Ebert & Roeper review "Thank You For Smoking

Ebert and Roeper review "Thank You For Smoking"

Category:

Film & Animation

Tags:

• Ebert
• and
• Roeper

[kasrkinmullet]

Smoking, drinking, eating unhealthy food may be bad for us, but it's our choice to do so if we want.

[cs925]

I loved this movie and I agree 100% w/everything they said.

[ImmortalfireTheMod]

I like this movie a lot. A great cast with great humor.

[PumaSweat]

@rorrt to answer your question. It was one of those films everyone recommened to me,

and i heard many reviewers talk about positively, but it just didn't move effect me like I wanted it to. I really wanted to like it and I found the tone all over the place. Eckhart is a great actor, but i just didn't laugh much and found the humor forced. Then it gets strangly dramatic at parts i was just disappointed. Had the same problem with lost in Translation.

[ddl74]

@rorrt What a tough category that year. I thought everyone was deserving. In another year, Eckhart would've gotten a nod.

[rorrt]

@ddl74

I totally agree!

Terrence Howard was the "Why is he here?" in 2005 Academy Awards for Best Actor.

I mean Philip Seymour Hoffman was the best actor that year, even above Heath Ledger in Brokeback mountain.

[rorrt]

@PumaSweat

How is it that you can find a film overrated?

Are you judging its overate-ness by this review, or people who have recommended this film to you?

Because i find this personally, to be the complete opposite. I personally have started smoking since watching this film, and think every smoker should watch this film. Its so, so sharp, well written, well directed. And what a performance by Ackhart!

[qwuezalothus]

Aaron was the perfect pick for Harvey Dent.

[kellygreen5556]

is that how Ebert got cancer?

[skinwalkerxxx]

Aaron Eckhart best actor working today

[AlsatianCousin]

@kasrkinmullet - ever heard of the illusion of free will?

[thearthurshow]

these guys are so much like spill i don't know if they meant it but i think spell feels so much like them