Chopin: discovered new Prélude in E flat minor
Top Comments
Video Responses
All Comments (53)
-
i'm a big fan of chopin but i can say that this is not the best of his work. this seems more of a sketch that he hasn't finished or that has just been thrown away
-
lmao pure shit. not chopin.
-
Highly interesting! One easily thinks of the finale of his second sonata, or the prélude op. 28 no. 14. Although a sketch, the piece is a sinister statement of his art, almost angry, definitely original in the utmost sense.
-
...Wow. This was amazing. I mean, this is as disturbing as the finale to his second sonata! Chopin was a genius!
-
chopin knew what he did when he wrote the devil`s trill. he saw this near the end and he said" My nose is long but my 4th finger is out of practice but george here is the devil`s trill so the world will know that the devil`s trill is not a foolish parody a mans angst against the world or just some song I wrote before I passed into the highlands, I want the world to know that I was a piano player and also George Sand Let them also know we are lovers and Franz Liszt, keep an eye on him when I die.
-
@cziffra1980 that score is utterly dreadful!!
-
Not Chopin!!!
-
no no, first part maybe Chopin but only scheme, ending part is XX c music I suppose only :)
-
Watduh
Arghhhhhhhhhh
Jeffry Kallbergh...Je ris.
-
There was an article in the August 2001 issue of "Early Music" by Kallberg. It includes a copy of the manuscript, the score, and an article telling how he pieced it together. The score is more Kallberg than Chopin.
@Lisztianpiano The score looks so vague to me that half of the harmonies can only be complete guesswork. Sounds like utter nonsense.
cziffra1980 1 year ago 6
I wonder why people think this doesn't sound like Chopin, as if to say he couldn't write some bizarre music? I don't think his finale to the b-flat minor sonata is any more strange than this. In fact this piece even establishes the tonic more regularly. From my understanding, this is just officially a sketch, perhaps unfinished, and possibly written later in his life?
Lisztianpiano 2 years ago 6