Top Comments
All Comments (293)
-
I bet Sarah absolutely LOVES Joni Mitchell. Just sayin.
-
@JDGFGE The reason it DOES matter who wrote it, is that it is a creation. Joni didn't have Sarah's advantage of hearing how it sounded, and deciding which songs to cover.
That's all right. Time will regard Sarah McLachlan as one of perhaps a dozen great singer-songwriters. But by any measure, Joni Mitchell would be at the top of that class. She and Carole King practically invented the genre.
-
junk
-
I love both Joni and Sarah's versions. Sarah has more melancholy (that's part of Sarah's overall style). Joni's is great as the original we all loved; it's like the Beatles they will always be the original and the best version of any song for most. I did have the great pleasure of posting a version from Cindy Alexander (winner of NBC's Star Tomorrow), which was posted on xmas day 2011.
Search YouTube for "River Cindy Alexander".
-
@atis377 It isn't her song.. It's Joni mitchel's.. Sarah just made a cover..
-
I'm partial to the Joni Mitchell version but this is very good.
-
@Jay435 ohyeeaaah! lol go canada <333
-
Sarah i love your song so good!!
-
Love it.. sad song so matter who wrote it, Sarah does a beautifil version of it.
-
@Janer369 I do; I think there's a YouTube video where she explains that to the audience. However, I'm not positive but I've always had the impression that her version was first. It's possible I'm mistaken, but I would still consider it HER song since she wrote it. =)
I don't know, but the way I feel right now, I really do wish I had a River, that I could skate away on!
BrianNeal 4 months ago 24
@BOSAHK LOL you musn't be Canadian, we skate on frozen rivers up here in winter. Oh yeah, we created hockey this way as well.
Jay435 3 months ago 9