Donatoni- Tre Improvvasazioni (1/3)
Uploader Comments (John11inch)
Top Comments
-
I understand that not everyone can warm up to this, but criticizing it for being "ugly" is ridiculous and subjective. 19th-century critics similarly called the music of late Beethoven, Berlioz, and Strauss ugly; were they wrong?
Besides... the world isn't daffodils and puppies and music should reflect that more often.
All Comments (11)
-
@unavoltatanto3485 Hi from what you are saying i strongley deduce that this piece puts your soul in a very stressful state. Whenever your feel something that disappoint you, there is a key theme of your life...
thinks about that..
We should be grateful to musicians who put us in difficulty...
-
@qtpipi the notes are open source, you can just play it yourself.
-
DOV'E' LA Musica ???????
-
Great Piece!
Thanks for posting.
-
Oh, I love minor seconds... I could just pound them as tone clusters on the piano all day.
You should add links to the original files in the description so that we can download and listen to something that's better than mono-youtube quality.
qtpipi 3 years ago
Yeah. Sure man. If you want to upload all the music to rapidshare or something, you have fun with that.
PS- you're welcome.
John11inch 3 years ago
It is ugly and nonsense. The usual shit that dominated entire unhappy decades of the XX Century musical world. But fortunately now it is over: just a few hypocritical, academic and pseudo-intellectual people want to hear this, and like to talk about it in public just to show their hollow knowledge of this nonsense music.
unavoltatanto3485 3 years ago
Yes, now it is over; we're in XXI Century. You don't have to worry about any more dissonance, just like you said. Your virgin ears are safe from ever hearing a minor second again. With the recent deaths of Kagel, Xenakis, Ligeti, Donatoni, Radulescu, Berio and Stockhausen (I'm sure each time one of them died, you masturbated to a repeated perfect fifth), you are left with the soothing, buttery sounds of Finnissy, Ferneyhough, Murail, Boulez, Dench, Dillon, Dusapin, Barrett, Gehlhaar, [cont.]
John11inch 3 years ago 10
Lachenmann, Wuorinen, Carter, Babbitt, Bussotti, Penderecki, Fox etc. etc. etc.
Yeah, just those guys, those few "hypocritical" (what in the fuck could you possibly mean by that??), "academic" (I'm sure they all take it as a compliment that you note they are intelligent) and "pseudo-intellectual (I would love to see you spar with them and crush them with you real-intellectualism; you've shown you are certainly quite the fountain of knowledge on modern music, after all) [cont.]
John11inch 3 years ago 9
who like to discuss music. HOW DARE ANYONE even MENTION music that you dislike? The AUDACITY. Anyway, obviously all of our (/they're) knowledge isn't so hollow, just in comparison to yours! We can't ALL be a tome of encyclopedic information and supreme philosophy of aesthetic and artistic merit like youuuuu can <3 *swoons at your gigantic brain*
John11inch 3 years ago 9