Uploaded by ProfMTH on Jan 10, 2010
Some thoughts about dualism (and they are just some thoughts with recommendations to expert opinions) in response to a video by and a exchange of text comments I had with LegoDesi.
If you get an error message when trying to view the video, either hit the "HQ" button or, if that doesn't work, try adding &fmt=18 to the URL for the video. One or the other usually solves the problem -- whatever the problem is. Hello, YouTube, maybe this could be fixed?!
Links:
LegoDesi's "QualiaSoup's video lacks substance"--
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tuPi-OJqDn8
QualiaSoup's "Substance Dualism"--
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WsPn5dXfTvA
SisyphusRedeemed's video on mind-body dualism-
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=luRqU7e_gEw
My "What is God?" video--
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rmhVuOxuo_I
Also, Nykytine2, a favorite YouTuber of mine, did a nice video on this topic a while back:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O05wZCVcbeY&NR=1
Music: "Anybody Seen My Mind?" by Michael Franti
Category:
Tags:
- dualism
- mind
- body
- brain
- physical
- spirit
- immaterial
- mental
- material
- Legodesi
- substance
- QualiaSoup
- SisyphusRedeemed
- coherent
- value
- function
- state
- event
- psychological
- human
- nature
- matter
- emergent
- Descartes
- Leibniz
- Hobbes
- ghost
- simplicity
- faith
- reason
- Jesus
- Christ
- God
- Christian
- atheist
- agnostic
- theist
- philosophy
- evidence
- positive
- negative
- Occam's
- Razor
- yt:stretch=16:9
License:
Standard YouTube License
-
847 likes, 41 dislikes
Link to this comment:
Uploader Comments (ProfMTH)
All Comments (688)
-
@1:33,
Not necessarily. If there is a great mathematician who needs a calculator to perform complex calculations and algorithms, I'd contend that the calculator is an extension of his brain, but not of his mind. The mind is the information behind the brain, but it is not an anatomic synonym.
Rather than the mind and brain being either completely separate or completely synonymous, the brain and the mind are both distinct components of the same thing, like a vector or a complex number.
MegaAstrodude 3 days ago
-
@SangMarocain "is the Mind purely a function of the Brain ?"
Nobody knows for sure, but based on what we know about the brain's important functions and neuroscience, it seems that the mind is obviously only an affect that is given off by the brain. Just like how you cannot have sight without the eye, you cannot have mind without the brain.
theBartone9119 3 weeks ago
-
Is the concept of a computer made out of happiness incoherent? Then so is mind-body dualism.
Staunts 1 month ago
8:29
God Appointed Hitler? (The New Testament, Government, & Morality)by ProfMTH25,993 views
5:58
Babies in Hellby ProfMTH35,586 views
9:58
The Book of Job -- Part Twoby ProfMTH24,921 views
2:07
Brief Bible Blunders -- Episode #12by ProfMTH21,327 views
6:51
Sam Harris on The Illusion of Free Will -1/3by 10sodot51,771 views
4:25
Christianity Refutes Itselfby ProfMTH20,182 views
3:05
Brief Bible Blunders -- Episode #11by ProfMTH22,943 views
8:45
Defense of Substance Dualism against QualiaSoup, part 1by migkillertwo3,644 views
4:10
Jesus Cannot Be the Atonementby ProfMTH19,720 views
9:38
What is God?by ProfMTH26,457 views
2:10
The Mind-Body Problem: Three Thought Experimentsby SentiencePhysics7,435 views
9:46
Jesus Was Not the Messiah -- Part 3 (Crucifixion "Prophecies")by ProfMTH21,805 views
10:14
Jesus Was Not the Messiah -- Part Oneby ProfMTH53,873 views
10:30
Brain Evolution: The Accidental Mind (I)by pangeaprogressblog31,761 views
1:04:27
Evolution of Mind and Brainby Arizona13,644 views
9:58
God is love?by ProfMTH33,127 views
10:34
Questions for Biblical Inerrantists & Literalistsby ProfMTH18,678 views
4:06
Daniel Dennett on Deflating Consciousnessby LennyBound27,294 views
9:52
Philosophy of Mindby thepathlesspath6,492 views
7:47
Descartes - Meditations on First Philosophy (Preface to the Reader)by raphaelyaakov2,903 views
- Loading more suggestions...
Excellent!
poeticjustice2000 2 weeks ago
@poeticjustice2000 Thanks!
ProfMTH 2 weeks ago
The brain and mind are not the same thing, that doesn't mean that the mind can operate without the brain. I mean sight and eyes are not the same thing, but you still can't have sight without the eyes...
theBartone9119 3 weeks ago
@theBartone9119 What is your point?
ProfMTH 3 weeks ago
This video is a favorite on Massachusetts
nickolascook718 1 month ago
@nickolascook718 A favorite on Massachusetts?
ProfMTH 3 weeks ago