American Idol 03/05/08 Girl's Top 8 Carly Smithson
Top Comments
All Comments (14)
-
Yep, its a reality show that serves as a promotional tool for Sony/BMG. The fact that Carly was on the show in the first place hurts her credibility in the recording industry, hopefully, her talent and the notoriety she gained from participating will trump that slight handicap.
-
This show is fixed. She was clearly the best of all the contestants. What a joke.
-
lol did they really call her donkey!?! n paula is sooo rite their isnt enough adjectives to discribe her and her gorgeous voice...
-
she's beautiful
-
This is one of the very few times that I disagreed with simon, I thought this song was perfect for her! I did think she chose some wrong songs throughout the show but I love her voice :)
-
hahah at 3:32 none of the guys are even paying attention. CARLY ROCKS!!!!
-
She is just amazing one of the best singers ever. She still just wows me.
-
no one in the world can touch her
-
"i was a donkey in hollywood week!" lol i love her
-
Gotta luv da Irish girl. Great great voice.
SHE IS TRUELY GREAT
nzinga04 4 years ago 14
shes the best
rowrow2inarow 4 years ago 13