Luke Kelly Banks Of The Roses
Loading...
Uploaded by kellyoneill on Nov 7, 2006
Video
Link to this comment:
Uploader Comments (kellyoneill)
Top Comments
-
IMO We should respect the wonderful Luke Kelly's memory as the great singer he was...and respect Sean as the great singer he still is. Luke is my favourite singer of all time but I can still enjoy others too.
3 years ago 22
-
Bless you Ireland!!! Greetings from your cousins across the water; Scotland :)
Alba agus Eire gu brath!!!
2 years ago 20
All Comments (40)
-
@kellyoneill I
-
lol. all of 3 dislikes, 3 idiots.
-
I think it's the arrangement/performance. Sean's version has a little more drive, a more prominent beat, probably due to the accompaniment. Luke has a more passionate, warmer approach which comes off a little calmer. My theory, both are great, I think Luke is the superior vocalist though.
-
@TheLordOden Both renditions are beaut, tho' while Sean performs and executes a song, Luke emits the greater passion but simply singing to his heart's delight and his vocal sound is more resonant and not at all stilted. Both have the Irish lilt which is lovely, yet Luke's sound is warmer, perhaps for its lower tone.
-
@kellyoneill Personally, i like both versions-Sean puts great inflection into it when he's singing...but luke's just luke :)
-
@opaldove I agree with that.
that said, my 5 year old boy refuses to listen to any version BUT Lukes. I played the Corries "Nancy Whisky" and he wasnt having it at all. lol
Kids are funny :-)
-
@kellyoneill LOL Nae Cahnce @ all!!
-
u can always bank on luke to belt out a master peice.
- 100 videosTop Tracks for The Dubliners
- 3:06
Luke Kelly Farewell To Carlingfordby kellyoneill144,639 views
- 2:21
luke kelly walking in the dew (Rare)by kellyoneill28,195 views
- 1:45
Luke Kelly Tibby Dunbarby kellyoneill26,952 views
- 3:07
Luke Kelly the brown and yellow ale (Rare)by kellyoneill31,907 views
- 2:50
Luke Kelly The Jail Of Cluain Mealaby kellyoneill70,310 views
- 2:24
Luke Kelly the jolly tinker (Rare)by kellyoneill51,339 views
- 4:09
Luke Kelly Patriot Gameby kellyoneill106,285 views
- 2:10
Muirsheen Durkin (1968)by kellyoneill244,759 views
- 2:49
Luke Kelly Hot Asphalt (Rare Version)by kellyoneill74,978 views
- 2:48
Luke Kelly Banks Of The Sweet Primrosesby kellyoneill13,364 views
- 3:55
Luke Kelly Maids When Your Youngby kellyoneill135,708 views
- 4:52
Luke Kelly When I Was A Bachalorby kellyoneill35,159 views
- 4:32
Luke Kelly Raglan Roadby kellyoneill131,636 views
- 2:42
Luke Kelly - Kelly The Boy From Killaneby kellyoneill273,561 views
- 3:27
Luke Kelly Paddy On The Railway ( 1979/80 )by kellyoneill161,825 views
- 1:30
Luke Kelly: Wrap The Green Flag Around Meby kellyoneill71,503 views
- 3:44
Luke Kelly Peggy Gordonby kellyoneill215,417 views
- 5:30
Luke Kelly: The Rare Auld Timesby kellyoneill127,762 views
- 3:12
luke kelly Rising Of The Moonby kellyoneill265,176 views
- 1:51
Luke Kelly: Saxon Shillingby kellyoneill37,039 views
kelly you wont be happy here but i honestly think sean cannon beats lukey here- just!
sammcc102 4 years ago
lol Nae Chance!
kellyoneill 4 years ago 6
@kellyoneill I agree with kelly, once Luke sings a song it becomes his. you just can't get any better
kojak543 1 year ago 12
@kojak543 Great minds think alike :)
kellyoneill 1 year ago 7