Anna Netrebko - Giudici, ad Anna - Anna Bolena - 2011

Anna Netrebko, Elina Garanca, Elisabeth Kulman, Francesco Meli and Ildebrando D'Arcangelo

Category:

Music

Tags:

• opera
• donizetti

[rscmrcmd]

This is absolutely glorious. I love Anna Netrebko so much. I like when MegaCavatina commented, "when Netrebko launched full tilt into "Giudice ad Anna" ...she set the opera on fire." That's exactly what happens. Callas, Caballe, Sills, etc, come on guys, why all the bitchiness? These the women are different, that's all and I think they would love Anna Netrebko.

[irenaburkett]

Absolutely beautiful.

[gestas60323]

@ferrykalos

you are absolutely right !

[ferrykalos]

@ilNuovoArchaeOpteryx very good idea...even devia is wonderful in this role. My favourite is Maria Callas, above all in this scene...her "giudici ad Anna" is so amazing, so powerfull and rich....a real queen who doesn't accept the judgment

[ilNuovoArchaeOpteryx]

@ferrykalos I am prepared. While I wait for the first strokes I entertain myself in listenig to Montserrat Caballé and Bev Sills singing this very scene... ;)

[ferrykalos]

@MAPIAKALLAS read your comment...if you think Bolena is a Callas' role, how can you appreciate netrebko's? There's no drama, no passion, no low notes, not belcanto....

[ferrykalos]

@Lindow Ah ah ah ah ah ah you are so right!!!!!!

[ferrykalos]

@Poetapersempre ma a quanto pare qua nessuno se ne rende conto...e la mancanza di voce non è nulla...vogliamo parlare della grande interpretazione drammatica??? Bhà...

[ferrykalos]

@ilNuovoArchaeOpteryx I'm glad someone has my own opinion as it seems here everyone likes her Bolena while I think It's a great production but not a good execution...

Prepere yourself to a gret number of negative comments...everyone likes the great Netrebko!

[ilNuovoArchaeOpteryx]

@ferrykalos Thank you, ferrykalos, this is exactly my opinion. She might be a giftes singer, with good techinique etc, but for me there is a great lack of drama! Just listen to her "Giudici, ad Anna..." at 9:17, there is for me no expression... and the cabaletta lacks the force in the bottom... sorry, but this is for me no real Belcanto heroine.