Re: C.S. Lewis was an IDIOT!

Your own faulty logic about Jesus

Category:

People & Blogs

Tags:

• Christianity
• agnostic
• atheist
• chadagg
• C.S.
• Lewis
• National
• Geographic
• Rivals
• of
• Jesus

[achantus1]

So C.S.Lewis was an idiot? And you are not? I'm sure you are a highly educated man. Or maybe you have put your cap on to look smart? Redneck!

[edzotube]

@achantus1

are you trolling? Or did you not watch the video? (Or perhaps you did watch the video, in which case I really don't get your point...). I am not calling CS Lewis an Idiot! I am responding to a video in which someone else called him that. I am challenging the original video author to look deeper.

[Sarusource]

Why can't you simply say that the Biblical Jesus said some good things but was deluded about others? Hitler was kind to animals but was a nutbar. Martin Luther King jr did great things for civil rights but was promiscuous in spite of being married and a Christian. David Icke was a sports presenter but then went on to proclaim himself the messiah.

[edzotube]

@Sarusource

of course you CAN say that about Jesus. But you're left with the problem that so many/all of the "good things" he said are predicated on the veracity of his claimed identity.I'd argue that if there is not the God that Jesus came to communicate, then It's not inherently "good" to put yourself last, to take the low place at the table, to give up your life and follow him. It's stupid. Unless He is who he said he was. Jesus didn't offer advice and truth, he claimed to BE the truth.

[edzotube]

@mutendistort

I think we can question anyone... The title is what it is because it is a video response to a video that had that as a title. That's why it says "RE: Cs lewis was an idiot"

thanks for the note though.

[TanzAnimer]

search in youtube:dr zakir naik on jesus there whole list proving u wrong plus search:Huge surprise for sincere Christians: The Bible clearly says that Jesus is not God

[TanzAnimer]

FIRST U AVOIDED MOST QUESTION? attack me on Quran facts on Jesus when Bible been change grammar/meaning over years?

u aware that Leiw was studying shai islam more than Islam which is followed by majority of real Muslims in this world as Sunni's proving shia islam as shame!! for man-made rules they imply.

[csaver]

I got another "L" word that fits....LEGEND.

[hglundahl]

@Hereticshadowstorm I have quoted in full and answered in some detail that on the message "I am a Seminarian - You are Not a Christian" on my blog with url specification triv7quadriv. In short: do reread Fernseeds and Elephants. For all of your Seminary.

[Hereticshadowstorm]

@hglundahl There is much evidence to suggest that the four Gospels were not written by the traditional authors, please keep in mind i am a seminarian. and i am not sure why the Qur'an would be brought up here but Scholars theorize that the Qur'an was written after Mohammed met with Aryan heretics who had been exiled from Christian society. The Aryan heresy taught much of the same beliefs that Islam does. Not meaning to start a religious flame war however just thought i would jump in lol

[Hereticshadowstorm]

Lewis was undoubtedly writing to a christian audience. Therefore his argument was not exactly flawed as it was an argument of his time. Lewis was a talented writer anyone who denies this would have to be half retarded.

[abcdefghijkl956]

What is wrong with you??

[hglundahl]

@TanzAnimer Yes, you are wrong. The Qu'ran which teaches about Jesus "not being God" is 600 years after he lived, or a few years less or more.

The Gospels are four, two of them written by close disciples and two written by one disciple of a disciple and one good reporter (Sts Matthew and John, St Marc, St Luke) and the latter two wrote before the second of the disciples, while disciples were alive to correct them. They say Christ claimed what is divine.

[TanzAnimer]

I argee of first small part of vid and Prophet Jesus (PBOH) existing but disagree about call God as Jesus

So then what muslims believe in Jeus (PBOH) as Prophet only is wrong too?

Because i follow many of teaching of all prophet's especially Jesus (PBOH)??

What was C.S. Lewis view to islam. (Shia's are not really muslim too that out) Shia's contradict every principle of islam.

I believe Jesus (PBOH) is prophet not god. Im i wrong to believe this?

[DonnieTHORMacLEOD]

You have grasped C.S. Lewis's message quite well. A followup to your comment in how C.S Lewis really felt would be to read "Who moved the Stone." which is a book that provided the completed message that Jesus was much more than a teacher in C.S. Lewis's sense of Theology . To C.S Lewis Jesus was the Perfect Lamb without sin whose life would have been a lie if He had not Risen from the dead and had others who witnessesed that Resurrection die without recanting what they saw.