Julie Fowlis - Hùg Air A' Bhonaid Mhòir
Top Comments
All Comments (282)
-
@yunta51 Celtic languages existed centuries before English. Your claims are fucking insane: you are fighting against histotrical facts. Your argument is inane.
-
@AlbaSiar I should have been more precise and said mongrel nation. I don't fancy the idea of being racially connected to your ass much!
I remember seeing the interesting programme 'Blood of the Vikings' from the BBC about 10 years ago - available on youtube with a quick search
-
@scotrelf My ass is mongrel - a couple of closely related north European tribes does not constitute mongrels. I am certainly not though I'm perfect able to accept you are. Professor Stephen Oppenheimer of Cambridge university - a world leading expert on genetics and DNA has found that the vast majority of Britons share identical genes - we all came from Northern Europe , even Gaels Picts, Britons and Angles at different times.
-
Take your linguistic debates and SHOVE them. Gaelic varies a lot just in Ireland from South to the captive North. Listen to the music and shut the hell up!
-
this is one of favorite languages because they have a real nice melody and their slow-kinda songs are soothing.
-
Very well, i like celtic folk.
-
tha seo uabasach math julie rinn sibh math a gaoil :)
-
Foregt all this Gaelic stuff. Isn't she just EDIBLE !!! Mmmmmm !!
-
Origins of the people living in scotland are mixed - as well as the scots (Scotti, tribe from Ireland) before that the Picts (slightly mysterious due to lack of written translated language) . Mix in with that scandinavian and northern english influences then later norman french and we are a mongrel race - but who isn't. the trick is to get on together and enjoy the benefits of the cultural mix
-
@yunta51 i think here is where someone is going to say "agree to disagree" lol. I'd say the PIEs have it tho.
Ok, gotta admit it....I don't understand a word of what she said....but her voice and the music are simply AWESOME!!!!
mapaxe007 7 months ago 14
@j0llygr33ng1ant Again, you have no proof, let alone written proof. Your idea of what Irish or Gaelic language is or isn't is in your own mind. Both Modern English and Modern Irish go back to their Germanic and Celtic branches, which in turn go back to an Proto-Indo-European source. You want to argue that the Celtic branch broke off sooner and developed into Modern Irish faster than the Germanic branch? Well be my guest. You'll be laughed out of any serious debates or forums with educated folks.
yunta51 1 year ago 9