Love for All, The Ahmadiyya Creed

reply to AK Shaikh
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User_talk:SaifullahKhalid

Category:

People & Blogs

Tags:

• ahmadi
• ahmadiyya
• ahmedi
• ahmediorg
• Karim
• Shaikh

[saqibtahir]

Are you without tuttay? I never said debate never resolve anything. I said Mubahla i.e war of curses never resolve anything. But I would say that debate within Muslims on theological issues never resolve any thing. That is the reason Muslims killed more Muslims on religious reasons than any other faith.

[saqibtahir]

You missed the whole point. When christians refused to accept Mubahala what did they prove? They proved that Mubahla means nothing for them. The same happened when MGA and his sn Mirza Mahmood and grandsons ignored mubahla challenges from Mullas and vice versa.

[saqibtahir]

You irritation and level of mind is completely visibale from your abusive language. Denying after clearly losing the stupid Mubahala challange, you blind Mirza worshipers ca do nothing except cry on you fate or to abuse others.

[saqibtahir]

Have you seen the Mubahala pamphlet that wa distributed home to home in Pakistan. It was in person. When Mirza Tahir acepted alyas Sattar's challange, he accepted in person.

[eldopesta]

2. saqibtahir. you say that debate never resolves anything and that i should leave God alone, while your tuttey waala mirza claimed to have sexual relations with God and then gave birth to himself?. forget the mubahila papers published in pakistan why not read tuttey waala's books that he published, then eat your own hat you jahil! why defend what your parents have FORCED ONTO YOU. your stuck in your jahilia so lets forget the debating shall we? bye bye! RIP

[saqibtahir]

Losing and winning means nothing in the 'war of curses'. My point was that Mubahila solves nothing in the religious discussions and wars. Leave God alone from this madness. Every one has to die.

[eldopesta]

1. saqibtahir. go and discuss with the donkey khalifa ji if he will enter into debate. discussing with brain washed youth and deciding if it is worthwhile or not is futile. the reason ahmadi's never enter into debate is the same reason that Jehova witnesses do not. they are affraid that their congregations, upon realising the truth will destroy their heirarchy. you preach falsehood that Muhammad PBUH lost against christians. bring out the hadith you pindus?

[frontliner860]

@ Mr. Saqibtahir

You wrote:

[I]Prophet Muhammad did mubahila with Christians but still Christians are the largest faith.[/I]

plz correct urself, no such Mubahla was held... Christians did not turn up for Mubahila....and the ALLAH's Prophet (SAW) said that if they had turned up, they would have totally ruined.

regards

[saqibtahir]

Last night I was discussing Mubahla issue with many Ahmedi friends. They all agreed on following:

Mubahla game proves nothing. Prophet Muhammad did mubahila with Christians but still Christians are the largest faith. Mirza sahib did some Mubahlas. He openly lost some and won some but it proved nothing because both parties claimed victory. Mirza Tahi's Mubahla is also claimed s victory by both sides. Bottom line

; Mubahla can create a good drama but no results. This is my humble opinion.

[ibneharris]

Stupid . Read my mail . Mubahla was that if Ahmadiyyat is false then it will be destroyed .But if it is not desroyed then Sattar will be the one who is liar . Has Jama'at been destroyed. Stupid.