Ave Maria - Bruckner
Top Comments
All Comments (47)
-
Beautiful! If you liked this, you should check out the American Boychoir singing the Ave Maria text in a plainchant setting by Richard Clark.
youtube.com/watch?v=ZOB7FuMA1N
U -
Beautiful!
-
Belíssimo. Minha música favorita.
-
@orvilleschmengy You're in music Theory huh?
-
@orvilleschmengy You're in music Theory huh?
-
4th species counterpoint creates the "suspension" here. The notes cannot be tied because of the text. Even nicer is the Ab dim7 chord over the pedal C in the previous measure.
-
@ThaSchwab Harmony and counterpoint work together. Harmonically, you could claim that the first "chord" in the measure at 0:37 functions in C major as ii (or in a minor as iv). But here I think it's more important how Bruckner accomplishes this contrapuntally, carrying over the double suspension from the previous measure. We may "see" the harmony functioning in a certain tonal way, but we hear it as an old-school Renaissance suspension.
-
I'm mistaken; the progression I mentioned would be I-VI-I, not I-IV-I.
-
I see the beginning of the bar as a different chord all together (like the downbeat of the second measure in the beginning). It could be a suspension, but I just don't see it. It would be more obvious if Bruckner included a bass note (ex., a bass note in the second measure of the beginning would make the chords go I-IV-I).
-
@ThaSchwab Why don't you think it is a suspension? The E and C in the tenor are held over from the previous bar while the bass moves to D and F. Is it because they aren't tied across the bar? (Suspensions do not have to be tied.)
Gotta love the suspension at 0:37 !
ecp2014 1 year ago 16
bello, muy bello
DasKindespiel 1 year ago 7