Answers to Six Sedevacantist Questions

TABLE OF CONTENTS

QUESTION 1: CAN A CATHOLIC CHRISTIAN ESTEEM FALSE RELIGIONS? (0:18)

QUESTION 2: ARE ANTI-CATHOLIC PROTESTANTS HERETICS? (1:46)

QUESTION 3: CAN A CATHOLIC REGARD THE EASTERN [QUOTE] ORTHODOX AS IN THE CHURCH? (3:23)

QUESTION 4: DOES THE CATHOLIC CHURCH TEACH THAT NON-CATHOLICS CAN RECEIVE HOLY COMMUNION? (4:16)

QUESTION 5: MUST THE EASTERN [QUOTE] ORTHODOX ACCEPT VATICAN I? (5:44)

QUESTION 6: DOES QUANTA CURA CONTRADICT DIGNITATIS HUMANAE? (6:15)


Apologetics Against Sedevacantism:

http://scripturecatholic.xanga.com/tags/traditionalism/

http://catholiclegate.blogspot.com

http://www.catholic-legate.com/Apologetics/Ultra-Traditionalism/Articles.aspx

http://www.catholic-legate.com/Apologetics/Ultra-Traditionalism/QandA.aspx

http://www.amazon.com/More-Catholic-Than-Pope-Traditionalism/dp/1931709262

Category:

Education

Tags:

• catholic
• church
• heresy
• manifest
• peter
• diamond
• brothers
• debate
• gnrhead
• Authentic
• Catholicism
• God
• Jesus
• Christ
• Counterfeit
• Love
• Hate
• Sedevacantism
• OneTrueChurch
• Glenn
• Glen
• Paleocrat
• Tradition
• Scripture
• Bible
• Mass
• Novus
• Ordo
• Latin
• Roman
• Cross

[elcamaras]

To all us real Catholics, the ones who accept all the teachings and doctrines of the Church, including Vatican II, here's what I propose. Let's all stop responding to, making videos about, and debating sedevacantists. They are so starved for attention that this little attention spurt we've been giving them is more than they deserve. Once we ignore them they will fall back into obscure irrelevancy where they belong. Sedevacantists are nothing more than armchair bishops. Oh, and heretics.

[SeptemberCatholic18]

@elcamaras That was everyone's original opinion, but after we lost OneTrueChurch and Paleocrat to them, we had to make a response. Eventually, we all decided to move on, and I for one will probably never make another Sedevacantism video. For the record, Paleocrat says he has changed his mind and is on his way back home to the Catholic Church. We must pray for OneTrueChurch.

[elcamaras]

@SeptemberCatholic18 What's that saying, "more Catholic than the pope". That is what they think are. Let's pray for OTC, but let's not respond to anything he says. Let him preach to his choir of other apostates. Sedevacantists are like protestants, each man is his own pope. As for paleocrat, I'll believe it when he makes a vid about it or removes his sede vids.

[SeptemberCatholic18]

@elcamaras I believe it. He messaged me, apologizing for his words, and says he is working on an apology to the Holy See. I'm sure he will soon remove them. He's probably working on a retraction video first before he removes anything.

Yes, I agree that we should ignore OTC's videos, although that is hard for me since his latest five-part series specifically addresses me. Also, there are two other Youtube users attacking me specifically, so I must pray for willpower to not respond.

[elcamaras]

@SeptemberCatholic18 I suggest you make a one-size-fits all vid basically summarizing your arguments against them all and expressly stating that it is your last vid on the subject. Otherwise you will get stuck in a perpetual back and forth w/ sedevacantists and you won't have time to make vids refuting protestant heresies. Last time I checked, evangelicals were drawing millions into heresy while sedevacantists drew in 2, OTC and paleo.

[SeptemberCatholic18]

@elcamaras That's been done. I've been done with these guys since before Easter. I have a couple summarizing vids already posted. I made a video making clear that I was done, then took it down after about two weeks when I was confident the message was conveyed.

[Z1GGYK3V]

Bless the Holy Roman Catholic Christian Church! Remember, words will not change the heart. Prayer will do just that, as it has been done to me when I was Protestant. I was debating with GodTowardSociety, he didn't open my eyes with words, but I saw that he was praying for me THROUGH his words and the love in them, I could see he has the Holy Spirit living with him, which made me come back home to the Catholic Church. Bless all Catholics around the world!

[SeptemberCatholic18]

@KC101X It contained some poorly worded statements and I couldn't bear to leave it up given that fact. Plus, that was during the time I was considering pulling all of my Sedevacantism videos down to prevent myself from giving the Sedes too much spotlight.

[xukeith33]

awesome!