Hye-Jin Kim-Bach-Partita III-Preludio-solo violin
Top Comments
All Comments (35)
-
hmm....how about she just plays however the hell she wants. i for one appreciate variety and a fresh perspective.
-
Fer God's sake missy slow down it's not a damn race - you supposed to be making nice vibrations for the body & soul not helping red rum win the derby!
-
This is one of the best performances of the Preludio that I've ever heard. Thank you so much for sharing your art with us!
-
you play this so beautifully!
-
Thanks for assuming that I do not know what Bach is capable of. I've never guessed that we were discussing other works than these pieces. You of course were referring to music for the cello while me, the violin. However, the only reason I never said "you would agree with me" is because I'm not the type of person who believes there should be a dictated belief of what music should be.
But, I guess you believe in a universal understanding of music and love to dictate it to other musicians. ty.
-
How can you possibly assume what my interpretations are like for these pieces? I used to think the same way you did couple years ago but if you were fortunate enough to hear what Bach was capable of, you would agree with me. I'm not trying to sound conceited here; I believe music ISN'T about taste and is universal when played right. Let's just stop the discussion here; only music, not words are ever going to convince you.
-
And it just happens that your interpretation of those "spaces" are to not add any "emotion."
Also, it just happens that adding "emotion" to those "spaces" is preferred far more by violinists for this piece.
-
I never said a great contrast in dynamics was necessary to make Bach sound good.
I just said adding your own emotions, I'm guessing the way the word is being used seems to offend your understanding of it?, own "phrasing" adding vibrato, adding subtle dynamic changes, make even Bach's work sound better.
Not "ruin" the piece but make it better.
And Bach leaves "spaces" in his music where the musician can add their interpretation.
wats with the long ass comments ROFL
whattheasiann 2 years ago 5
It need not be that fast, not necessarily.
Give it a little breath.
Esosphere 1 year ago 3