Joe McElderry 'There's A Place For Us'
Uploader Comments (zaashleyfan)
Top Comments
-
i think both joe and carrie sound equally beautiful singing this song. love em both
All Comments (78)
-
@zaashleyfan Disney actually dropped out right after Prince Caspian. WaldenMedia then had a little pre-production just dumped on them and went on a partner hunt until they came across Fox. Then they made the movie from there.
-
@BigRedShinyGuitar If you're in the Western part of the world, you heard Carrie Underwood. If you're in Europe, you heard this guy. Same song either way.
-
This version has its strong moments, and Carrie's has its strong moments. I like them both just as much.
-
I don't know what you are all saying because Joe is amazing at this song!<3
One of my favourite songs he has sung!:] Simply Brilliant!<3
-
is this the one I heard in the credits of the movie?
-
@zaashleyfan Well they were wrong weren't they!
-
@JLSBTRTW1DESluver I'm not debating that Joe can't sing - he can just not this kind of music! I am simply comparing one version over the other. I prefer the original, that's it plain and simple. I like Joe singing the show tune type music he's been doing lately, he has a trained voice that has been designed for those songs. I never thought he was rubbish, in fact I backed him all the way through XFactor, but the sad fact is, is that the winners of that show rarely every go anywhere!
-
@sineadgrant1 joe mcelderry is 10x a better singer than carrie, people just dont like the fact that they all thought he'd be rubbish and they're wrong!
-
Joe you are AMAZING!
This movie wasn't Disney
RobHarm76 10 months ago
@RobHarm76 It was at the time of the making of this video. Disney sold it when they realised that it wasn't going to be a success.
zaashleyfan 10 months ago
rofl 1080 hp for this video is so overkill...at least i could stare at the poster
irongut12345 1 year ago
@irongut12345 I don't understand what that comment means. Care to explain?
zaashleyfan 1 year ago
Putting aside the fact that I am probably one of Joe's biggest fans, although it's inevitable, I don't think it fair for either version to be compared with one another. Both Joe & Carrie are amazing singers &, in my opinion, sing the song equally well. But what people have failed to consider is that this song was written by Carrie therefore it was written to match her vocals and style of singing. People haven't realized what a good job Joe has done considering this song was written for a woman.
zaashleyfan 1 year ago 33