The organ of St Sulpice, Paris (please ignore inaccurate opening titles)
Loading...
5,183
Loading...
Uploader Comments (4candles)
see all
All Comments (18)
-
@4candles do you think they labeled the CD wrong?... dont have the score, no :/
-
In my ears it definitely sounds like roth, improvisation or maybe a composition, I can't say.
-
Hi there I had once commented on your video and i think this might be discouraging but the more i think about this wonderful piece the more i am think its and improvisation and i don't know if that's correct but after being and organist for 15 years and hearing almost every piece there is and i have been looking in my archives for a couple of months to find out what song this is. I swear it might be one of those things that could be right under my nose. I will continue to look in to this.
Loading...
to clear all confusion: I own this CD and this is Jean-Jaques Grunenwalds "Tu es Petrus" played by Daniel Roth in St. Sulpice!
Egestus18 3 weeks ago
@Egestus18 I had thought that it was a Grunenwald piece originally, but then I read the sleeve notes from my own copy of the disc and the piece I was hearing didn't correspond to what I was reading in the sleeve notes, so that's why I became confused. Most seem to think it is a Daniel Roth improvisation. If you have the score of 'Tu es Petrus' by Grunenwald, that would clear everything up I think!
Thanks.
4candles 2 weeks ago
I actually own the score to this Grunenwald work, and this performance here is definitely NOT that piece at all. Just to alleviate any confusion.
originaltommy 1 year ago
@originaltommy Many thanks for your advice - I will amend the video accordingly. Do you have any idea what this piece actually is?
Best.
4candles 1 year ago
where can i get a copy of this wonderful recording? o and thank you for this wonderful video.
ThePipeorganman 1 year ago
@ThePipeorganman Hi there - I bought this CD in St Sulpice when I visited Paris a number of years ago.
Someone has since posted a comment suggesting that this piece is not, in fact, by Grunenwald, but I do not have any scores to cross-check it against and no-body has confirmed that it is not by Grunenwald.
I'm glad you enjoyed this piece nonetheless!
4candles 1 year ago