The Tale of the Slave - Robert Nozick
Sign in to YouTube
Sign in with your Google Account (YouTube, Google+, Gmail, Orkut, Picasa, or Chrome) to like StatelessLiberty's video.
Sign in to YouTube
Sign in with your Google Account (YouTube, Google+, Gmail, Orkut, Picasa, or Chrome) to dislike StatelessLiberty's video.
Sign in to YouTube
Sign in with your Google Account (YouTube, Google+, Gmail, Orkut, Picasa, or Chrome) to add StatelessLiberty's video to your playlist.
Uploaded on Aug 16, 2011
This is a remix, no copyright intended. "The Tale of the Slave" features in Robert Nozick's book, "Anarchy, State and Utopia". I would recommend re-watching the video to see clearly if Nozick's question is answerable.
Credit to TomWoodsTV for the voice-over in this video:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_6n1FL...
Read the original text:
http://www.duke.edu/web/philsociety/t...
-
Category
-
License
Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed)
- Source videos Loading... View attributions
Loading...
Loading...
Loading...
The interactive transcript could not be loaded.
Loading...
Loading...
Ratings have been disabled for this video.
Rating is available when the video has been rented.
This feature is not available right now. Please try again later.
Loading...
-
13:10
The Story of Your Enslavementby Stefan MolyneuxFeatured
1,858,146
-
2:32
Milton Friedman Sets Liberal Straight On "Too Many Millionaires".wmvby Lew Waters
59,213 views
-
2:19
Rothbard destroys a common statist argumentby StatelessLiberty
59,334 views
-
1:29:54
This shit's got to go! - Jacque Fresco - The Venus Project (subs)by iimuhin
138,823 views
-
16:51
Milton Friedman debates a protectionistby StatelessLiberty
61,062 views
-
128
videos
Play all
Economicsby kaewonf8
-
30:34
The American Dream Film-Full Lengthby amy2x .
1,212,005 views
-
0:55
Rothbard Making Fun of Keynesby This Is Not Here
12,018 views
-
33:38
Facts and Fallacies with Thomas Sowellby Hoover Institution
51,291 views
-
28:39
Is Limited Government an Oxymoron? | Thomas E. Woods, Jr.by misesmedia
50,447 views
-
4:56
The Power of Property Rightsby LearnLiberty.org
25,371 views
-
6:26
TheAmazingAtheist Is A Doucheby Jacob Spinney
15,072 views
-
3:52
"Capitalism" and "Socialism" are anti-concepts - Roderick T. Longby StatelessLiberty
3,669 views
-
8:57
You Are A Slave Part 1by SilverShieldGrp
10,927 views
-
4:00
Do Women Earn Less than Men?by LearnLiberty.org
579,302 views
-
6:06
Social Justice and Its Criticsby LearnLiberty.org
36,374 views
-
2:30
Socialism vs Capitalism: Milton Friedman.by MindCrimesInc
174,172 views
-
5:50
When Did I Sign This 'Social Contract'?by TomWoodsTV
25,513 views
-
4:36
Schools of Thought in Classical Liberalism, Part 5: Natural Rightsby LearnLiberty.org
12,814 views
-
4:05
George Ought to Helpby bitbutter
129,222 views
-
1:14:06
End of Libertyby National Inflation Association
978,185 views
- Loading more suggestions...
Uploader Comments (StatelessLiberty)
apeironishome 2 weeks ago
I'm asking the question again. why does the libertarian mission involve private ownership? why not do away with it? libertarian socialism I guess its called.
Sign in to YouTube
Sign in to YouTube
StatelessLiberty 2 weeks ago
Because private property is inextricably linked with prosperity and civilisation. The "libertarian socialist" program has been tried in places, like Catalonia during the Spanish Revolution. Needless to say, it failed (see Bryan Caplan's The Anarcho-Statists of Spain).
Sign in to YouTube
Sign in to YouTube
apeironishome 2 weeks ago
ok so where are the examples of anarcho-capitalism working. I'm sure you have them
Sign in to YouTube
Sign in to YouTube
StatelessLiberty 2 weeks ago
All of the individual elements of a stateless free-market society have been shown to work in isolation. I challenge you to name an element that hasn't.
Sign in to YouTube
Sign in to YouTube
All Comments (286)
apeironishome 1 week ago
if you were paying attention you huge ignorant & naive idiot I was asking why private property is presupposed in a stateless society. the magna carta for instance makes no reference to it. not until Henry VIII did capitalism become the standard. and even then there revolts and demonstrations and appeals to "the commonwealth".
Sign in to YouTube
Sign in to YouTube
SuperCodeable 1 week ago
You do realize that JUSTICE is totally 100% INDEPENDENT OF THE STATE right?
Justice, virtue, peace- ARBITRATION- these things had predated the very notion of the state. And in fact, "governments" and "rulers" never really got involved in such matters as arbitrations and laws for many many centuries. Did that mean NO arbitration ever really occurred and everyone just murder, rape and steal from everyone?
lol
you must be a huge ignorant & naive idiot if you think so
Sign in to YouTube
Sign in to YouTube
apeironishome 2 weeks ago
bahaha we're not talking about the FANS of Noam Chomsky. we're talking about the person himself. and you're begging the question with "good understanding of their opponent's criticisms." Marx died before neo classical econ became popular. the fact that LTV was refuted does not mean it was DEFEATED. go back to Wikipedia and find the reference where it was
Sign in to YouTube
Sign in to YouTube
StatelessLiberty 2 weeks ago
That's because the LTV was refuted by marginalism in the late 19th century. And anyone who likes Noam Chomsky is a lightweight. I have never met a fan of Chomsky who had a good understanding of their opponent's criticisms.
Sign in to YouTube
Sign in to YouTube
apeironishome 2 weeks ago
labor theory of value. neo classical and austrian schools don't recognize it.
Sign in to YouTube
Sign in to YouTube
apeironishome 2 weeks ago
well you could probably refer to Noam Chomsky's entire body of work. or any one else who agree's with the value theory of labor. I just did a paper on Value, Price, Profit.
Sign in to YouTube
Sign in to YouTube