Wagner - Tristan und Isolde - Liebestod - Charbonnet

Jeanne-Michèle Charbonnet (Isolda) Suisse Romande (Orquesta) Armin Jordan (Director)

Category:

Music

Tags:

• Tristan
• Isolde
• Liebestod
• Wagner
• Opera
• Jordan

[MrCogito93]

Wagner was a genius. I think its a good interpretation.

[charlesoban]

Et ben moi ce n'est pas celle que je préfère. Ok pour l'intensité dramatique, mais on a un peu l'impression qu'elle va prendre le train et la voix ne domine pas ses modulations alors si c'est fait exprès c'est bien mais bon... Cela dit, ça reste très qualitatif, mais ce n'est pas mon goût.

[dddvas]

Fantastic even after all these years. The voice, the look, the orchestra all meld to make this a super production. All you armchair critics should try doing it sometime.

[Dymension]

@jorfel49 Waltraud Meier is a lyric mezzo and has no business singing this repertoire.  As for Nina Stemme, I'll wait until I hear her live...

[deusirae76]

@michonnetsu I have just come back from David McVicar's rendition of Wagner's Götterdämmerung, I'm not expert but I think she was truly great as Brünnhilde, the best I've seen and heard in the decade.

[mucfister]

Ihre Stimme ist nicht schlecht, so weit ich das aus dem Ausschnitt beurteilen kann. Aber leider versteht man kein einziges Wort. Da müßte Frau Charbonnet noch viel arbeiten!

[jorfel49]

She is not in the Nina Stemme/Waltraud Meier League, but she she does a pretty decent job nonetheless.

Sometimes having a huge voice is not enough...

[izifit1]

jjj

[izifit1]

Magnifique Michelle  Je le savais....... Bises

[figliaimpuradibolena]

She is like most of the Isoldes are these years: She is OK, the voice is pretty unspectacular, but she doesn't die on stage because of the challenges, and she gets good jobs because there are not too many better sopranos around. Those who really like her should check the really important sopranos of the past that you find at youtube and elsewhere to get an idea what Isolde is all about!