Andrea McArdle - I Dreamed A Dream - Les Miserables
Top Comments
All Comments (127)
-
@nyre455 No way. I have not heard Andrea before and I don't think she can compare to Susan Boyle.
-
@MageSutek Andrea performed Fantine in the Broadway run of Les Mis. and did a great job in the role. She is not that little 11 year old anymore but she is still a very good adult singer.
-
Don't bite my head off for not knowing, but has she ever played Fantine? I'd love to see her live in anything, but especially in Les Mis!
-
God, she is so freakin fabulous
-
Susan Boyle was a made for tv creation , nothing more
-
Much better than Susan Boyle!
-
Her voice is so youthful and nice to listen to.
-
She is as nice a person as you can meet....very down to earth and warm
Her voice is ammmmmaaaazing still
-
she was amazing when she was younger, but she's definitely feeling her age in terms of the beauty of her voice. but her musicality is like vintage wine.
-
Yes, and you're speaking of Broadway "veterans" of which Susan isn't. Let's not compare apples to oranges, and give appropriate credit to each. Peace...



I know it isn't "politically correct" to say so, but I honestly enjoy Andrea's performance FAR more than Susan Boyle's. Susan's story is wonderful and she is talented, but her voice is too shrill for me. Andrea has a warmth and an earthiness to her voice that makes the song more powerful for me. I also think she's kinda hot. Just my opinion.
nyre455 2 years ago 17
people -Susan is good but pretty much any Broadway veteran can sing better than her including Andrea
brilliant1a 2 years ago 17