those aged between 18 and 20 and £3.64 for 16 and 17 year olds.
The MP claimed the most vulnerable, including those with learning disabilities and mental health problems, were disadvantaged in their search for work because they had to compete with candidates without disabilities and could not offer to accept lower pay.
They were desperate to work but continually found the "door was being closed in their face".
He said he had talked to people with mental health problems during a visit to a surgery run by the charity Mind, and they had "accepted" that they would be passed over in favour of jobseekers without disabilities.
"Given some of those people with a learning disability clearly, by definition, cannot be as productive in their work as somebody who has not got a disability of that nature, then it was inevitable given the employer was going to have to pay them both the same they were going to take on the person who was going to be more productive, less of a risk," he said.
He continued: "My view is that for some people, the national minimum wage may be more of a hindrance than a help.
"If those people who consider it is being a hindrance to them, and in my view that's some of the most vulnerable people in society, if they feel that for a short period of time, taking a lower rate of pay to help them get on their first rung of the jobs ladder, if they judge that that is a good thing, I don't see why we should be standing in their way."
Mr Davies was challenged over his remarks by fellow Tory MP Edward Leigh who told him: "Forget the fact there is a minimum wage for a moment. Why actually should a disabled person work for less than £5.93 an hour. It is not a lot of money, is it?"
Mr Davies replied that, irrespective of whether it was "right or wrong", that was "just the real world that we operate in".
He later told the BBC Radio 4's PM that the minimum wage had benefited a lot of people and he was not suggesting that vulnerable people should work for less than the legal minimum.
But he believed they should have the opportunity to do so, should they wish, for a short term to ensure they had time in the workplace "to prove themselves".
But Mind spokesman Sophie Corlett said: "It is a preposterous suggestion that someone who has a mental health problem should be prepared to accept less than minimum wage to get their foot in the door with an employer.
"People with mental health problems should not be considered a source of cheap labour and should be paid appropriately for the jobs they do."
She said employers should be educated about mental health problems, adding that more than 50% of people with mental health problems lived on weekly household income of less than £200.
A Conservative Party spokesman told the BBC: "These comments do not reflect the views of the Conservative Party and do not reflect government policy".
Labour MP Dame Anne Begg, chairman of the work and pensions committee, said more needed to be done to remove the barriers facing disabled people in the workplace but the MP's arguments were "unfair and wrong".
"To say that all disabled people should be excluded from the coverage of the minimum wage ... would be discriminatory against disabled people. It would set the cause of equality for disabled people back sometime to the middle of the last century."
George Galloways blasts Philip Davies (a guest on his show at least twice) for his comments as being insensitive.
Originally broadcasted on 17th June 2011.
-
7 likes, 2 dislikes
7:02
Philip Davies - Newsnight - Disabled people and minimum wageby latentexistence986 views
3:59
George Galloway speaks to a Thatcherite (no 43535)by taldari3,686 views
2:16
Andrew Neil vs George Galloway on TV appearances (21Jun11)by liarpoliticians210,445 views
1:01
George Galloway reads conspiracy theorist text on the tsunami in Japanby ignaciosanmon1,240 views
7:12
George Galloway blasts Colonel Muammar al-Gaddafiby taldari10,586 views
9:27
George Galloway educates an American about Israel and the USAby MegaChairmanMao26,251 views
2:56
George Galloway on Bin Laden's Deathby reelmckay44,961 views
4:44
Philip Davies MP on climate change.movby robdaleworks336 views
1:56
George Galloway gets caught in a lie againby GallowayWatch5,810 views
5:56
George Galloway on Syria and Middle East (21Jun11)by liarpoliticians29,661 views
9:19
George Galloway speaks to 2 nutters on Irish independenceby taldari11,597 views
8:35
George Galloway Owns an Ignorant Rebel on Radio.flvby Libya17f4,989 views
4:00
George Galloway speaks to another dumb supporter of Rupert Murdochby taldari2,520 views
4:24
George Galloway speaks to Tea Partier Tony Katz on Murdochgateby taldari1,216 views
3:27
George Galloway exposes a racist on migrants and immigrantsby taldari2,343 views
5:20
George Galloway blasts closeted Conservative on pension reformsby taldari947 views
11:13
George Galloway debates 9 11 with US callersby ignaciosanmon3,777 views
6:55
George Galloway interviews Ryan G Van Cleave on video games and divorcesby taldari258 views
5:29
George Galloway blasts illiterate native English texters!by taldari6,569 views
2:20
Anti-Minimum Wage Tories slammed in the Commonsby GoFourthTV1,482 views
- Loading more suggestions...
madness indeed. he is an mp for shipley ha ha
RYANKOKO 2 months ago
Philip Davies is a cunt pure and simple
Tzimnewman3 8 months ago 2
For once, I agree 100% with George Galloway, I have autism and dyspraxia, two learning disibilities and using disabled people as cheap labour is the lowest I've seen an MP go and all that says to me is what a cunt!
cafcjames 8 months ago