Symphony No 8 by Berliner Philharmoniker & Herbert von Karajan
Uploader Comments (Truus1949)
All Comments (32)
-
Thank you for your answer. I don't have a copy of the CD but as far as I can see from timings on Amazon, the first part of Schubert's Unfinished seems complete, quite unlike the video above. Leaving aside the fact that symphonies really should be listened to in toto, the recording does indeed contain some of Karajan's best recordings; and some of them are rather scarce on other CDs, like the pieces by Strauss for instance. Will get a copy for them only.
-
@Spiritakis The CD has the title "Herbert von Karajan - The Legend" and was released by EMI in 2008 to celebrate the 100th anniversary of Karajan's birthday. I don't know if there's also a recording of the Schumann-Symphonies only, because this is a double-cd-mix. It is a recommndable recording, in my opinion.
-
Would you mind telling me which is the exact CD where this excerpt can be found?
I would certainly blame the people who release such ridiculously cut versions, not something unusual for Karajan's recordings, alas. But you're not altogether innocent either, for you propagate the mutilation.
Anyway, it doesn't really matter. People who really care for the music will know what to listen to. In case you do care, I suggest you find a complete recording of the symphony.
-
..beautiful part of a music...excellent tune...spectacular image...great composer.....
-
I know this recording - I had it on LP when I was a kid and I loved it. I remember every nuance and it is wonderful to hear it again - and I really like your art! Thanks for doing this - it has been really moving
-
I love Karajan! You made a nice video! Great job! Thank you!
I am sorry to be the first to click the ''not like'' button. The music is of course terrific and so is the performance; the slideslow, though not my cup of tea, is certainly beautiful and fits the music surprisingly well. BUT - why did you cut this first part almost in the middle?! It's true that this is the 'Unfinished' symphony, but the first part was finished and right after your cut there is an amazing climax. What a pity: there's only one Karajan's 'Unfinished' on YT and it's mutilated.
Spiritakis 1 year ago
@Spiritakis My first intention was to put the thumb down because of a bad comment, but I didn't. It is okay by me that it is not your cup of tea, nice to read further that you did find it fits well with the music, but I do really hate it that people simply assume that I do something, like you assume that I have cut in the music. I have bought this piece the way it is in the store, so blame them and not me. Nevertheless thank you for your time to watch and listen.
Truus1949 1 year ago
I'd really like it if you could finish the movement! This is probably my favorite out of all the recordings of Schubert's Unfinished on Youtube...
devaraja42 2 years ago
Thank you very much for your nice comment!
Truus1949 2 years ago
Only ONE word for music and clip: BEAUTIFUL !!!!!
MrPeter3011 2 years ago
2 words! THANK YOU!!!
Truus1949 2 years ago