Top Comments
All Comments (85)
-
this song is for miserable people
-
such a powerful song, I think I like this version better.
-
Incredible. Such a simple song, yet so so powerful. I personally like the line: "some enchanted night I'll be with you". The versions, though musically very similar, have a different tone to me.
-
amazing
-
Something tells me this song was modified to fit a happy/bittersweet ending at the end of Good Will Hunting. The way that the song is portrayed in Good Will Hunting doesn't make much sense to me. I feel that all songs are stories in themselves and I'm glad to have finally heard the whole story.
-
@ghostofchat77 2nite is one of those nights when i feel really bad, so i'm flickin' through yt-songs and end up listening to elliott smith (although i've got all his stuff in my record collection, how mad is that?) and i feel even worse - feels good...;)
-
@Malocclusiontenfour Yeah there is a good moment in one of his live concerts where he says "Sometimes a sad song can make you happy... even if it's a sad song... like walk on by"
-
@AniSmith i don't know if the GWH version is "happier" -at least this version ends on a note of hope "some enchanted evening I will be with you"....but yes, this one seems deeper on many, many levels...just a few tweaks to the lyrics and acoustics makes such a big difference!
-
@AniSmith Elliott liked to make some of his saddest songs sound happy, because he thought the more contrast there was in a song the more interesting it was. "Waltz #2" is a good example of this. The lyrics are tragic, but the melody makes you want to jump up and dance around the room.
-
@delmodet Hope this helps. I speak English, and even I had some trouble with a word here and there, and where he punctuates sentences. His delivery is so hushed, and the breaks are idiosyncratic. This is at least close, though.
I don't care which version it is-- I think this is the most beautiful song to have been written in my lifetime. People outside the U.S. seem to appreciate Elliott more than they do in his own country. I don't know why that is, but I hope he is never forgotten.



As a recovering alcoholic and a man that has been through so much in my life this song touches me in many ways and chills my soul,,it is really amazing
RiseOfThePhoenix30 2 years ago 46
Ive only just discovered elliot but he is incredible, such a haunting and beautiful voice
guyroxorz 2 years ago 19