Simultaneity - Albert Einstein and the Theory of Relativity
Sign in to YouTube
Sign in to YouTube
Sign in to YouTube
Uploaded on May 5, 2007
Imagine two observers, one seated in the center of a speeding train car, and another standing on the platform as the train races by. As the center of the car passes the observer on the platform, he sees two bolts of lightning strike the car - one on the front, and one on the rear. The flashes of light from each strike reach him at the same time, so he concludes that the bolts were simultaneous, since he knows that the light from both strikes traveled the same distance at the same speed, the speed of light. He also predicts that his friend on the train will notice the front strike before the rear strike, because from her perspective on the platform the train is moving to meet the flash from the front, and moving away from the flash from the rear.
But what does the passenger see? As her friend on the platform predicted, the passenger does notice the flash from the front before the flash from the rear. But her conclusion is very different. As Einstein showed, the speed of the flashes as measured in the reference frame of the train must also be the speed of light. So, because each light pulse travels the same distance from each end of the train to the passenger, and because both pulses must move at the same speed, he can only conclude one thing: if he sees the front strike first, it actually happened first.
Whose interpretation is correct - the observer on the platform, who claims that the strikes happened simultaneously, or the observer on the train, who claims that the front strike happened before the rear strike? Einstein tells us that both are correct, within their own frame of reference. This is a fundamental result of special relativity: From different reference frames, there can never be agreement on the simultaneity of events.
Standard YouTube License
- 9:05 4th Dimension Explained By A High-School Studentby xkcdHatGuyFeatured 1,571,074
- 3:01 Einstein's General Theory of Relativityby Razin Shaikh 17,683 views
- 2:16 The Theory of Relativity Explainedby cabobean 15,998 views
- Scientific American Space Lab 259 videos156K
- 1:49:23 Lecture 1 | Modern Physics: Special Relativity (Stanford)by StanfordUniversity 418,138 views
- 5:50 Stephen Hawking - Train Ride to the Futureby WeAreStarStuff51 195,715 views
- 4:29 TIME TRAVEL: What Einstein Did Not Seeby timespacevector 140,395 views
- 1:42 Time Travel Evidence? Watch Found in 400 Year Old Tombby StrangeandCurious 2,047,488 views
- 1:43:17 The Extraordinary Genius of Albert Einsteinby laroucheyouth 555,423 views
- 1:47:37 Einstein's General Theory of Relativity | Lecture 2by StanfordUniversity 199,767 views
- 21 videos Play all Einstein's Relativityby starseed03
- 20:14 Einstein's Messengersby SpaceRip 85,783 views
- 5:43 Space-Time And The Speed Of Light | Einstein's Relativityby ScienceTV 673,403 views
- 10:06 Einstein's Relativity: Basics And Impact In Our Everyday Lifeby Best0fScience 193,816 views
- 1:22 Distance and Special Relativity: How far away is tomorrow?by minutephysics 753,041 views
- 9:14 Special relativity: time dilation and length contractionby drdwittman 41,452 views
- 2:11 Einstein's Proof of E=mc²by minutephysics 1,292,783 views
- 6:19 Einstein's Relativity: Gravity And Accelerationby Best0fScience 63,171 views
- 1:39 Albert Einstein on Buddhismby craigMellow 278,719 views
- 4:52 Albert Einstein Short Biographyby Aldo Medina 159,773 views
- 1:19 Albert Einstein: Why Light is Quantumby minutephysics 616,322 views
- 5:04 The Twin Paradox Narrative Explained (Animated)by Bastian Hulselmans 43,282 views
- Loading more suggestions...