Why Don't You Commit Murder?

My goal is to start a discussion on what we each believe is the source of our morality. Gods laws? Human laws? Innate behavior? Learned behavior?

To download this video copyright free please go to:
http://www.mediafire.com/?ojmh5omdrkz

If you wish to translate the subtitles you can download them from:
http://www.mediafire.com/?yuymwqmyuyx
Then send me a link to them and I'll add them to the video.

And remember to always, Think about it.

Category:

Education

Tags:

• Murder
• Morals
• Good
• Bad
• Evil
• Choice
• Law
• Jail
• Citizen
• Rule
• Commandment
• God
• Religion
• Heaven
• Hell
• School
• Education
• Brain

[shadowsburnme]

@KeistasZmogelis You are right, there is no logical fallacy in his argument, because his argument is actually a non-argument.

[KeistasZmogelis]

@shadowsburnme Jimmies argument has logical fallacies. For example, when he says that if birds had no wings, then would they fly? The thing is, birds do have wings, therefore the question is invalid.

I see no logical fallacy here. (do you even know what those are?) I can easily answer the question "Yes, birds would not fly". If this was an invalid question, I would not be able to answer it. The question "What if...?" is perfectly valid.

[shadowsburnme]

This video has logical fallacies. For example, when you say that what if God said there is no heaven or hell then would you commit murder? The thing is God has not said so. The question is invalid.

More importantly, I ask you, would you commit murder of a person who raped your wife and your daughter, and then beheaded them, and you knew there is no God, and you knew there is no court system/jail (the country is in chaos lets assume) and you are certain the murderer would run away?

[Cainkane1]

@topperheartramada The tendency goes for humans outside my group. Cultural exchange beats conflict any day of the week. Humans fight each other and being religious doesn't stop that.

[topperheartramada]

I don't kill because of guilt and fear of retribution. But frankly there are a few people I hate so much it would give me some sort of pleasure if they were to die from some nasty illness or if someone else killed them.

[topperheartramada]

@Cainkane1 Ok, but what about non-fellow man, i.e. the member of a rival tribe?

[micometer]

Why don't I commit murder?

I like life enough to allow everyone the same chance to enjoy theirs.

[Amashkitotamoes]

If it wasn't for cops and jail, Donald Buttcheaks (Trump) would be my first choice.

[Cainkane1]

Human beings evolved a tendency to want to live in harmony with their fellow man. The same is true of other social animals. For instance piranas never bite each other during a feeding frenzy.

[3434343434utubeguy]

@lukipelaSOD Sin is an opposite. To be able to "go with someone" you also have to be able to "go against someone." Free will makes this possible. Again, it's not that God made sin rather than sin was inevitably made possible via the creation of free will. Everyone who is capable of making a decision can choose to either rebel or obey God. Hell is being sent away from God's presence. Life today is filled with hardships, but have you ever thought about how much worse it could be?